2026 AI IDE Selection Guide: A Hands-On Evaluation Using an E-Commerce Site Build

    This article presents a practical evaluation of AI-powered integrated development environments (IDEs) available in China in 2026, based on a real-world task: building a 10-page e-commerce frontend from scratch. We compare several popular domestic tools across four dimensions—user interface, one-shot task completion, code quality, and stability—and provide a methodology for selecting the right AI coding assistant for your workflow, along with best practices for prompt engineering and code review.

    1. Evaluation Background and Task Design

    By 2026, AI coding tools have become standard equipment for frontend and full-stack developers. However, for developers in China, the selection process is still constrained by several practical factors: network accessibility, model response speed, the ability to understand Chinese prompts, and the engineering quality of generated code.

    For this evaluation, we designed a representative practical task: building a React-based e-commerce shopping site from scratch, with the requirement to generate 10 complete pages in one go:

    • Homepage (product listing)
    • Product details page
    • Product purchase page
    • Successful purchase page
    • User login / registration pages
    • User center: Dashboard, Orders, Wallet (coupons), and Settings

    This task was chosen because it covers several critical dimensions of AI coding tool capability:

    1. Task complexity: The 10-page requirement means component reuse, routing organization, and state management all need basic planning—simply generating pages one by one won’t work.
    2. Business completeness: A shopping flow involves login and authentication, form validation, and order progression, which directly tests the model’s understanding of business logic.
    3. Quantifiable code quality: Whether styling and logic are separated, whether mock data is coupled, and whether the directory structure is sensible are all objectively assessable criteria.

    The unified prompt used for all tools was roughly as follows:

    1. Use React to build a frontend shopping site with 10 pages:
    2. Homepage, Product Details, Purchase, Purchase Success,
    3. Login, Registration, and User Center (Dashboard, Orders, Wallet, Settings).

    2. Selection Criteria for Participating IDEs

    All IDEs evaluated are domestically available in China with no additional network configuration required. They fall into three categories:

    • Large-vendor IDEs: Built by cloud and AI teams at major internet companies, typically with proprietary models and agent-style development modes.
    • Domestic counterparts of Cursor-style tools: These follow the interaction paradigms of mainstream international AI IDEs (dialog panels, inline editing, diff-based multi-file changes) but are localized for the Chinese market.
    • AI-enhanced traditional IDEs: Focused primarily on code completion and Q&A, with weaker agentic capabilities.

    To ensure fairness, all IDEs were given the same prompt, the same model tier (the highest reasoning tier where selectable), and no manual intervention. We recorded the first-generation result and any necessary error-fix rounds.

    3. Four-Dimension Comparative Evaluation

    3.1 Interface and Interaction Experience

    Finding: Differences in interaction design directly affect developer trust and the speed of onboarding.

    One IDE stood out with a notably more “friendly” interface—featuring an anthropomorphized assistant and clearer progress feedback. The generation process was not a cold log stream but a staged task display. This matters especially for novice developers: the most stressful part of AI code generation is the “black box” waiting period, and visual progress indicators significantly reduce that anxiety.

    Another IDE category faithfully inherited the interaction paradigm of mainstream international AI IDEs: a file tree on the left, a chat panel on the right, and diff-view confirmation for modifications. For developers already familiar with Cursor, the learning curve is nearly zero. Notably, this tool also offered a privacy mode—a detail worth all vendors adopting, given that enterprise users have a hard requirement for code to stay within their own infrastructure.

    One interesting industry observation: mainstream international tools generally provide an “Auto mode” that automatically decides tool calls and file modifications, whereas most Chinese IDEs adopt a more explicit “Craft/Builder” style naming with more conservative automation strategies. This may reflect the lower tolerance Chinese users have for “uncontrollable behavior,” but it also adds an extra cognitive burden.

    3.2 One-Shot Task Completion Rate

    Finding: The quality of the agent mode determines the feasibility of “one-prompt site building.”

    • Best-performing IDE: In Craft mode, a single run generated all 10 pages, and the shopping flow was fully functional. Server response was fast, with no noticeable lag.
    • Mid-tier performers: The project could start after initial generation but had runtime errors; 2–3 rounds of conversational fixes were required before it worked properly.
    • Some IDEs offered multiple specialized agents (e.g., a planning agent, a coding agent, a review agent). In theory, this enhances complex task quality, but in practice it increases the decision cost—novice users are left wondering which agent to choose.

    A general rule emerged: Agent success rates do not depend on “aggressiveness” but on task decomposition capability. A good agent builds out a page structure and data model plan before writing code, then implements file by file. This succeeds far more often than directly stacking code.

    3.3 Code Quality Analysis

    A source code review of the generated results revealed a typical tiered pattern:

    What was done well:

    • Form validation was complete (login, registration, and purchase pages all had required-field and format checks).
    • Styling and JavaScript logic were separated, not all inline.
    • Some tools generated product detail pages with richer information architecture.

    Common issues:

    1. Mock data coupled with business code: Product data was hardcoded directly in components rather than isolated in a data layer, meaning significant refactoring would be needed to integrate a real API later.
    2. All images were placeholders: Usable, but it shows that current agents lack a solution for static asset management.
    3. Overly flat project architecture: There was no clear directory layering (e.g., components/, pages/, services/, hooks/), and route organization was somewhat arbitrary.
    4. Incomplete responsive design: The layout generally skewed toward mobile, and the PC version of the login and registration pages displayed poorly.

    One typical improvement is to explicitly constrain the project structure in the prompt:

    1. Please organize the code using the following directory structure and isolate mock data into a mock/ directory:
    2. src/
    3. components/ # Reusable components
    4. pages/ # Route pages
    5. services/ # API layer (returning mock data for now)
    6. hooks/ # Custom hooks
    7. router/ # Route configuration

    Our tests showed that adding this type of structural constraint significantly improves the maintainability of generated code—prompt engineering remains important in the agent era.

    3.4 Stability and Performance

    Inference speed and file-write stability during generation varied significantly between tools: some were smooth throughout, while others caused waits during high-concurrency file modifications. For everyday development, a stability shortfall is more disruptive than a missing feature—a single interrupted generation often means re-running the entire task.

    4. Selection Methodology: How to Evaluate an AI Coding IDE

    Based on this practice, we recommend evaluating AI coding IDEs using the following framework:

    1. Task completion rate: Use a standardized task (such as the 10-page site in this evaluation) to test one-shot success rate and the number of fix rounds required.
    2. Code engineering quality: Focus on directory structure, data layer decoupling, and type safety (e.g., whether TypeScript is used).
    3. Contextual understanding: Can the tool understand the entire project structure, rather than just handling single files?
    4. Controllability: Are diff confirmation, rollback mechanisms, and privacy modes fully implemented?
    5. Stability and speed: The ability to handle long-running tasks without interruption.
    6. Learning cost: Does the interaction paradigm match your team’s existing habits?

    5. Conclusion

    By 2026, AI-powered coding IDEs in China have achieved basic usability across the board. “One-prompt site building” is no longer just a marketing gimmick. However, the issues exposed in our tests are equally clear: weak architectural planning, tightly coupled mock data, and incomplete responsive design. These are precisely the aspects that determine whether generated code is production-ready.

    Our advice to developers: Treat the agent as a highly efficient junior collaborator—constrain it with structured prompts and review its output with a proper code review process. The tools will continue to evolve, but “how to collaborate with AI on development” is itself becoming one of the core skills every developer needs to master.