Evaluating LLMs for Mathematical Proof and Engineering Collaboration

    This article presents a practical framework for evaluating large language models in mathematical proof and software engineering workflows. It covers four dimensions—mathematical reasoning and proof, engineering collaboration and tool use, long-task context management, and quota and cost efficiency—and explains how to assess models through layered math test sets, multi-agent task routing, quota governance, and business-relevant selection criteria. Readers can use the framework to focus on verifiability, reproducibility, rework rate, and resource efficiency rather than relying on single demonstrations or leaderboard rankings.

    1. Background: From Single-Turn Q&A to Long-Chain Production

    The value of LLMs in mathematical proof and software engineering is shifting from single-turn Q&A to long-chain production. Users no longer ask a model only to answer a concept question. They ask it to read materials, locate problems, construct proofs, generate code, review defects, produce compilable documents, and maintain context consistency across multiple tool calls. Such tasks cannot be evaluated only by whether a single response looks smart. The evaluation must consider whether the result is verifiable, whether the process is reproducible, and whether resource consumption is controllable.

    Therefore, evaluating a model or a set of intelligent programming tools should be split into at least four dimensions: mathematical reasoning and proof capability, engineering collaboration and tool use capability, long-task context management capability, and quota and cost efficiency. The scenario mentioned in the original experience—proving propositions for which a literature repository provides no proof and writing them into English lecture notes with mathematical typesetting—is essentially a composite task. The model must understand definitions and existing lemmas, construct a logically closed proof chain, and ensure symbol consistency, compilable typesetting, and clear language. A single demonstration is rarely enough to judge a model’s real level. Layered evaluation sets and reproducible processes are necessary.

    2. Mathematical Capability: Layered, Verifiable, and Rework-Aware

    Mathematical capability cannot be summarized by one broad ranking. It should be divided into at least three layers.

    The first layer covers textbook and standard problems. Accuracy on this layer tends to saturate, so it is suitable for basic regression testing but has limited discriminative power. Evaluation should record symbol consistency, step completeness, and final answer correctness rather than looking only at the conclusion.

    The second layer covers propositions in the literature for which no proof is provided. This type of task is closer to real research assistance: the model needs to construct a proof based on existing definitions, lemmas, and context rather than restating a known answer. Evaluation should focus on whether lemma citations are reasonable, whether the proof chain is closed, whether steps are skipped, whether symbols remain consistent, whether the typesetting can compile, and whether the English expression is accurate. In practice, expert blind review should be combined with automated checks, and metrics such as first-pass rate, manual rework rate, and average correction time should be recorded. Rework rate often reflects production usability better than single-pass correctness.

    The third layer covers exploration of open mathematical problems. This layer places high demands on exploration ability, counterexample awareness, and long-chain reasoning, and it should not be mixed with ordinary problems. Evaluation of open problems must involve experts. The focus should be on whether the model can propose testable conjectures, identify its own assumptions, and converge when it fails rather than becoming overconfident. A longer chain of thought does not mean stronger capability. A readable, verifiable, and reproducible proof process is more valuable. A concise writing style with clear step citations is usually easier to review than lengthy accumulation.

    3. Engineering Collaboration: Multi-Agent Division of Labor and Task Routing

    Long-chain engineering tasks, such as defect localization, code review, and small feature implementation, often depend more on context management and tool collaboration than mathematical proof does. A feasible approach is hierarchical routing: “strong model plans, lightweight model executes, strong model reviews.” A high-reasoning model decomposes tasks, identifies risks, and defines acceptance criteria. A lightweight model handles retrieval, formatting, repetitive checks, and low-risk edits. Critical patches and final reviews then return to the strong model or to human reviewers.

    Agent configuration files should clearly define responsibilities and avoid pushing every subtask onto a high-cost model. For example:

    1. task_router:
    2. planner: high_reasoning_model
    3. executor: lightweight_model
    4. reviewer: high_reasoning_model
    5. rules:
    6. - if task.type in ["defect localization", "code review"]:
    7. route_to: lightweight_model
    8. - if task.requires_proof or task.risk == "high":
    9. route_to: high_reasoning_model
    10. - always:
    11. log_usage_and_artifact: true
    12. require_checkpoint: true

    This pseudocode expresses a general governance principle: route by task risk and verification cost, not by which model is more famous. Engineering tasks should also require minimal patches, accompanying tests, change notes, and review records. Otherwise, a model may generate a large amount of plausible but unmergeable code, which increases manual cost instead.

    4. Quota and Cost Governance: Review Short- and Long-Cycle Limits Together

    A common pain point in long-task production is opaque quota consumption. When short-cycle and long-cycle limits are combined, multiple concurrent sessions, high reasoning tiers, long contexts, and tool calls can quickly consume the budget. Without budget controls and alerts, teams may run tasks at night, hit the limit in the morning, and be unable to continue during the day. Governance should cover four points: set a budget before the task, record call volume and token usage during the task, archive artifacts and consumption after the task, and automatically degrade or pause when anomalies occur.

    On Baidu AI Cloud, teams can use log services to record call volume and task stages, monitoring alerts to set thresholds, and container platforms to host reproducible evaluation pipelines. These general infrastructure components do not change model capability, but they significantly improve the observability of quota usage. Governance measures can be summarized as follows: use high-cost models only for planning, key proofs, and final review; use lightweight models for retrieval, formatting, and repetitive checks; set checkpoints and resumable runs for long tasks; approve budgets separately for open problems; and periodically review resource consumption per unit of valid output rather than looking only at total call count.

    5. Evaluation and Selection: Avoid Single-Experience and Leaderboard Dependence

    When selecting models, teams should build task sets that are close to their business: mathematical proof problems, propositions without provided proofs, code defect localization, code review, small feature implementation, and document generation. Metrics should include correctness, verifiability, rework rate, latency, quota consumption, readability, and failure modes. Blind review and A/B comparison are recommended, with failure types such as symbol drift, skipped proof steps, overconfidence, context loss, and duplicate work recorded. Open mathematical problems should have a separate expert review channel and should not be mixed with ordinary problems.

    For cost-effectiveness, strong models are suitable for key nodes, while lightweight models are suitable for parallel low-risk tasks. The final conclusion should return to task verifiability, engineering controllability, and resource efficiency, rather than promotional comparison based on a single experience with a specific product. Through layered evaluation, task routing, quota monitoring, and audit logs, teams can obtain more stable and more explainable production capability in complex mathematical and software engineering scenarios.