Post-Training Optimization vs. Base Model Scaling: Two Routes for Large Model Competition

    As large-model competition shifts from parameter counts to reliable task completion, teams face a practical choice: keep an existing base model and invest heavily in post-training, or redesign and scale the base model for a higher capability ceiling. This article compares the two routes across long-horizon task training, environment diversity, base-model engineering costs, coding-agent capability, reinforcement learning, safety alignment, and enterprise evaluation. It explains why neither route is universally superior, how to identify whether a bottleneck comes from behavior or from model capacity, and how teams can combine post-training, tool orchestration, and base-model expansion in a more disciplined engineering sequence.

    In recent years, competition among large models in China has gradually shifted from “who has more parameters” to “who can reliably complete more work in real tasks.” This is especially visible in coding, automated operations, cybersecurity, data analysis, and complex agent scenarios. The final user experience is not determined by parameter size alone. A model that keeps its architecture unchanged and continuously strengthens post-training may outperform a larger new model in real workflows. At the same time, redesigning the base model and increasing parameter scale may deliver greater knowledge capacity, reasoning potential, and multi-task generalization.

    Neither route is absolutely better. They correspond to different engineering goals, resource constraints, and product stages. Understanding the difference helps developers and enterprises avoid simplistic conclusions such as “larger parameters are always stronger” or “post-training can solve everything.”

    1. Model capability is not determined by parameter size alone

    A large model can usually be divided into three interconnected stages: pre-training, post-training, and application-side orchestration.

    Pre-training is mainly responsible for building general capabilities, including language modeling, knowledge absorption, code understanding, pattern recognition, and basic reasoning. At this stage, the model is exposed to large amounts of text, code, and structured data, forming a broad capability boundary. Base-model scale, data quality, training objectives, model architecture, and training stability all affect the model’s potential ceiling.

    Post-training focuses more on “how to use the capability.” Through supervised fine-tuning, preference optimization, reinforcement learning, tool-calling training, and interaction with task environments, a model can learn to plan steps more clearly, follow requirements more strictly, use tools more effectively, and maintain state consistency across longer task chains.

    Application-side orchestration sits outside the model itself. It typically includes prompt templates, context management, retrieval augmentation, code execution, permission control, memory systems, task scheduling, and result validation. Many experiences that appear to belong to the model are actually determined jointly by the model and these surrounding components.

    Therefore, parameter size is closer to “potential capacity,” while post-training and application orchestration determine whether the model can convert that capacity into stable output. For tasks such as code generation, repository modification, and automated operations, the ability to continuously execute twenty, thirty, or even longer task chains often matters more than knowledge coverage in single-turn question answering.

    2. Route one: keep the base model unchanged and amplify post-training

    Keeping the base model unchanged and focusing investment on post-training is a typical efficiency-oriented route. Its core assumption is that the existing model still has a great deal of capability that has not been fully activated. The problem may not be that “the model cannot do it,” but that “the model has not been trained on sufficiently good tasks.”

    2.1 From short-answer training to long-horizon task training

    Traditional supervised data often consists of single-turn question answering, a single function, or a single problem. Such data helps improve local accuracy, but it is difficult to train a model to complete complex engineering tasks.

    Long-horizon task training breaks the objective into a continuous process, for example:

    1. Understand the requirement and identify constraints.
    2. Browse the directory structure and relevant files.
    3. Locate potential defects.
    4. Formulate a modification plan.
    5. Write or refactor code.
    6. Run tests and static checks.
    7. Fix issues based on error logs.
    8. Summarize changes and explain risks.

    In this process, the model must not only generate correct content. It must also decide what to do next, when to call tools, how to handle failures, and how to avoid contradictions between earlier and later steps.

    This kind of training significantly increases the cost of sample construction and environment execution, but it is closer to real development work. What the model ultimately learns is not a fixed answer, but a repeatable process for solving problems.

    2.2 Environment quantity matters more than sample quantity

    If all training tasks are completed in similar environments, the model can easily memorize fixed patterns. Once the directory structure, dependency relationships, testing methods, or error types change, performance may drop noticeably.

    Richer environments should cover different types of tasks, such as:

    • multilingual code repositories;
    • different build systems and test frameworks;
    • terminal operations and file management;
    • data cleaning and script automation;
    • service configuration and log analysis;
    • cross-file refactoring;
    • multi-tool collaboration;
    • tasks that require reading documentation and interface specifications.

    The value of environment diversity lies in improving transferability. The model must learn abstract methods rather than memorizing the modification patterns of a particular repository.

    2.3 Marginal gains from training duration

    Post-training is not simply a matter of adding more epochs and expecting it to work. With longer training, a model may gain stronger planning and error-correction abilities, but it may also overfit, become rigid in behavior, or exploit reward loopholes.

    Therefore, post-training scaling needs multi-dimensional monitoring:

    • task completion rate;
    • test pass rate;
    • rate of missing critical steps;
    • tool-calling accuracy;
    • number of ineffective loops;
    • average task length;
    • error recovery success rate;
    • maintainability of output;
    • accuracy of safety-policy triggers.

    Only when training gains can be reproduced on unseen tasks and in new environments does compute investment have practical meaning.

    3. Route two: expand the base model to pursue a higher potential ceiling

    The other route is to redesign or retrain a larger base model. Its advantage is that it can obtain potential benefits from larger data capacity, stronger representation ability, and more complex architectures.

    3.1 Capabilities that larger scale may bring

    When data quality and training methods are sufficiently matched, larger models usually have the following potential:

    • richer memory of knowledge and code patterns;
    • ability to handle more complex semantic relationships;
    • transfer across tasks in multiple domains;
    • stronger abstraction and induction;
    • support for more complex multi-step reasoning;
    • better information integration over long contexts.

    However, “potential” does not equal “production experience.” If a model lacks sufficient post-training, it may know a lot but fail to execute reliably according to user requirements. If tool-calling protocols, error recovery, and safety boundaries are not well trained, the larger the model, the broader the impact of incorrect operations may be.

    3.2 Engineering costs of base-model expansion

    Expanding the base model means more than increasing training compute. It brings a whole set of systemic challenges:

    • higher data cleaning and deduplication costs;
    • stricter requirements for distributed training stability;
    • increased memory, communication, and storage pressure;
    • more complex training failure recovery;
    • potentially higher inference latency and deployment costs;
    • synchronous expansion of evaluation data and validation environments;
    • greater difficulty in model compression, quantization, and serving.

    Therefore, base-model expansion is suitable for teams with long-term infrastructure investment capacity and a clear need for a higher general-purpose ceiling. For teams that already have a strong base model but want to quickly improve coding and agent experiences, prioritizing post-training optimization often offers a better return on investment.

    4. Coding capability is not just code generation

    Evaluating a model’s coding ability cannot rely only on whether it can generate a snippet that looks correct. Real development scenarios include at least four layers.

    4.1 Code understanding

    The model needs to accurately understand project structure, module dependencies, data flow, exception handling, and implicit constraints. Reading only the current file is often insufficient to determine whether a change will affect other modules.

    4.2 Modification quality

    Code must not only run; it should also be readable, maintainable, and compatible. The model needs to avoid unrelated changes, preserve existing interfaces, and follow the project’s original style.

    4.3 Verification and repair

    One-shot success is unrealistic. A strong coding agent should proactively run tests, read error messages, locate failure causes, and revise the change, rather than simply providing an explanation after a test failure.

    4.4 Task closure

    Truly valuable capability runs from requirement understanding to result delivery, including change descriptions, risk warnings, test conclusions, and unfinished items. Only when the loop is closed does the model become a real development tool rather than a code-snippet generator.

    5. How reinforcement learning improves long-horizon task capability

    In long-horizon tasks, a model may have multiple feasible paths. It is difficult for standard answers alone to cover all correct behaviors. Therefore, training usually needs to combine process rewards and outcome rewards.

    Outcome rewards focus on the final objective, such as whether tests pass, whether a vulnerability is fixed, or whether a build succeeds. Process rewards focus on intermediate behavior, such as whether files are read correctly, whether appropriate tools are selected, whether results are checked in time, and whether repeated operations are avoided.

    Reward design must prevent the model from gaming the system. For example, a model may obtain a superficially high score by skipping tests, modifying test cases, or hiding errors. For this reason, the training environment must have independent validation mechanisms and permission boundaries for dangerous operations.

    A more reliable task execution framework usually includes:

    1. User request
    2. ↓
    3. Task decomposition
    4. ↓
    5. Environment observation
    6. ↓
    7. Tool invocation
    8. ↓
    9. Result verification
    10. ↓
    11. Error recovery
    12. ↓
    13. Final delivery

    Each stage should record trajectories so that failure causes can be analyzed. Compared with only counting whether the final answer is correct, complete trajectories help training teams identify whether the model misunderstood the task, planned incorrectly, called tools incorrectly, or failed to handle feedback properly.

    6. Safety capability also depends on post-training

    Scenarios such as cybersecurity, system operations, and code auditing require both technical capability and an understanding of permission and risk boundaries.

    Models need to distinguish between:

    • legitimate defensive analysis and high-risk operations;
    • test environments and production environments;
    • simulated data and real sensitive data;
    • read-only inspection and destructive modification;
    • ordinary recommendations and execution actions that require human approval.

    These boundaries are difficult to acquire through pre-training alone. They must be trained through explicit safety data, isolated environments, permission control, and refusal strategies. At the same time, safety policies cannot be too coarse, or the model will frequently refuse normal development and defensive tasks.

    A more reasonable approach is tiered handling: answer low-risk tasks directly, provide explanations and require confirmation for medium-risk tasks, and give only compliant defensive recommendations for high-risk tasks while prohibiting direct execution of sensitive operations.

    7. How enterprises should compare the two types of models

    Model selection should not rely only on parameter size, leaderboard rankings, or single-turn examples. Enterprises should build evaluation sets that are close to their actual business.

    Validation is recommended across the following dimensions:

    1. Task success rate: whether the model truly completes the objective rather than merely generating superficially correct text.
    2. First-pass rate: the proportion of work that avoids manual revision.
    3. Error-correction ability: whether the model can recover from build failures, test failures, or tool exceptions.
    4. Long-task stability: whether performance degrades quickly as task steps increase.
    5. Context utilization: whether the model can accurately use large code repositories and historical information.
    6. Tool-use quality: whether it selects the right tools and correctly interprets returned results.
    7. Safety and compliance: whether it follows permission, privacy, and approval requirements.
    8. Total cost: including inference cost, latency, deployment resources, and manual review cost.

    For enterprises, the final metric is usually not “how smart the model sounds,” but “how much time is saved per task, how much rework is reduced, and whether the process remains controllable.”

    8. The two routes are not mutually exclusive

    Base-model expansion and post-training reinforcement can form a progressive relationship. A larger base model provides a higher capability ceiling, while post-training is responsible for turning potential into stable behavior. High-quality task environments and evaluation data can also help teams identify the real weaknesses of the base model.

    From an engineering practice perspective, a relatively prudent route is:

    • first use the existing base model to build a real-task evaluation set;
    • validate benefits through post-training and tool orchestration;
    • analyze which problems are behavioral defects and which are limitations in knowledge or reasoning capacity;
    • consider expanding the base model only for bottlenecks that truly cannot be resolved through post-training;
    • after a new base model is launched, continue long-horizon task training and safety calibration.

    This approach avoids blindly pursuing scale and also prevents attributing all problems to prompts or workflow design.

    Conclusion: the real competition combines capability ceiling and task completion rate

    Large-model competition is shifting from parameter-count competition to system-engineering competition. A larger base model represents higher potential capacity. Deep post-training represents stronger task execution. Real product experience also depends on the tool system, evaluation methods, safety mechanisms, and deployment costs.

    If the goal is to quickly improve coding, agent, and automation task experiences, long-horizon environments and post-training scaling are often cost-effective levers. If the goal is to break through the ceiling of knowledge coverage, complex reasoning, and cross-domain generalization, base-model expansion has long-term value.

    Ultimately, whether a model is truly leading should not be judged only by how many parameters it has, but by whether it can understand problems, form plans, call tools, handle failures, and deliver verifiable results in real environments. For developers and enterprise users, this shift from “can answer” to “can complete” is the core of the next stage of large-model technology competition.