Native Multimodal Large Models: Technical Route Comparison and Engineering Selection

    This article examines the technical differences between native multimodal large models and拼接式 (pipeline) approaches, analyzes the limitations of feature projection in long-chain reasoning and generation, and provides practical guidance for model selection. It evaluates several promising technical paths—including unified discrete tokenization, understanding-first design principles, and multimodal chain-of-thought—and uses 3D content generation as a concrete application case. The article concludes with a comparative scenario table and a framework for building multimodal evaluation systems.

    1. What Does “Native Multimodal” Mean?

    Native multimodal large models incorporate text, images, audio, video, and other modalities into a unified training objective from the training stage. The industry does not use this term with complete consistency; there are two main interpretations.

    The first interpretation is a unified training objective. From pretraining onward, data from all modalities jointly participate in learning. Even if vision or audio components still use separate encoders, as long as those encoders are trained jointly with the language backbone, the model can be considered native.

    The second interpretation goes further by completely eliminating separate encoders, allowing raw signals to pass directly into a single network through a unified representation. This approach demands significantly more data and compute, and is also harder to debug from an engineering perspective.

    The opposite approach is the pipeline-based (拼接式) solution. It uses a language model as the backbone; vision or audio signals are first processed by independent encoders to extract features, which are then mapped into the language model’s input space through a projection layer. This approach has lower training costs and faster iteration, but its multimodal capability is constrained by the information bottleneck of the projection layer.

    Understanding these two routes helps readers interpret what “native” means in papers and product descriptions.

    2. Limitations of Feature Projection

    2.1 Why Long-Chain Reasoning Is Affected

    A common two-step paradigm is to first train a feature extractor to obtain a feature space, then align modalities through a projection or adapter layer. On tasks such as image-text Q&A and simple descriptions, this paradigm performs reasonably well.

    Problems appear in multi-step reasoning. Language model reasoning is built on discrete token sequences, where each token has a clear boundary, can be combined, and can be progressively verified. Vision features are usually continuous, high-dimensional vectors with unclear semantic unit boundaries. When models perform multi-step reasoning on these features, common issues include:

    1. Reasoning chains break, and intermediate steps cannot be explicitly expressed or verified;
    2. Hallucinations increase—models tend to describe content that does not exist in the image;
    3. Fine-grained ability weakens—tasks such as spatial relations, counting, and precise attribute recognition become unstable.

    The severity of these problems depends heavily on task type, model scale, and training objectives. On some models, projected features already support long-chain reasoning quite well. For example, when the training data includes many fine-grained perception samples, the same projection structure shows noticeably better spatial reasoning. Therefore, the claim that “projection methods are unsuitable for reasoning” only holds under certain conditions and should not be treated as a universal rule.

    2.2 Imbalance Between Understanding and Generation

    Another common phenomenon is strong understanding but weak generation, or the opposite. Many models score well on image understanding benchmarks, but when asked to generate structured content from an image—such as runnable front-end code or precise 3D scene descriptions—the quality drops markedly.

    Some argue that understanding and generation do not naturally lead to each other, and therefore require dedicated architectural and training-objective design. Others believe that scaling up data and parameters can still mitigate the problem. Currently, neither view has unified experimental conclusions; teams should base their choices on their own evaluation results.

    3. Technical Routes Worth Prioritizing

    Several ideas have been publicly discussed in the industry and deserve early evaluation.

    3.1 Unified Discrete Representation

    One route is to convert vision and audio signals into discrete sequences that are isomorphic to text tokens, allowing all modalities to share the same autoregressive or hybrid modeling framework. Benefits include:

    • Cross-modal reasoning chains can be written as token sequences, making intermediate steps easier to verify and trace;
    • The training objective is unified, reducing catastrophic forgetting in multi-stage training;
    • Understanding and generation connect within the same model, leading to a simpler structure.

    Discretization also has a cost. After an image is divided into discrete codebook tokens, subtle textures, color gradients, and precise geometric relationships can be lost; the same goes for audio timbre and prosody. There is a trade-off among codebook size, resolution, and compression rate.

    Thus, discretization should be treated as one of several paths to evaluate, not the only answer. Continuous representations generally preserve details better, but their reasoning chains are harder to make explicit. If the task emphasizes fine-grained perception—such as industrial quality inspection or medical image analysis—continuous representations paired with a strong vision encoder may be more suitable. If the task emphasizes explainable multi-step reasoning and unified generation/understanding, the discrete route is worth trying.

    3.2 Understanding-First Design Principle

    At the architecture level, it is advisable to prioritize representation quality on the understanding side. The rationale is an empirical observation: when understanding-side features are unreliable, training on the generation side cannot easily compensate for the foundational defect. In practice, the following principles can guide design:

    • Keep enough spatial and semantic detail in the vision encoder, avoiding premature compression;
    • Include training data that requires precise perception, such as OCR, chart understanding, and spatial reasoning, to drive representation learning;
    • Introduce reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards to constrain perception and reasoning through task outcomes.

    This principle also carries risk. Over-emphasizing the understanding side may lead to insufficient generation-side training, eventually causing noticeable weaknesses in generation tasks. Teams should build joint evaluation sets for both understanding and generation, and use ablation studies to confirm the contribution of each module, rather than looking at only one side.

    3.3 Combining Reasoning Chains with Multimodality

    Extending the chain-of-thought mechanism to multimodal scenarios is a low-cost experiment. Before giving a final answer, the model first describes its understanding of the image in text. This forces visual representations to pass through the explicit verification of language, making errors more visible.

    Some studies report that, in certain tasks and evaluation setups, this approach may reduce hallucination rates. But results depend on the specific task, model scale, and evaluation criteria, and cannot be directly generalized to all scenarios. Before adopting it, teams should first define how hallucinations are measured—for example, checking each description against image content item by item—and compare the difference with and without textual restatement on the same evaluation set.

    4. Application Practice: 3D Content Generation

    A typical use case for multimodal capabilities is 3D modeling. A user uploads an image or a text description, and the model produces a usable 3D asset. The full technical chain roughly consists of four stages:

    1. Perception and understanding: identify the geometric structure and material attributes of objects in the input;
    2. Geometry generation: generate topologically valid 3D meshes or implicit representations;
    3. Texture and material: generate renderable maps and PBR materials;
    4. Engineering delivery: output asset files that conform to mainstream toolchain formats.

    When evaluating such capabilities, the following acceptance checks can be used:

    • Geometric consistency: from multiple viewpoints, is the model structure coherent, without obvious misalignment or interpenetration?
    • Controllability: can size, proportions, and local details be adjusted through parameters or subsequent editing?
    • Topology and polygon count: can the mesh be used in real-time rendering or subsequent editing? Does the polygon count meet the target platform’s constraints?
    • UV unwrap quality: are seams placed reasonably? Is there obvious texture stretching?
    • PBR material completeness: does it output base color, normal, roughness, metallic, and other channels?
    • Export compatibility: can common formats be correctly read by the target toolchain?

    At the product level, the source of capabilities and promotional messaging also need attention. Some products integrate third-party generation capabilities and present them as feature highlights. If the messaging is not clear, users may question the true source of the capability, which can affect overall trust in the product. Teams should clearly distinguish platform-native capabilities, third-party integrated capabilities, and self-developed model capabilities in marketing materials, so users know exactly what they are using.

    5. Technical Selection Recommendations

    How to Define the Boundary Between Understanding-Oriented and Generation-Oriented Tasks?

    Understanding-oriented and generation-oriented tasks have different architectural requirements. Understanding tasks focus on perception accuracy and reasoning stability, while generation tasks emphasize output quality and controllability. When selecting a model, do not expect a single solution to achieve the best results on both types of tasks.

    The table below provides a rough comparison across three scenarios:

    Dimension Understanding Tasks General Generation Tasks 3D Generation Tasks
    Typical input/output Image + question → text answer Text or image → image, code, or text Image or text → mesh, texture, material files
    Key metrics Accuracy, hallucination rate, fine-grained recognition Generation quality, instruction following, structural correctness Geometric consistency, topology quality, UV and material completeness
    Compute cost Medium; mainly inference Medium to high; depends on generation steps and resolution High; multi-view generation and post-processing are time-consuming
    Main risks Hallucination, missed detection Structural errors, style drift Interpenetration, polygon count exceeding limits, export format incompatibility

    How to Build a Multimodal Evaluation System?

    Detecting multimodal hallucinations is harder than in text-only settings, because verifying whether a description matches an image often requires human judgment or a stronger model. The following steps are recommended:

    1. Build separate evaluation sets for each task type, covering common and edge cases;
    2. Establish clear criteria for hallucination, and periodically re-sample for review;
    3. Automate the evaluation pipeline, running regression tests after each model or data change;
    4. Record both understanding and generation metrics, and review them together to avoid one-sided conclusions.