LLM Selection and Quota Management: Practical Guide for Math Reasoning and Code Review Tasks
A practical guide to selecting large language models for engineering teams. Learn how to define evaluation criteria, build your own test sets, organize models into tiers with task routing, manage quota pools with alerts and circuit breakers, and run structured reviews for math reasoning and code review workloads.
1. Define Evaluation Criteria Before Choosing a Model
Before selecting a model, you need a clear definition of “good.” Judging by a single demo often leads to misjudgment. Evaluate models along four dimensions:
- Output quality: Are conclusions correct, and can reasoning steps be verified line by line?
- Response speed: First-token latency and full completion time per call.
- Long-context retention: Does the model still remember constraints set early in the conversation after multiple turns?
- Cost: Per-call cost based on actual input and output tokens.
Output quality usually gets the most attention, but for engineering teams, the rework caused by long-context forgetting is often more expensive, so it should be evaluated separately.
1.1 Build Your Team’s Own Test Set
Third-party benchmarks are only a reference, because their task distribution may not match your codebase and business scenarios. Prepare a fixed set of test samples and re-run them regularly. Aim for 20 to 50 samples per task type, covering simple, medium, and complex difficulty levels.
Record the results in a table like this:
| Task Type | Sample Count | Accuracy | Avg. Response Time | Cost per Call | Acceptance Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Math proofs | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Code review | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Unit test generation | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Documentation cleanup | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
Every test run should record the model name, version, test date, and parameter settings. Without this information, you cannot compare future results against previous ones.
1.2 How to Calculate Cost
Models in different tiers have different unit prices and output limits, so cost cannot be estimated with a single rough multiplier. Most providers charge more for output than input tokens; check the official pricing page for exact numbers.
The cost of a single call is:
Cost per call = input tokens × input price + output tokens × output price
The total cost of a task also depends on the number of calls and the extra consumption caused by retries:
Total task cost = cost per call × number of calls × (1 + retry rate)
2. Model Tiers and Task Routing
Split your available models into three tiers, each mapped to a class of tasks. The table below is a starting template; the actual grouping should be based on your own test results.
| Tier | Suitable Tasks | Typical Use | Budget Cap | Acceptance Metrics | Re-test Cycle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | Hard math reasoning, architecture reviews, core algorithms | Tasks whose conclusions require human verification | Approved per project | Accuracy, verifiability of derivations | Quarterly |
| Tier 2 | Code review, complex refactoring suggestions | Gating before merging into the main branch | Fixed weekly quota | False positive rate, false negative rate | Every two months |
| Tier 3 | Code completion, unit tests, documentation, daily Q&A | High-frequency, low-risk tasks | Daily quota | Pass rate, response time | Quarterly |
2.1 Routing Rules
When a task enters the system, route it in this order:
- Does the result affect a production release or a formal conclusion? If yes, assign it to Tier 1 or Tier 2 and mark it as requiring human review.
- Can the task be split into independent subtasks? If yes, delegate fine-grained generation to Tier 3 and integrate the results in the main session.
- Is the task exploratory or non-urgent batch processing? If yes, route it to a restricted channel and execute it when quota is available.
2.2 Acceptance and Fallback in a Master-Worker Architecture
In a master-worker setup, the main model handles planning, task decomposition, and final integration, while lighter models handle the actual generation. To prevent errors from lower-tier models from reaching the main branch, enforce these rules:
- Subtask output must pass automated checks first, such as compilation, unit tests, and static analysis.
- The main model spot-checks subtask results. Set the sampling rate based on risk; high-risk modules should be checked in full.
- If the same subtask fails twice, escalate it to the next tier up and redo it.
- If it still fails after escalation, hand it off to a human, and add the failed sample to the test set for the next re-test round.
3. Quota Pools, Alerts, and Circuit Breakers
3.1 Tiered Quota Pools
Split the team’s total quota into three pools: a high-priority pool for release-related tasks, a normal pool for daily development, and an exploration pool for experiments and batch tasks. The exploration pool is automatically disabled when remaining quota falls below 60%.
Here is an example configuration; the values only illustrate the structure:
quota:total_budget: 1000000 # Total token budget for this cycle (example value)pools:high_priority:share: 0.5allowed_tiers: [1, 2]normal:share: 0.35allowed_tiers: [2, 3]exploration:share: 0.15allowed_tiers: [3]disable_below_ratio: 0.6
3.2 Alerts and Degradation Logic
Set alert thresholds at 40%, 60%, and 80%, triggering three actions in turn: a reminder, pausing exploration tasks, and allowing only high-priority tasks. Pseudocode:
def check_quota(used, total):ratio = used / totalif ratio >= 0.8:set_mode("high_priority_only")notify("80% of quota used; only high-priority tasks allowed")elif ratio >= 0.6:disable_pool("exploration")notify("60% of quota used; exploration tasks paused")elif ratio >= 0.4:notify("40% of quota used; monitor remaining consumption")
These thresholds only provide early warnings. With many concurrent requests, several requests may exceed the quota between two checks. Therefore, reserve quota based on estimated token counts before submitting a request:
def submit(task, estimated_tokens):if reserved + used + estimated_tokens > total:return reject(task)reserved += estimated_tokensreturn enqueue(task)
3.3 Circuit Breakers and Interrupt Recovery
Open the circuit breaker and pause new calls when any of the following occurs:
- A single task consumes more than twice its estimate.
- The same session fails three consecutive calls.
- The hourly consumption rate exceeds three times the cycle average.
Task interruptions carry two risks. First, unsaved intermediate results may be lost when a task stops midway. Second, re-running the task consumes quota again. Every long-running task should therefore save checkpoints periodically and resume from the most recent checkpoint instead of starting over.
3.4 Overnight and Weekend Jobs
Overnight full regression tests and offline builds can run in two modes: full speed when quota is sufficient, and a low-speed, single-threaded mode when quota is tight, ensuring the job eventually completes.
night_job:full_speed:condition: quota_ratio < 0.4concurrency: 4backup_run:condition: quota_ratio >= 0.4concurrency: 1tier: 3checkpoint_every_minutes: 10
The backup run is slow and may exceed the overnight window. The next morning, check the job status first, confirm the results are complete, and then decide whether a re-run is needed.
4. Checklists for Math Reasoning and Code Review
4.1 Math Reasoning
- Require the model to output full derivation steps, not just conclusions.
- For key lemmas, verify independently with another model or a human.
- Cross-check citations against authoritative references or established theorem libraries. Do not accept references generated by the model itself.
- For propositions not covered by existing material, treat conclusions as hypotheses to be verified; never insert them directly into formal documents.
4.2 Code Review
- Submit code in batches by module and control input size per call, so cross-module call context is not truncated.
- Ask the model to categorize its findings: concurrency issues, resource leaks, API misuse, boundary conditions.
- Require each finding to include the code location and a reproduction idea, so humans can verify it quickly.
- Review the review pass rate and false positive rate every two weeks. If false positives are too high, adjust the prompt or reduce that model’s weight in the review workflow.
5. Cost and Risk Retrospective
At the end of each release cycle, fill in the following retrospective table:
| Metric | Planned | Actual | Reason for Deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quota utilization | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Circuit breaker triggers | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Task interruptions | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Escalations to a higher tier | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Errors found in human review | TBD | TBD | TBD |
Poor quota planning is a common cause of project delays. These problems typically surface near critical milestones, when quota is nearly exhausted. If a retrospective shows quota usage exceeded 80% two weeks before a release, adjust the pool shares earlier next time instead of scrambling for quota right before the release.
Actual quotas and prices depend on your provider’s current terms. The numbers in this article only illustrate structure.
