Why Next-Gen LLMs Are Still Difficult to Use in AI Agents

    A deep dive into the gap between general LLM capabilities and actual usability in AI agent scenarios. This article explores why new models often underperform in agents, the continuous training stages required for stability, common failure points, and practical engineering strategies for evaluation and improvement.

    In the practice of applying Large Language Models (LLMs), an often-overlooked fact is that a model’s general Q&A capability does not equate to its actual usability in agent scenarios.

    When developers test new models, they typically focus on whether the response is fluent, the knowledge coverage is broad, and the code generation is complete. However, once a model is integrated into an AI agent system, the evaluation criteria change significantly. At this point, the model must do more than just “answer questions.” It must understand complex goals, decompose tasks, select tools, generate structured parameters, continuously correct based on execution results, and maintain stability across multi-turn interactions.

    Consequently, some models that appear highly capable in chat scenarios might turn out to be “difficult to use” when deployed in agents. This usually does not mean the model lacks capability entirely, but rather that it has not undergone sufficient targeted optimization in training objectives, tool usage, long-term planning, and exception recovery.

    1. Why AI Agents Are Harder Than Standard Q&A

    Standard Q&A typically involves a single input and a single output. The user asks a question, the model generates an answer, and the task is essentially complete. Even if the response has minor flaws, the user can follow up with questions for correction.

    Agents are different. A typical task might include the following steps:

    1. Understanding the user’s natural language goal;
    2. Determining whether external tools need to be called;
    3. Breaking down the main goal into multiple subtasks;
    4. Executing search, query, calculation, or write operations in sequence;
    5. Reading the results returned by the tools;
    6. Judging whether the current result meets expectations;
    7. Retrying, adjusting parameters, or switching approaches upon failure;
    8. Finally, organizing the results and explaining the process to the user.

    This means agents impose higher demands on the model. The model needs not only language generation capabilities but also process control, state tracking, and error recovery capabilities.

    For example, if a user requests to “query a batch of data and generate an analysis report,” a model suited for agents must first determine the data source, select the query tool, construct valid parameters, handle paginated results, identify empty and anomalous data, and finally complete the statistical analysis. If a model excels only at natural language generation but cannot strictly adhere to tool protocols, the entire workflow will frequently break.

    2. Model Iteration is a Continuous Training Process

    Well-performing agent models today typically do not reach maturity in a single training run. Instead, they go through multiple rounds of pre-training, instruction fine-tuning, preference optimization, tool calling training, and online feedback correction.

    Model capability iteration can be roughly understood in four stages:

    Stage 1: Basic Language Capability

    This stage primarily addresses the model’s language understanding, text generation, knowledge representation, and code completion. The model can handle summarization, translation, Q&A, and routine coding, but its ability to control complex workflows is often limited.

    Stage 2: Instruction Following

    The model begins training on a large volume of instruction samples, learning to output specified formats according to user requirements. For instance, when a user asks for lists, tables, or fixed fields, the model should try to comply with these constraints.

    However, instruction following does not equate to reliable execution. The model might perform well with simple instructions, but when multiple instructions stack up, or when it must simultaneously satisfy formatting, logic, and business rules, omissions are still likely.

    Stage 3: Tool Calling and Task Planning

    In this stage, the model learns how to identify tools, generate parameters, understand returned results, and execute subsequent steps based on those results.

    Tool calling demands high output accuracy. A minor error in a natural language response might just be a loose expression, but an extra field, a missing field, a type error, or a misunderstood field meaning in tool parameters can directly cause the task to fail.

    Stage 4: Agent Stability Optimization

    A truly mature agent model needs optimization for long-chain tasks, including multi-turn state maintenance, complex task decomposition, failure retries, context compression, result validation, and safety boundary control.

    This stage often requires a massive amount of real task feedback. The model must know which behaviors easily lead to workflow failures, under what circumstances it should stop calling tools, and when it needs to clarify information with the user, rather than blindly continuing execution.

    3. Why “New Models” May Not Be Immediately Usable

    A model release or version update does not mean it has completed maturity validation in all scenarios.

    First, different models may have different training focuses. Some focus on improving coding ability, some on optimizing long-text comprehension, some on strengthening reasoning, and others specifically target low-cost, high-concurrency scenarios. An improvement in one capability does not mean all agent tasks will improve synchronously.

    Second, a model’s performance in offline evaluations may differ from its performance in real business workflows. Offline tests usually feature clear inputs, well-defined task boundaries, and stable tool responses. In contrast, production environment requests often suffer from missing information, non-standard parameters, data latency, and permission restrictions.

    Third, the agent’s effectiveness is determined not only by the model but also by system design. Unclear tool descriptions, chaotic context concatenation, excessively long historical messages, and unreadable error messages will all degrade model performance. Even if the model itself is highly capable, it may produce unstable results due to insufficient peripheral engineering quality.

    Therefore, when evaluating a model, you shouldn’t just ask “is it smart?” You should also ask:

    • Can it stably adhere to tool calling protocols?
    • Can it maintain goal consistency throughout a long workflow?
    • Can it correctly handle tool errors?
    • Will it repeatedly execute steps that have already been completed?
    • Can it proactively clarify when information is insufficient?
    • Can it identify unachievable tasks and stop in a timely manner?
    • Is its output easy for programs to parse and process?

    4. Common Instability Behaviors in Agents

    1. Incorrect Tool Selection

    The model might force a tool call when none is needed, or directly answer from experience when querying external information is necessary. For tasks involving real-time data, internal data, or precise calculations, this behavior significantly reduces reliability.

    2. Non-Standard Parameter Generation

    Common issues include missing fields, incorrect field types, non-compliant enum values, inconsistent date formats, and directly filling tool parameters with vague information from user descriptions.

    Solving these issues cannot rely solely on the model’s self-awareness; it also requires adding parameter validation and error prompts at the tool layer.

    3. Unreasonable Task Decomposition

    Some models break simple tasks down too granularly, causing excessive call counts, while others process complex tasks all at once, skipping intermediate validations. Reasonable decomposition should be based on task risk and dependencies, rather than a fixed pattern.

    4. Context Gradually Spinning Out of Control

    When an agent executes multi-turn tasks, the context continuously grows. Excessively long historical information might dilute the current goal, causing the model to repeat old steps or misuse expired results.

    Engineering-wise, it is usually necessary to summarize, compress, and hierarchically manage historical information. Data such as “user goal, completed steps, key results, pending items, error messages” should be stored separately, rather than simply concatenating the entire conversation.

    5. Lack of Failure Recovery

    In real environments, tool timeouts, insufficient permissions, empty data, and temporarily unavailable services are common. If a model can only execute on the success path, the overall system availability will be very low.

    A more reliable agent should have mechanisms for a limited number of retries, parameter corrections, alternative paths, and manual confirmation. For unrecoverable errors, it should clearly explain the cause rather than generating results that look complete but are actually untrustworthy.

    5. How to Properly Evaluate Models for Agents

    Model selection should not rely solely on public demos or a single experience; instead, a test set close to your business should be established.

    1. Build Samples by Task Type

    The test set should at least cover:

    • Single-turn tool calling;
    • Multi-step serial tasks;
    • Multi-tool combination tasks;
    • Ambiguous tasks requiring user clarification;
    • Tasks where tools return exceptions;
    • Long-context tasks;
    • Tasks requiring strict format output;
    • Tasks requiring the rejection of unauthorized operations.

    2. Focus on Process Metrics

    Beyond whether the final answer is correct, you should also record:

    • Tool selection accuracy;
    • Parameter legality rate;
    • Task completion rate;
    • Average number of calls;
    • Invalid call ratio;
    • Error recovery success rate;
    • Repetition rate;
    • Average response latency;
    • Output format compliance rate.

    These metrics are more valuable than simply observing whether the language is fluent.

    3. Distinguish Model Issues from System Issues

    If the model frequently calls the wrong tool, it might be due to insufficient model capability or unclear tool documentation. If the model cannot understand the returned results, there might be an issue with how the context is organized. If the model repeatedly retries, the system might lack clear termination conditions.

    Therefore, during testing, try to fix the tool definitions, prompt templates, and runtime environment to locate the source of the problem through controlled experiments.

    6. Engineering Methods to Improve Agent Usability

    1. Design Clear Tool Descriptions

    Tool names, functional descriptions, parameter meanings, required fields, return structures, and error examples should all be explicit. Do not just tell the model to “query data”; specify the query scope, time format, pagination rules, and how empty results are handled.

    2. Use Structured State Management

    Do not rely on natural language memory for all states. Abstract task states into structured objects, for example:

    1. {
    2. "goal": "Complete data analysis report",
    3. "completed_steps": [],
    4. "pending_steps": [],
    5. "tool_results": [],
    6. "needs_confirmation": false
    7. }

    This reduces the risk of information loss in long workflows and makes it easier for the system to resume execution after an interruption.

    3. Add Validation Before and After Tool Calls

    Check parameter legality before the call, and verify result completeness after the call. For critical operations, add permission confirmation, risk alerts, and double confirmation to prevent the model from directly executing sensitive actions in unclear situations.

    4. Set Clear Stop Conditions

    Agents cannot loop infinitely. The system should set maximum steps, maximum retries, and timeout limits. When a task cannot continue, it should shift to explaining the reason or requesting supplementary information from the user.

    5. Adopt a Layered Model Strategy

    Simple classification, field extraction, and format conversion can be delegated to lightweight models, while complex planning, exception handling, and final review can be handed to more capable models. Layered calling balances cost, latency, and effectiveness.

    7. Correctly Understanding the Reasons Behind “Difficult to Use”

    When a new model performs poorly in an agent, you should not simply conclude that “the model got worse.” A more accurate approach is to distinguish between three levels:

    First, does the model possess the basic capabilities required to complete the task?
    Second, has the model undergone sufficient tool calling and agent scenario training?
    Third, does the application system provide a clear, stable, and verifiable execution environment for the model?

    Many models require multiple rounds of training and targeted optimization to evolve from “able to answer questions” to “able to complete tasks stably.” This is why similar models exhibit noticeable differences across stages: early versions might lean towards language generation, while later versions gradually strengthen task planning, tool calling, and error recovery.

    Conclusion

    The core competitiveness of an AI agent is not just model parameter size or single-response quality, but the closed loop formed by the model, tools, state management, evaluation system, and exception handling mechanisms.

    If you feel a model is unstable during use, it is recommended to first locate the problem through reproducible tasks, then optimize the prompt templates, tool definitions, context management, and process control separately. Meanwhile, recognize that excellent agent models typically require multiple rounds of training, scenario adaptation, and real feedback iteration. It is difficult to solve all problems with a single version update in the short term.

    For developers, the most reliable approach is not to blindly chase new versions, but to establish their own task evaluation sets and failure analysis mechanisms. Only by transforming “is the model easy to use” into a quantifiable, reproducible, and continuously optimizable engineering problem can you truly build stable, efficient agent systems.