An Engineering Review of Chinese LLMs' Coding Capabilities at the End of 2025

    This article examines how to evaluate the coding capabilities of Chinese large language models from an engineering perspective, using a ten-page e-commerce site as a test case. It covers task scoping, acceptance matrices, common weaknesses in page generation, mobile usability validation, defect-fixing quality, architecture boundaries, phased generation workflows, and credible capability assessment—arguing that the real question is whether LLMs can deliver verifiable, maintainable, and iterable software under real constraints.

    1. Evaluating Coding Ability Requires More Than Checking Whether a Page Renders

    At the end of 2025, any discussion of Chinese large language models’ coding capabilities must start by defining what is actually being evaluated: Are we measuring code completion, the ability to generate a project independently, or the ability to continuously deliver software under real-world constraints?

    These abilities are related but not interchangeable. A model may quickly produce a visually complete homepage yet fail to keep data consistent across product detail, cart, and order pages. Another model may generate flawed code on the first attempt but iteratively fix it based on error messages until the project runs.

    A single generation result therefore only reflects performance under a specific task, prompt, and execution environment—it cannot represent the overall level of all Chinese LLMs. The underlying practice material involved building a ten-page e-commerce site from scratch, observing issues such as incomplete page coverage, basically usable mobile layouts, and relatively smooth type-migration fixes. These observations are better suited to distilling an engineering evaluation methodology than to producing a product ranking.

    The truly valuable question is: Can a large model turn requirements into verifiable, maintainable, and iterable engineering deliverables?

    2. Defining Verifiable Task Boundaries with a Ten-Page E-Commerce Site

    An e-commerce site works well as a comprehensive coding task because it simultaneously involves page layout, routing, state management, data modeling, input validation, and exception handling. Even without real payment integration, it can test fairly complete application development skills.

    A practical ten-page scope could include:

    1. Home page;
    2. Product listing page;
    3. Product search results page;
    4. Product detail page;
    5. Shopping cart page;
    6. Order confirmation page;
    7. Order submission result page;
    8. Login page;
    9. User profile page;
    10. Order detail page.

    This is an example scope, not a confirmed page list from the original test. Before execution, the pages, features, and data boundaries should be written into the task specification—otherwise the model fills in requirements on its own while the developer accepts the result against a different standard.

    Two types of deliverables must be clearly distinguished:

    • Interactive prototype: Mock data is allowed; the focus is on page organization and user flows.
    • Business system: The server side must handle authentication, permission checks, inventory confirmation, price calculation, and order persistence.

    If the task only asks for a frontend prototype, the absence of a real transaction system is not a failure; conversely, a mock checkout interface must not be treated as production-ready transaction capability.

    Building a Page Acceptance Matrix

    Acceptance Dimension Questions to Verify
    Page coverage Do all agreed pages exist and are they directly accessible?
    Shared layout Are the header, footer, navigation, and main content areas consistent?
    Data consistency Does product information match across list, detail, and cart pages?
    Business interactions Do search, filtering, quantity adjustment, and order submission form a closed loop?
    Exception states Do empty lists, invalid parameters, and failed requests produce clear feedback?
    Adaptability Do narrow-screen layouts, touch interactions, and long text remain usable?
    Engineering quality Do the build, type checks, and core tests pass?

    The purpose of an acceptance matrix is to turn “looks good” into repeatable, checkable facts.

    3. Common Shortcomings in Page Generation: Local Completeness Is Not System Completeness

    1. Shared Layouts Are Prone to Omissions

    In automatically generated sites, the header is usually fairly complete because the navigation, search box, and cart entry are visually prominent; the footer’s site navigation, help links, and copyright area are easily overlooked.

    This is not merely an aesthetic issue—it signals incomplete requirement coverage. Similar omissions can occur with back navigation, form validation messages, loading states, and empty-result notices.

    The fix is not to keep issuing scattered instructions, but to first define a shared page framework: which pages share the header and footer, which use a simplified layout, and how the main content width is controlled. Then check page by page whether the framework is applied consistently.

    2. Product Card Problems Usually Stem from Both Data and Layout Losing Control

    A messy homepage product grid can involve inconsistent image aspect ratios, wildly varying title lengths, misaligned price areas, and action buttons without fixed positions.

    More stable implementation approaches include:

    • Set a uniform aspect ratio for image areas;
    • Choose a full-display or cropping strategy based on product display needs;
    • Apply explicit wrapping or truncation rules for long titles;
    • Fix the order of price, stock hints, and buttons;
    • Provide placeholder content for missing images;
    • Use structurally consistent product data instead of assembling fields separately on each page.

    Visual defects do not necessarily require rewriting the whole page. First determine whether the problem lies in the data, the styles, or the component structure—the repair scope usually becomes much clearer.

    3. The Detail Page Cannot Be Display-Only

    A product detail page containing only an image, name, and price shows that static content was generated, not that the purchase flow works.

    A more complete detail page should at least handle variant selection, purchase quantity, stock hints, feedback after adding to cart, and invalid product identifiers. If variants exist, cart item uniqueness cannot rely on the product ID alone—it must also distinguish the specific variant.

    Issues like this show that the model must understand not only what a page looks like, but also how data flows through it.

    4. Mobile Usability Should Be Verified Through Behavior, Not Screenshots

    The absence of obvious horizontal scrolling on mobile only suggests the basic layout may hold; it does not prove full adaptation.

    Acceptance testing should cover these scenarios:

    • Do long product names squeeze out prices and buttons?
    • Can an expanded filter panel be closed normally?
    • Does a fixed bottom action bar obscure the content?
    • After an input field gains focus, are the main actions still reachable?
    • Are cart quantity controls easy to tap?
    • Do tooltips rely on mouse hover to be seen?

    Basic accessibility should also be checked—for example, whether forms have explicit labels, whether interactive controls work with a keyboard, and whether important states are conveyed by color alone.

    Mobile adaptation is a complete interaction quality problem, not simply shrinking a desktop layout.

    5. Defect-Fixing Ability: Passing Checks Is Not Enough—the Fixes Must Be Trustworthy

    When migrating dynamically typed scripts to a statically typed implementation, it is not unusual for a batch of problems to surface at once. Common causes include unclear object field definitions, unhandled nullable values, inconsistent component inputs, and different pages holding different understandings of the same data structure.

    In the original practice, the type migration exposed more than twenty issues, and the subsequent fixing process went relatively smoothly. This can serve as an observation from one task, but it cannot by itself prove the model has stable engineering capability.

    Evaluating fix quality also requires answering three questions:

    1. Was the Root Cause Identified?

    If the same product object repeatedly triggers field errors across multiple pages, the data model should be unified rather than bypassing the check at each location.

    2. Were Constraints Weakened?

    Eliminating errors by broadly loosening types, skipping checks, or forcing assertions may simply hide risk. Passing checks does not mean the data is reliable.

    3. Were Regressions Introduced?

    Fixing product fields may affect cart calculations and order displays. Every fix should therefore validate the related operation paths, not just confirm the error count went down.

    A short feedback loop is recommended:

    Reproduce the problem → provide error messages and relevant code → identify the root cause → make the minimal change → run checks → regression-test key flows.

    This approach controls change risk far better than a single demand to “fix all problems and optimize the entire project.”

    6. Architecture Quality: Directory Count Is Not the Standard—Responsibility Boundaries Are

    A directory structure containing only pages, components, and styles is not inherently wrong. For a short-term prototype, it may be clear enough.

    What genuinely warrants caution is business rules, mock data, request handling, and UI rendering all mixed together inside pages. As features grow, duplicated logic increases, and changing one field can affect multiple pages.

    Depending on actual complexity, an e-commerce project can progressively separate these responsibilities:

    • Page layer: organizes page structure and user flows;
    • Component layer: holds reusable presentation and interaction;
    • Domain model layer: describes core objects such as products, cart items, and orders;
    • Data access layer: encapsulates mock data or remote requests;
    • State management layer: maintains data shared across pages;
    • Shared rules layer: handles amount formatting, quantity constraints, and common validation;
    • Test layer: verifies core calculations and main business paths.

    For example, cart total calculation should not be implemented separately on the cart page, order confirmation page, and user profile. Once the rule is centralized, subsequent model-driven modifications have a clearly defined impact boundary.

    That said, the project should not be over-split just for the appearance of engineering rigor. Abstraction should serve reducing duplication, isolating change, and enabling testing—not adding directory layers.

    7. Phased Generation Instead of One-Shot Site Delivery

    A more reliable human-AI collaboration workflow can be divided into five phases.

    Phase 1: Freeze Requirements and Acceptance Criteria

    Define the page list, mock data scope, feature boundaries, and prohibitions. For example: no real secrets in frontend code, no presenting mock payments as real payments, and no adding business modules unilaterally for visual effect.

    Phase 2: Build a Runnable Skeleton First

    Prioritize page entries, the shared layout, navigation relationships, and a working build. Do not pursue polish on every page yet—first ensure the site structure is complete and access paths are correct.

    Phase 3: Establish the Minimal Business Loop

    Implement a consistent data flow around “browse products → view details → add to cart → confirm order → view result.” Product identifiers, variants, quantities, and amount rules should stay uniform across pages.

    Phase 4: Fill In Exceptions and Edge Cases

    Cover empty carts, invalid products, quantity overruns, duplicate submissions, failed requests, and page refreshes. If state persistence is needed, define its scope explicitly and avoid storing sensitive information in inappropriate locations.

    Phase 5: Run Quality Regression

    Execute static checks, core logic tests, page interaction tests, and mobile checks in sequence. Finally, record what was manually modified—do not merely count how much code the model generated.

    The value of phased delivery is that every step has a clear result and problems can be corrected before they spread.

    8. How to Form Credible Capability Conclusions

    When comparing different solutions or configurations, keep the requirement description, initial code, execution environment, time budget, and human-intervention rules as consistent as possible, while recording the number of post-generation revisions and unresolved issues.

    Useful metrics include:

    • The proportion of pages and features passing acceptance;
    • Whether key business paths are complete;
    • Severe defects and how they were fixed;
    • Whether core logic has test coverage;
    • The scope of manual rewriting and refactoring;
    • The number of modules affected when new requirements are added.

    These metrics should not be mechanically merged into a single total score. Strong visuals, fast defect fixing, and maintainable architecture represent different capabilities, and their importance differs between a demo prototype and a long-lived business system.

    Likewise, release timing alone cannot explain capability differences, and similar page styles are insufficient to determine the underlying model’s origin. Task outcomes are also influenced by prompts, context completeness, execution permissions, and feedback mechanisms.

    9. Conclusion: From Generating Pages to Delivering Engineering

    When discussing the coding capabilities of Chinese LLMs at the end of 2025, the more meaningful perspective is not “can a model generate an e-commerce site with one click,” but “can it continuously complete verifiable software work under explicit constraints.”

    The ten-page e-commerce practice highlights several directions worth attention: shared structures are easily omitted, complex interactions require explicit data models, type-error fixes must not bypass constraints, and project architecture needs to evolve with business complexity.

    For developers, LLMs are well suited to scaffolding, repetitive implementation, and localized fixes—but requirement boundaries, core business rules, security requirements, and final acceptance still demand human oversight. Breaking tasks down to reduce generation difficulty, providing feedback through automated checks, and constraining modification scope with regression tests are what turn one-shot page generation into stable, maintainable engineering delivery.