LLM Scaling Laws Diverge: Pretraining Parameter Scaling vs. Post-Training Potential
A recent benchmark shows two open-source LLMs matching some closed-source flagship models through very different technical paths: one scales pretraining with a trillion-parameter MoE architecture, while the other reuses a much smaller base and invests heavily in post-training reinforcement learning. This article examines the tradeoffs behind both approaches, revisits how Scaling Laws evolved from training cost to inference cost, explains the distinct roles of total and active parameters in MoE models, and outlines what the shift means for enterprise model selection and cloud-native deployment.
Recent results from a widely watched intelligence index benchmark have drawn attention across the industry. Two recently released open-source large models have matched some closed-source flagship models on composite scores, and in certain dynamic benchmark rankings they have posted jumps of hundreds of points and placed near the top. For developers and enterprise users, however, the more important issue is not the scores themselves, but the sharply different technical paths the two models took to reach them. The collision of these paths is one of the most informative divides in the current evolution of large language models.
1. Pretraining Brute Force and Mixture-of-Experts Architectures
The first model follows a classic “brute force” route. It scales total parameters to the trillion level—for example, 2.8 trillion—and adopts a mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture with nearly a thousand expert networks, activating only dozens of them during each forward pass. The core idea is to expand the parameter scale of the model base aggressively in order to obtain a much larger knowledge capacity.
From a technical perspective, MoE uses a routing mechanism to assign input tokens to different expert networks. This greatly expands the model’s total parameter count without significantly increasing the computation required for a single inference pass. The advantage of this “stack parameters” approach is clear: a larger base means the model can memorize and understand richer long-tail knowledge and facts. Its disadvantages are equally clear. Trillion-level total parameters impose extremely demanding VRAM requirements, and communication across multiple GPUs or even multiple machines incurs substantial overhead. As a result, deployment cost is very high, making this approach difficult to implement in conventional enterprise compute environments.
2. Post-Training Scaling as an Alternative Breakthrough
The second model stands in sharp contrast. Its total parameter count is only in the range of tens of billions to around 100 billion, and it shares the same base as its previous-generation model, with almost no change to architecture or parameter scale. It achieves a significant performance improvement and matches closed-source flagships entirely through scaling in the post-training stage.
Within a one-month cycle, the team built long-horizon task environments dozens of times larger than those used previously, introduced richer environment types, and conducted larger-scale reinforcement learning training. This work demonstrates that pretraining is not the only knob for improving model capability. By starting from an existing base and using reinforcement learning to let the model explore and receive feedback in massive, complex task environments, it is possible to more effectively extract the potential of existing parameters and significantly improve performance on complex logical reasoning, multi-step causal-chain tracking, and related tasks.
3. A Scholar’s View: The Evolution of Scaling Laws and Inference Cost
A senior industry scholar recently published a deeper reflection on scaling laws, placing these developments in a broader historical context. Early research once proposed that parameter counts should grow faster than data volume, and many well-known models of that period followed this principle. Later, a revised scaling law corrected this misconception, stating that the optimal ratio between model parameters and training data should remain around 1:20.
The scholar further points out that even the revised scaling law optimizes only the cost of a model that is “trained once and evaluated once.” In commercial deployment today, large models may handle billions of API calls each day, and inference cost becomes the dominant component of total cost. Once long-term inference cost is included, the optimal solution is no longer to blindly stack pretraining parameters, but to move toward “smaller models with longer training.” This explains why the industry has continued to release lightweight models with fewer parameters but strong performance.
4. MoE’s Core Insight: Knowledge Capacity vs. Causal Reasoning Depth
When analyzing MoE architectures, the scholar offers a key insight: in MoE, total parameters and activated parameters serve completely different purposes.
Total parameters determine how much the model can store. They govern the model’s knowledge reserves, factual memory, and breadth of long-tail information coverage. Activated parameters and the model’s effective depth determine how far the model can think. They govern how many steps of a causal chain the model can carry during inference and how deep its logical reasoning can go.
The practical implication is clear. Under a fixed inference compute budget, blindly increasing total parameters may instead hurt real-time inference because of more complex routing computation and memory bottlenecks. By contrast, within a reasonable total parameter envelope, optimizing the routing mechanism to activate more effective experts can reliably help improve complex reasoning capability.
5. Enterprise Implications and Cloud-Native Deployment
For enterprise users, these technical routes directly affect underlying compute planning and technology selection. In real business scenarios, enterprises must often balance model performance, inference latency, and compute cost.
When deploying such complex LLMs, enterprises typically depend on mature cloud-native infrastructure. For example, with Baidu AI Cloud’s high-performance computing clusters and container platform, enterprises can perform flexible resource scheduling and VRAM partitioning for the large-memory requirements of MoE models. Using Baidu AI Cloud’s model inference optimization solutions, such as dynamic batching and PagedAttention, can effectively reduce inference latency and increase throughput in high-concurrency scenarios. For models using the post-training scaling route, Baidu AI Cloud’s distributed training platform and massive data storage services can provide stable compute support for building the complex environments required for reinforcement learning.
In summary, large model development is moving from a single-minded stage of stacking compute and parameters toward a more refined, multi-dimensional scaling phase. While paying attention to benchmark scores, developers should understand the technical implementation paths behind the models. Selecting a base model suited to their own inference workload and compute budget, and making full use of post-training reinforcement learning and cloud-native inference optimization tools, is the practical path to efficient LLM deployment.
