Evaluating LLM Math Reasoning and Planning Coding Assistant Quotas

    This article presents a reproducible approach to evaluating LLM math reasoning and a practical method for managing coding assistant usage under 5-hour and 7-day quotas. It covers key evaluation variables, metric definitions for single-response accuracy, majority voting, and pass@k, dataset isolation and contamination checks, reasoning-length interpretation, monitoring fields, session splitting, task prioritization, and alert steps. Readers can use the checklists and tables to compare models more reliably and schedule work within limited quotas.

    Introduction

    When developers discuss large language models, two common issues arise. One is comparing the math capabilities of different models. The other is usage limits on coding assistants, which make task scheduling difficult. Both share the same core: measure tools with verifiable methods and arrange work within a limited quota. This article covers the topic in two parts. The first part provides a process and checklist for evaluating math reasoning. The second explains monitoring fields, session splitting, and alert steps under dual 5-hour and 7-day quotas.

    1. How to Make Math Reasoning Evaluation Reproducible

    1.1 Why Personal Experience Cannot Be Used Directly for Ranking

    Individual users usually try only a few problems, and they tend to remember successful responses more easily. Whether a problem appeared in training data, whether the wording was appropriate, and whether several paraphrases were needed to get a satisfactory result all affect impressions. For example, two models may both answer the same problem correctly, but one succeeds on the first attempt while the other succeeds after four rephrasings. Looking only at the result makes them appear identical, while their stability differs greatly. A single experience is useful for finding issues, but not for ranking.

    1.2 Key Variables That Affect Results

    Variable Effect on results Control method Fields to record
    Problem difficulty distribution Accuracy varies greatly across competition problems, textbook problems, and research problems; a mixed average has little explanatory power Stratify by difficulty and report results for each stratum separately Problem ID, difficulty label, source
    Data contamination Public problems may already be in the training corpus, inflating accuracy Time split, private problem set, manual sampling Publication time, public status, suspected overlap flag
    Sampling method Single response, majority vote, and pass@k measure different capabilities Fix sampling parameters and report the sampling count k Sampling count, temperature, each answer
    Prompt Wording changes can change the answer Fix the template and save it with versioning Prompt version number
    Reasoning chain length Long reasoning is not equal to correct reasoning Treat it only as an observation item; do not score it directly Output length, whether truncated

    1.3 Definitions and Applicable Conditions of Three Metrics

    • Single-response accuracy: take only one output per problem. It has the lowest cost and the largest variance. It is suitable for quick regression tests, not for comparing closely matched models.
    • Majority vote: sample k times for the same problem and take the most frequent final answer. This requires answers to be normalizable, such as numeric values, options, or fixed-format expressions. Open-ended proof problems cannot directly use majority voting.
    • pass@k: the probability that at least one of k samples is correct. If each problem is sampled n times and c samples are correct (n ≥ k), the unbiased estimate is 1 - C(n-c, k) / C(n, k), averaged over all problems. It measures whether multiple attempts can produce a correct solution, not the reliability of a single output.

    1.4 Problem Isolation and Contamination Checks

    Problem isolation works as follows:

    1. Divide the problem bank into a public set and a private set. Do not upload the private set to any online platform; run it only locally.
    2. Record publication times for public problems. If the model’s training data cutoff is public, use only problems published after the cutoff. If the cutoff is unknown, note this limitation in the report.
    3. Perform text overlap checks between problems and solutions, such as calculating n-gram overlap. Flag problems with high overlap separately and exclude them from the main results.
    4. Randomly sample a percentage of problems and manually verify whether they are original or paraphrased. Include the sampling percentage and sample size in the report.

    1.5 Boundaries for Interpreting Reasoning Chain Length

    Reasoning chain length is a common observation metric, but it only indicates the length of the output. Longer reasoning may contain detours, or it may simply repeat itself. Shorter answers may also be correct. Therefore, recording length is acceptable, but do not treat length as a capability score. To compare long reasoning between two models, also check final-answer accuracy and the truncation rate. Truncated outputs should be counted separately because they are often misjudged as errors.

    1.6 Reproducible Math Evaluation Checklist

    1. Write down the evaluation goal and clarify whether it measures single-response accuracy, majority vote, or pass@k.
    2. Fix the problem bank version and record the ID and source of each problem.
    3. Split the public and private sets, and record publication times.
    4. Run contamination checks and flag problems with suspected overlap.
    5. Fix the prompt template and record its version number.
    6. Fix sampling parameters such as temperature and top_p, and record the sampling count k.
    7. For each output, save the final answer, reasoning length, and truncation status.
    8. Report results stratified by difficulty, with the number of problems in each stratum.
    9. When using majority voting, record the answer normalization rules.
    10. Include the sample size in conclusions and describe the scope not covered.

    2. Managing Usage Under 5-Hour and 7-Day Dual Quotas

    2.1 Confirm Quota Definitions First

    Different providers calculate quotas differently. Before planning, confirm the following in the backend or official documentation: whether the 5-hour window is a fixed period or a rolling window; whether the window start is determined by the first request time or by natural clock hours; whether the 7-day quota is calculated by natural days or by a rolling seven-day period; and whether different models or features use different metering units. Write these answers into the team’s configuration notes so later numbers are comparable.

    2.2 Monitoring Metrics

    The goal of monitoring is to know at any time how much quota remains, where consumption occurs, and when it resets. Suggested fields to record are:

    Field Description Recording frequency
    Timestamp Time the request was sent Per session
    Session ID Distinguish multiple sessions for the same task Per session
    Task type Such as debugging, refactoring, writing tests, consulting documentation Per session
    Model and version Name and version of the model used Per session
    Consumption Record according to the provider backend’s metering definition End of each session
    5-hour window remaining Quota available in the current window Hourly, or before each large task
    7-day window remaining Quota available in the current period Daily
    Retry count Number of requests reissued due to errors or unsatisfactory results End of each session

    2.3 Session Splitting

    Long sessions quickly consume quota, and context also grows longer, which can make later responses slower or drift from the goal. Split sessions as follows:

    • Handle only one goal per session. Start a new session after the goal is complete.
    • Write requirements, key file paths, and agreed conventions into a short summary at the beginning of the new session.
    • Split large tasks into independently verifiable subtasks, each with clear inputs and completion criteria.
    • Complete work that does not require the model locally when possible, such as formatting, batch renaming, and running tests.

    2.4 Task Prioritization

    When quota is tight, order tasks as follows:

    1. Tasks that block others, such as locating a production incident.
    2. Deliverables with firm deadlines.
    3. Implementation tasks whose plan has already been decided.
    4. Exploratory tasks, such as researching a new library or trying a new approach.

    Exploratory tasks are best scheduled in the first half of the 7-day window, to avoid starting them only when weekend quota is nearly exhausted. High-consumption tasks within the 5-hour window should be completed as early as possible in the window, leaving time before the reset.

    2.5 Over-Limit Alert Steps

    1. Set two thresholds. For example, send a reminder when the remaining window quota falls below 30%, and stop starting new large tasks below 10%. These values are suggestions and should be adjusted to the team’s task scale.
    2. Before starting each large task, check the remaining quota in the current window. If expected consumption exceeds the remaining amount, split or defer the task first.
    3. After receiving an alert, pause exploratory tasks and keep only the highest-priority tasks.
    4. If the limit has already been exceeded, record the session ID and task type at the trigger time for later review.
    5. Review once a week, calculate the median consumption for each task type, and update the next week’s schedule accordingly.

    2.6 Quota Monitoring Checklist

    1. Confirm the window calculation definition and write it into the team configuration notes.
    2. At the start of each session, record the timestamp, session ID, task type, and model.