LLM Scaling: Pre-training vs. Post-training and How to Choose

    This article explains where large language model capabilities come from, compares pre-training scaling with post-training scaling, and provides a decision framework for teams that need to consider inference cost, MoE total and activated parameters, evaluation quality, and engineering readiness. It helps readers move beyond leaderboard rankings and choose a scaling strategy that fits their workload and business constraints.

    1. Beyond Scores: Where Do Capability Improvements Come From?

    Leaderboards for large language models are updating more frequently, and composite intelligence indexes often move up and down as models trade places. However, focusing only on who is first or who has been overtaken can hide a more important question: how are these scores produced?

    Similar-looking scores can come from very different sources of capability. Some models improve by expanding parameter scale and increasing training compute during pre-training. Others keep the base model structure unchanged and place most of the gains in post-training. The first approach emphasizes pre-training scaling; the second emphasizes post-training scaling. Together, they form one of the most important divides in the current large-model competition.

    This article does not rank specific models. Instead, it answers three questions from an engineering and methodology perspective: where capability comes from, how different paths trade off, and how enterprises can choose a strategy that fits their own business. For readers concerned with MoE activated parameters, inference cost, and model serving, understanding these differences is often more valuable than simply tracking leaderboard positions.

    2. Scaling Law: From Parameter Priority to Compute and Inference-Cost Optimization

    The core question of Scaling Law is how to allocate model parameters, training data, and compute under a given compute budget to achieve better results.

    Early experience often emphasized parameter expansion, and the industry once largely assumed that larger parameter scale would naturally lead to stronger model capability. Later research corrected this view, pointing out that under limited compute budgets, model size and training tokens need to be balanced to avoid the case where a model is too large but data is insufficient. A rule of thumb such as “about 20 tokens per parameter” is often mentioned, but it comes from specific experiments and architecture ranges and is not a universal conclusion. In practice, adjustments still need to be made based on data quality, model architecture, training objectives, context length, and inference budget.

    More importantly, traditional Scaling Law discussions often optimize only the cost of “training once and evaluating once.” In real business environments, however, a model may be called billions of times per day. Over the long term, inference cost is often more critical than one-time training cost. Once inference overhead is included in the overall cost equation, the optimal solution may shift from “the larger the parameters, the better” to “a smaller base model with longer training” or “a fixed base model with post-training enhancement.”

    Therefore, scaling is not a single knob. It is a multi-dimensional optimization problem involving parameters, data, training strategy, and inference cost. Judging which path is better depends on what the business objective function is actually optimizing: training-stage performance, cost per call, or completion rate for long-tail tasks.

    3. How to Choose Between the Two Paths: Pre-training vs. Post-training Scaling

    In MoE architectures, the distinction between pre-training scaling and post-training scaling becomes easier to understand.

    Pre-training scaling follows a “scale aggressively and see capability emerge” path: expand the base model, increase total parameters, involve more experts in computation, and invest more training compute. Its assumption is that if model capacity and knowledge coverage are pushed high enough, capability will improve accordingly. The advantage is a high capability ceiling and a relatively direct improvement path. The cost is expensive training; once the base model is finalized, later adjustments can be difficult and costly.

    Post-training scaling usually keeps the base model unchanged. Architecture, total parameters, and pre-training objectives remain the same, while the main gains come from post-training: longer task environments, richer interaction distributions, and larger-scale reinforcement learning or preference optimization. Its assumption is that the same base model still contains a large amount of underused potential, which can be released through targeted post-training. The advantage is relatively controllable cost and faster iteration. The cost is that the capability ceiling is constrained by the base model’s inherent capabilities.

    The two approaches can be compared as follows:

    Dimension Pre-training Scaling Post-training Scaling Selection consideration
    Where investment goes Mostly during pre-training Mostly during post-training Budget constraints
    Cost pattern High upfront cost, long cycle More incremental, can scale up gradually Cash flow and iteration speed
    Iteration pace Slower; adjusting after the base model is finalized is costly Faster; suitable for continuous experimentation Speed of business change
    Capability ceiling Higher ceiling; suitable for pushing general capability Constrained by the base model’s inherent capabilities Whether you must break the base-model ceiling
    Main risk High cost and uncertain return Limited gains if the base model is insufficient Base-model quality and task fit
    Typical use case Building a strong general-purpose base from scratch Improving specific capabilities on an existing base Whether an existing base can be reused

    If the goal is to build a completely new general-purpose foundation model and the budget is sufficient, pre-training scaling still has value. If a usable base model already exists and the business emphasizes rapid iteration, controllable cost, and scenario-specific optimization, post-training scaling is often more worth evaluating first.

    4. Total Parameters vs. Activated Parameters in MoE

    In MoE architectures, it is necessary to distinguish between two concepts: total parameters and activated parameters.

    Total parameters determine how much the model can “store,” including knowledge, facts, and long-tail information. They are more like capacity or storage. Activated parameters and effective computation depth determine how far the model can “think” and how many reasoning steps it can execute. They are more like compute or reasoning capability.

    A key point is that when activated parameters, training data, and optimization budget are held fixed, simply increasing total parameters may lead to diminishing marginal returns in reasoning ability. This is because more resources are being used to expand storage and knowledge capacity rather than to increase effective computation. However, this does not mean that increasing total parameters will definitely reduce reasoning ability, nor does it mean that more total parameters are always worse. Total parameters mainly improve capacity or knowledge coverage; whether this translates into reasoning capability also depends on training objectives, activation mechanisms, data structure, and inference budget.

    This insight is important for post-training scaling. If the base model’s total parameters remain unchanged, post-training does not simply add parameters. Instead, it makes better use of existing experts, extends effective reasoning chains, and broadens task-environment coverage, thereby improving performance without changing the base model’s scale. This is also why post-training can continue to bring capability improvements on a fixed base model.

    The following is pseudocode and cannot be run directly. If it is treated as a workflow sketch, its dependencies are: envs.rollout requires task environments, action spaces, and termination conditions; policy_update requires a reinforcement-learning algorithm, a reward function, a training framework, and compute configuration.

    1. # Workflow illustration for post-training scaling: freeze the base model and improve how the model reasons
    2. base_model = load_frozen_base() # Base model parameters remain unchanged
    3. envs = build_task_environments(
    4. horizon="long", # Long-horizon task environments that extend the effective reasoning chain
    5. diversity="high", # Diverse environment types to cover more distributions
    6. )
    7. def post_train_scaling(model, envs, steps):
    8. for _ in range(steps):
    9. traj = envs.rollout(model) # Sample long-horizon trajectories
    10. reward = evaluate_outcome(traj) # Score the outcome; outcome-oriented reward
    11. model = policy_update(model, traj, reward) # Update the policy with reinforcement learning
    12. return model

    The key point of this pseudocode is not that it can be reused directly in engineering, but that it illustrates the core idea of post-training: keep the base model unchanged, and improve the model’s ability to handle complex tasks through task environments, long-horizon trajectories, outcome rewards, and policy updates.

    5. Aggregate Scores vs. Sub-scores: What Should Matter During Evaluation?

    Composite intelligence indexes are usually weighted aggregate metrics that measure average capability. Evaluations that focus more on real task completion may use Elo-style relative scoring to measure relative win rates under real workloads. The two often disagree: a model may tie on a composite index while leading or lagging significantly on a specific long-horizon task.

    There are three common mistakes when interpreting scores:

    1. Looking only at the total score, not the sub-scores. Similar total scores do not mean that reasoning, coding, long-text handling, and tool use are equally similar.
    2. Ignoring long-tail capabilities. What a business truly needs may not be the average score, but stability in a specific scenario.
    3. Ignoring inference cost. A slightly stronger model may still fail to scale in production if its cost is too high.

    A more reasonable evaluation order is:

    1. First clarify what the evaluation is measuring: knowledge breadth, reasoning depth, or end-to-end task completion?
    2. Then examine sub-score performance: which dimensions are business must-haves, and which are nice-to-haves?
    3. Finally, return to your own scenario: the top-ranked model is not necessarily the best choice for your use case.

    6. Selection Checklist and Decision Rules

    Choosing between pre-training and post-training scaling should not be based only on intuition. It should start from business constraints. The following checklist covers at least six key items:

    Checklist item Question to answer Impact on path choice
    Business request volume How large is the daily request volume? Is it expected to grow over the long term? Larger request volume makes inference cost more important
    Inference cost sensitivity Does per-call cost directly affect gross margin? If cost is sensitive, prioritize smaller models and post-training optimization
    Required capability ceiling Is it necessary to break the current base-model capability ceiling? If yes, pre-training scaling deserves more evaluation
    Base model replaceability Must you build a base model in-house, or can you use an existing one? If an existing base model is usable, post-training is usually more economical
    Post-training resources Do you have task environments, reward models, and reinforcement-learning teams? If resources are limited, start with lightweight post-training or fine-tuning
    Evaluation metrics Are there clear sub-score evaluations and business acceptance criteria? Without clear evaluation, do not blindly chase high scores

    The decision rules can be simplified as follows:

    • Prefer post-training scaling when request volume is high, inference cost is sensitive, a usable base model exists, post-training resources are relatively sufficient, and the target scenario is clear.
    • Evaluate pre-training scaling when the required capability ceiling is extremely high, budget is sufficient, a long-term general-purpose base model is needed, and the organization is willing to bear high training costs.
    • Adopt a hybrid strategy when there are both scenario-specific optimization needs and a desire to gradually improve general capability: first fix the base model and perform post-training, then evaluate whether it is worth starting pre-training.

    7. Engineering Delivery Matters as Much as Model Capability

    Model capability is only half of the value. Whether it can be served reliably, cost-effectively, and observably is equally important for realizing the final return.

    In practice, delivery usually requires attention to the following areas:

    • Containerized deployment: ensures environmental consistency and elastic scaling.
    • Model serving frameworks: supports inference acceleration, batching, canary releases, and version management.
    • Monitoring and alerting: tracks latency, throughput, error rate, token consumption, and abnormal requests.
    • Logging services: supports issue diagnosis, rollback, and cost analysis.
    • Evaluation loop: connects online task performance with offline evaluation to continuously optimize model versions.

    General cloud infrastructure capabilities—such as containerized deployment, model serving frameworks, monitoring and alerting, and logging services—are a necessary part of turning model capability into business value. Without these engineering foundations, even a high leaderboard score is difficult to deploy reliably.

    8. Conclusion

    Leaderboard chasing is only a surface issue; the real key is path selection. Pre-training scaling raises the capability ceiling and is suitable for building a strong general-purpose base model. Post-training scaling unlocks the potential of an existing base model and is suitable for rapid iteration and cost control.

    By understanding the evolution of Scaling Law from parameter priority to compute efficiency and then to inference-cost sensitivity, and by combining this with the division between total parameters and activated parameters in MoE models, developers can build a more stable decision framework: do not blindly chase higher scores, do not be swayed by a single metric, and make decisions based on request volume, cost, capability ceiling, and evaluation criteria.