2026 AI Coding Tools Tested: Building a Full E-Commerce Site from Scratch
This article presents a reusable framework for comparing AI coding tools using one unified task: building a 10-page e-commerce shopping site from 0 to 1 with a component-based frontend framework. It explains how to control evaluation variables (unified prompt, clean environment, and consistent error-feedback process), turns subjective impressions into a six-dimension weighted scoring system with two veto rules, and profiles four categories of AI coding tools by capability. It then breaks down the most common failure patterns (nested directories, non-converging runtime errors, visual inconsistencies, empty-shell structures, and mock-data coupling) with concrete fixes, and proposes a four-phase hardening workflow to take AI-generated code from prototype to production. The key takeaway is to combine tools by project stage rather than chase a single all-in-one tool, backed by clear prompt contracts, a multi-dimensional scoring system, and disciplined engineering standards.
1. Introduction: A complete project is the real test of an AI coding tool
When people discuss AI-assisted programming, the comparisons usually focus on completion speed, single-file generation quality, and response latency. But for enterprises and individual developers alike, the real production challenge is different: whether a tool can take a single requirement and reliably deliver a complete system that runs, stays maintainable, and is ready to ship.
By 2026, AI coding tools have matured into several distinct forms: coding assistants embedded in cloud consoles or developer platforms, agentic coding tools that plan and execute autonomously, multi-agent collaboration modes, and enterprise-grade code assistants built around team development workflows.
The most common mistake when choosing a tool is inferring “whole-project delivery capability” from “single-snippet generation experience.” This article uses one unified task—building a 10-page e-commerce shopping site—to answer three questions: how to design the task, how to evaluate the tools, and how to harden the output. The result is a reusable comparison framework and a practical methodology.
2. Evaluation design: one task, one prompt, one standard
A fair comparison requires controlling variables across three areas:
- Unified input: the same prompt and the same requirements document, with no special treatment for any single tool;
- Unified environment: starting from zero in a clean working directory, with no scaffolding pre-installed;
- Unified process: feeding the same errors back to each tool for fixes in the same way, while recording the number of fix rounds and any human intervention.
2.1 Task goals and page list
The task is to “build an e-commerce site from 0 to 1” using a component-based frontend framework. The site contains 10 pages:
| # | Page | Core elements | Main challenges |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Home (product list) | Product cards, category filter, search, pagination | Placeholder images, loading and empty states |
| 2 | Product detail | Main image, price, specs, stock, add to cart | Data consistency with the list page |
| 3 | Checkout | Shipping info, payment method, total summary | Form validation, amount calculation |
| 4 | Purchase success | Order summary, next-step actions | Passing data through from the order result |
| 5 | Login | Account/password, error messages | Sharing login state across pages |
| 6 | Register | Nickname, email, password, confirm password | Multi-field validation rules |
| 7 | User center - overview | Profile info, order and wallet entries | Dependence on login state |
| 8 | User center - orders | Order list, status filter | Data flowing back after an order |
| 9 | User center - wallet (coupons) | Balance, coupons, used and expired states | Coordination with the purchase flow |
| 10 | User center - settings | Profile edit, password change, address management | Form reuse and submission feedback |
This task was chosen because it exercises the core capabilities of AI coding tools within a short cycle:
- Multi-file collaboration: 10 pages means coordinated generation of routing, components, styles, and data files;
- State continuity: cart, login state, orders, and coupons depend on each other; if any link breaks, the site cannot work end to end;
- Front-to-back consistency: navigation, color scheme, component style, and interaction feedback must stay consistent across every page.
2.2 Breaking down the three core challenges
The completeness and overall consistency of the site are the core difficulty. It can be broken into three observable sub-problems:
- Coverage: are all 10 pages implemented, are routes reachable, and are pages linked to each other;
- Consistency: are the navigation structure, visual style, component styles, and interaction feedback unified;
- Continuity: do the data chains hold together—cart → checkout → success page → order page, and login state → user center → wallet.
These map to “does it run,” “does it look like a real product,” and “is the logic self-consistent.” Only when all three hold can the site be considered truly built from 0 to 1.
2.3 Prompt template: define the contract before writing code
In practice, a large share of “poor generation quality” problems stem from vague requirements. An input like “make a shopping website” leaves the model free to invent the page scope, tech stack, and data structures, so results naturally vary. The template below makes the requirements explicit as a set of contracts:
[Role] You are a senior frontend architect responsible for the complete delivery of an e-commerce storefront from 0 to 1.[Goal] Build a runnable frontend shopping site with the following 10 pages:Home (product list), Product detail, Checkout, Purchase success, Login, Register,User center - overview, User center - orders, User center - wallet (coupons), User center - settings.[Technical constraints]- Use a component-based, declarative frontend framework with built-in routing and global state management;- Use a statically typed language; do not scatter untyped dynamic props across components;- Layer the code: pages / components / hooks / context / services / data / styles;- All product, order, and coupon data comes from local mock data, accessed through a unified data layer.[Page contract]- For each page, specify: route path, required data, triggering actions, navigation targets, empty and error states;- Extract the nav bar, footer, and user-center sidebar as shared components; do not rewrite them per page.[Design contract]- The primary color comes from the brand primary (e.g. #2563eb); the accent color (e.g. #dc2626) is used only for warnings;- Define colors, spacing, radius, and shadows with CSS variables; do not hardcode color values in components;- Body text/background contrast >= 4.5:1; interactive elements >= 3:1;- Mobile-first, with no horizontal overflow at the 375px/768px/1280px breakpoints.[Data contract]- Define unified data structures for products, orders, and coupons, with prices as integer units in cents;- Use a type-safe placeholder image component: render a solid color plus icon at a fixed aspect ratio; no broken images.[Quality contract]- Do not generate empty-shell files; every directory/module must contain a real implementation;- Self-check before delivery: complete routing, working form validation, cart and login state synced across pages, zero type-check errors;- On delivery, output: the file structure tree, a page-to-route mapping table, and a known-limitations list.[Output constraints]- Create files only within the current working directory; do not nest a same-named directory;- For each step, first explain which files change and why, then write the code.
The value of this template is making implicit requirements explicit. The type, design, and data contracts turn consistency from “a matter of feel” into “something checkable,” so many evaluation dimensions later on can be verified directly against this prompt.
3. Evaluation dimensions and scoring system
Around these challenges, subjective experience can be converted into a quantifiable scoring system. Evaluate across six dimensions, each worth 10 points, weighted into a total:
| Dimension | Weight | What to check | How to collect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Completeness | 25% | Whether all 10 pages are implemented with reachable routes and can link to each other | Walk the page-to-route table and check off each item |
| Runnability | 20% | Whether it starts directly, whether the build passes, number of errors on first run | Record error counts across the start, build, and fix stages |
| Consistency | 15% | Whether navigation, color scheme, component style, and interaction feedback are unified | Check against the design contract and compare screenshots |
| Code quality | 15% | Whether layering is clear, types are complete, mock data is decoupled from components | Directory review, static checks, manual walkthrough |
| Interaction & debugging efficiency | 15% | Generation speed, number of fix rounds after errors, whether heavy manual rework is needed | Record generation time, fix rounds, share of lines changed manually |
| Responsive & usability | 10% | Whether mobile adapts, whether contrast meets standards | Screenshots at three breakpoints, contrast-tool checks |
The scoring rule should not be a simple weighted sum. Add two veto items:
- Cannot start: judged an outright fail. A project that does not run has no delivery value, however good it looks;
- Dense consistency problems (e.g. 3 or more): the total is capped at 60 points, because the fix cost often exceeds the cost of a rewrite.
In addition, run the same prompt at least 3 times to observe output stability, since large-model generation has inherent randomness. A single run reflects the ceiling; multiple runs are closer to the real experience.
4. Capability profiles of four categories of AI coding tools
By product form, AI coding tools on the market fall into roughly four categories. The following discusses capability characteristics only, not specific products.
- General-purpose integrated type: typically coding assistants from cloud vendors or large internet companies, usually delivered as plugins in mainstream editors or as standalone IDEs.
- Strengths: friendly interaction, low learning curve, first generation often works in one pass;
- Weaknesses: project architecture tends to be simple, mock data is coupled with page logic, so later extension and maintenance costs are higher.
- End-to-end agentic coding type: works by “given a goal, plan autonomously, modify multiple files, run and debug,” with a UI that generally follows mainstream AI editor conventions and usually offers privacy-mode toggles.
- Strengths: suited to building complete projects from zero, with autonomous repair ability;
- Weaknesses: relatively slow generation, first-pass code may contain errors, insufficient polish on details such as component color scheme and style consistency.
- Multi-agent orchestration type: splits tasks across multiple specialized agents, for example one for fast generation and one for planning and decomposing complex tasks. Baidu AI Cloud’s coding tool belongs to this category, with its Zulu mode focused on rapid development and its Architect mode focused on planning and handling complex tasks.
- Strengths: stronger decomposition and controllability for complex tasks;
- Weaknesses: generation style and response speed differ between modes, and choosing a mode has a learning cost; when output from multiple agents is mixed in one project, structural conflicts and style inconsistency can easily appear.
- Enterprise-grade code assistant type: focused on code completion, code review, and knowledge-base Q&A, tightly integrated with code hosting, continuous integration, and compliance auditing.
- Strengths: good at localized optimization and standardization within an existing codebase, suited to unifying team development standards;
- Weaknesses: relatively limited long-chain, end-to-end closed-loop capability; the 0-to-1 new-project experience is usually worse than that of dedicated coding agents.
4.1 Comparison framework
The table below summarizes the typical behavior of different tool forms, which you can use as a reference when choosing:
| Dimension | General-purpose integrated | End-to-end agentic coding | Multi-agent orchestration |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-run success rate | High, often works in one pass | Medium, often needs several fix rounds | Depends on the chosen mode, high variance |
| Page completeness | All 10 pages basically present | Fairly complete | Noticeable differences between modes |
| Visual & interaction consistency | Consistent style but simple pages | Rich detail info but insufficient polish | More complete overall, but style may be inconsistent |
| Project architecture & code quality | Simple layering, mock data coupled with components | Layering awareness, but reserved directories are often empty shells | Strong planning, generation quality depends on mode |
| Responsive behavior | Basic adaptation, some pages may distort | Some pages lack mobile adaptation | Depends on completeness of task planning |
| Generation & iteration speed | Fast | Slower | Depends on the chosen mode |
| Debugging loop | Lightweight fixes | Can read errors and fix autonomously | Fix effectiveness depends on mode and task complexity |
| Best-fit scenario | Rapid prototypes, personal projects | Building from 0 to 1, iterating small-to-medium projects | Decomposing complex requirements, planning larger projects |
This table reveals an important pattern: the weak spots of different tools are not identical—they are complementary.
- General-purpose integrated tools win on “fast and stable,” quickly producing a usable starting point, but with simple architecture;
- End-to-end agentic coding tools win on “complete and deep,” covering a fuller chain, but needing more debugging rounds;
- Multi-agent orchestration tools win on “planning and control,” suited to breaking down complex requirements before delivery.
So the mature approach is not to find one “all-capable tool,” but to combine tools by project stage.
5. Typical problems and fixes in testing
Measured against the scoring system, the problems most often exposed when generating a complete site from 0 to 1 fall into six categories. Analyzing them is more valuable than memorizing any single tool’s performance.
5.1 Completeness: nested directories and “won’t start”
Some tools generated files with a nested same-named directory—an outer directory with the same name as an inner subdirectory—which scrambled import paths and left the project unable to start. This usually comes from two things: first, the tool misunderstood the project root; second, it followed the “new project” habit and created another layer using the directory as the project name.
The fix has three steps:
- Clarify the working directory, requiring “create files only in the current directory”;
- Establish a start-up check: immediately run build and dev-start commands after each generation, and feed the full error output back to the tool;
- If errors are concentrated at the path level, ask the tool to rearrange the directory structure and unify import paths directly, rather than patching them one by one.
5.2 Runnability: recurring errors and non-converging fixes
Another common symptom is that the first-pass code starts, but pages throw runtime errors on open, and it takes several fix rounds to see the full effect. This usually means the tool lacks a “verify immediately after generation” loop. AI-generated code is often syntactically correct, but runtime issues—data shape, async timing, null handling—only surface when it actually runs.
The recommended engineering practice is an incremental “change a little, run a little” rhythm: first generate the routing skeleton and one page and get it running, then progressively add the rest. Handle one error at a time and provide the full stack trace, avoiding multiple simultaneous problems that interfere with each other’s fixes.
5.3 Visual consistency: placeholder images, white-on-white text, and poor color choices
Testing consistently surfaced three visual defects:
- All images are placeholders, hurting both the look and the content expression of pages;
- White buttons with white text, making the button labels invisible;
- Layouts that do not adapt on mobile, with some pages distorting.
The root cause is that AI tends to “get functionality running first,” pushing visual details down the priority list. A deeper cause is the lack of a unified design contract:
- Colors are not managed through centralized variables; each component picks its own values;
- Image assets have no placeholder scheme, so only basic placeholders are used.
The fix is to move visual constraints forward into the prompt, including:
- Defining the boundaries for the brand primary and accent colors;
- Requiring CSS variables to manage design variables uniformly;
- Requiring contrast to meet standards;
- Establishing a placeholder-image convention (fixed aspect ratio, solid or gradient background plus an icon, replaced with the real image after load) to avoid layout shift at the source.
Also fold “multi-breakpoint screenshot verification” into the acceptance checklist, checking item by item with screenshots rather than relying on the naked eye.
5.4 Code quality: empty-shell structures and mock-data coupling
Two code-quality problems are most worth watching:
The first is the “empty-shell structure.” The output shows directories like hooks and context, but the files inside are nearly empty—common engineering directories are merely “reserved” as placeholders. This looks standard but has no real maintainability. The AI is imitating a generic project template without understanding what each module should be responsible for.
The second is “mock-data coupling.” Data such as product lists and details is hardcoded directly in page components, so switching to real APIs would require rewriting almost every page.
The countermeasure is “interface first”:
- Define the data-access-layer contract first, then let pages depend only on the contract;
- Set mandatory requirements for empty-shell modules, such as “every module under a directory must have a real implementation or a clear TODO note”;
- Add a “do any empty-implementation files exist” check to the acceptance checklist.
Example code:
// src/types/index.ts — shared data structures for the whole siteexport interface Product {id: string;name: string;priceCents: number; // prices are always in cents to avoid floating-point errorsstock: number;category: string;cover: string; // placeholder image identifier, replaced with a real URL laterdescription: string;specs: { label: string; value: string }[];}export interface CartItem {productId: string;quantity: number;}export interface Order {id: string;items: CartItem[];totalCents: number;status: 'paid' | 'shipped' | 'completed';createdAt: string;}export interface Coupon {id: string;title: string;amountCents: number;expireAt: string; // ISO date stringused: boolean;}export interface UserProfile {nickname: string;email: string;balanceCents: number;}
// src/services/productRepository.ts — data-access contract and mock implementationimport type { Product } from '../types';export interface ProductQuery {page: number;pageSize: number;keyword?: string;category?: string;}export interface ProductRepository {list(query: ProductQuery): Promise<{ items: Product[]; total: number }>;detail(id: string): Promise<Product | null>;}export function createMockProductRepository(seed: Product[]): ProductRepository {return {async list(query) {const keyword = (query.keyword ?? '').trim().toLowerCase();const filtered = seed.filter((p) => {const hitKeyword = !keyword || p.name.toLowerCase().includes(keyword);const hitCategory = !query.category || p.category === query.category;return hitKeyword && hitCategory;});const start = (query.page - 1) * query.pageSize;return { items: filtered.slice(start, start + query.pageSize), total: filtered.length };},async detail(id) {return seed.find((p) => p.id === id) ?? null;},};}
Pages depend only on the ProductRepository interface. Later, implementing a same-named class backed by real APIs and swapping the injection requires no changes to page code. That is the replaceability that “interface first” brings.
5.5 Systematic governance of consistency: route tables and design tokens
Beyond fixing issues point by point, consistency should be governed at the mechanism level. Navigation, routing, and permission checks can all be driven by a single route table, avoiding per-page navigation logic:
// src/router/routes.ts — the route table is the single source of truth for the page listexport type PageKey =| 'home' | 'productDetail' | 'checkout' | 'purchaseSuccess'| 'login' | 'register'| 'userDashboard' | 'userOrders' | 'userWallet' | 'userSettings';export interface RouteMeta {key: PageKey;path: string;requiresAuth: boolean;navLabel?: string; // only shown in the main nav when present}export const routes: RouteMeta[] = [{ key: 'home', path: '/', requiresAuth: false, navLabel: 'Home' },{ key: 'productDetail', path: '/product/:id', requiresAuth: false },{ key: 'checkout', path: '/checkout', requiresAuth: true, navLabel: 'Cart' },{ key: 'purchaseSuccess', path: '/purchase/success', requiresAuth: true },{ key: 'login', path: '/login', requiresAuth: false, navLabel: 'Login' },{ key: 'register', path: '/register', requiresAuth: false },{ key: 'userDashboard', path: '/user', requiresAuth: true, navLabel: 'User Center' },{ key: 'userOrders', path: '/user/orders', requiresAuth: true },{ key: 'userWallet', path: '/user/wallet', requiresAuth: true },{ key: 'userSettings', path: '/user/settings', requiresAuth: true },];
The nav bar is generated automatically from navLabel, and the user-center sidebar is generated automatically from the user key prefix. The permission guard only needs to check requiresAuth uniformly: an unauthenticated visit redirects to the login page, then returns to the original address after a successful login. Adding a page then means appending one row to the table, and the site structure stays consistent by nature.
The visual layer works the same way. Design variables such as colors, spacing, radius, and shadows are all consolidated into CSS variables, and components only reference the variables rather than writing color values directly:
/* src/styles/tokens.css — the single source of design variables for the whole site */:root {--color-brand: #2563eb;--color-accent: #dc2626;--color-bg: #f5f7fa;--color-surface: #ffffff;--color-text: #1f2937;--color-text-muted: #6b7280;--color-border: #e5e7eb;--space-1: 4px;--space-2: 8px;--space-3: 16px;--space-4: 24px;--radius-md: 8px;--shadow-card: 0 1px 3px rgba(15, 23, 42, 0.08);}
With design variables, changing the theme color or adjusting the radius means editing one place, which also eliminates at the root the chaos of “the same accent color appearing in several near-identical values on different pages.” One important reminder: color combinations that fail contrast must be checked before submission—this is the problem most easily overlooked in the prototype stage, yet the one that most affects usability after launch.
6. From prototype to product: a four-phase hardening workflow
AI can quickly produce a “skeleton,” but rarely a “product” in one shot. It helps to divide the collaboration into four phases, each with a clear exit criterion.
Phase 1: Skeleton
First have the tool generate the route table, shared layouts, shared components, and design variables. The exit criterion is that the project starts, the home page renders a basic layout, and the remaining pages show placeholder content.
- Manual checkpoints: is the working directory correct, are there any nested same-named directories, does the build pass.
Phase 2: Page population
Generate pages in the order home → detail → checkout → success → login/register → user center, advancing one page at a time and requiring the data contract to be updated in sync. This confines errors to a single page and makes them easy to locate. The exit criterion is that all 10 pages are reachable and each has loading, empty, and error states.
- Manual checkpoints: are placeholder images unified, does form validation work.
Phase 3: Flow continuity
Chain the cart, login state, orders, and coupons into a closed loop, and verify these two main flows:
- Login → browse → add to cart → checkout → success page → order page;
- Wallet balance or coupon deduction → order amount changes → order status flows back.
Take the cart as an example: the total should be computed in a single pure function so unit tests can cover it easily:
import type { CartItem, Product } from '../types';export function cartTotalCents(items: CartItem[], productMap: Record<string, Product>): number {return items.reduce((sum, item) => {const product = productMap[item.productId];return product ? sum + product.priceCents * item.quantity : sum;}, 0);}
Login state is best managed through unified session state, together with a unified route guard for unauthenticated access. A common detail defect is “no return after login”: a user redirected from a protected page to the login page stays on the login page after logging in, breaking the flow. Adding “return to the original target page after a successful login” to the prompt significantly improves this.
The exit criterion is that both main flows run end to end without blockage, with cross-page state kept consistent.
Phase 4: Engineering hardening
Complete type checking, unit tests, the production build, and quality gates, and fill in accessibility, error handling, and logging. Example code:
// Form validation rules (illustrative)const rules = {email: { required: true, pattern: /^[^\s@]+@[^\s@]+\.[^\s@]+$/ },password: { required: true, minLength: 8, pattern: /(?=.*[A-Za-z])(?=.*\d).{8,}/ },confirmPassword: { required: true, match: 'password' },};
#!/usr/bin/env bash# ci/quality-gate.sh — illustrative quality-gate scriptset -euo pipefailrun() { echo "==> $1"; shift; "$@"; }# 1. Static checks and type checksrun "lint" npm run lintrun "type-check" npm run type-check# 2. Unit tests (recommended to cover cart total, form validation, order status transitions)run "unit-test" npm test# 3. Production build, ensuring it is publishablerun "build" npm run build# 4. Key-flow acceptance (login → browse → checkout → success page)run "e2e-smoke" npm run test:e2e -- --grep @smoke
For launch, static assets can be stored in object storage with a content delivery network for acceleration. Parts that need server-side capability can deploy business services on a container platform, handle asynchronous tasks such as orders through a message queue, and connect to log services and monitoring/alerting for observability.
Security must hold the line: mock data cannot replace authentication and validation on real APIs; business logic such as orders, payments, and coupons must be re-validated on the server; never hardcode any key or credential in frontend code; and handle user personal information and account data under the principle of least necessity.
7. Selection guidance: combine by scenario, don’t chase “all-in-one”
| Use case | Recommended choice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Validating an idea quickly, small personal projects | General-purpose integrated | Fast to start, high first-pass rate, quickly yields a usable prototype |
| Building a complete application from 0 to 1 | End-to-end agentic coding | Covers multiple files and pages, with autonomous debugging |
| Decomposing complex requirements, planning large projects | Multi-agent orchestration | Strong planning, suited to breaking requirements down before execution |
| Optimizing and standardizing an existing codebase | Enterprise-grade code assistant | Tightly integrated with dev workflows, code hosting, and CI |
For most teams, a more pragmatic strategy is to combine them:
- Use general-purpose integrated tools to validate product form quickly;
- Use end-to-end agentic coding tools to build and iterate the core features;
- Use multi-agent orchestration modes for complex cross-module changes;
- Use enterprise-grade code assistants to unify team standards and hold the code-quality line.
It is worth emphasizing that tools are only amplifiers; prompt quality, acceptance standards, and engineering conventions determine whether the final output can actually land. On Baidu AI Cloud’s Qianfan platform, enterprises can build code-generation and code-review agents for their own development scenarios on top of general-purpose models, and combine them with Baidu AI Cloud capabilities such as object storage, container services, log services, and monitoring/alerting to bring AI coding into a complete development and operations system.
8. Conclusion
Using “building a 10-page e-commerce site from 0 to 1” as the unified evaluation task, each category of AI coding tool shows its own strengths and weaknesses:
- General-purpose integrated tools are friendly and stable on first generation, but architecturally simple;
- End-to-end agentic coding tools complete a fuller chain, but need more debugging rounds;
- Multi-agent orchestration tools plan strongly, but may conflict in generation style.
Rather than agonizing over “which tool is strongest,” it is better to build a methodology of “prompts with explicit contracts + a multi-dimensional scoring system + a phased hardening workflow.” Only by placing AI’s generation capability inside a verifiable, iterable, and maintainable engineering framework can AI coding truly become a reliable productivity boost for R&D.
