Choosing Between Generalized Linear Models (GLMs) and Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs)

    This guide explains how to choose between GLMs and GLMMs for non-normal outcomes such as binary results, count data, and proportions. It focuses on the key distinction between independent observations and correlated observations caused by repeated measurements, hierarchical structures, clustering, or individual differences. You will learn how to distinguish fixed effects from random effects, assess whether group-level variables adequately address dependence, and compare GLM, fixed-effect GLM, and GLMM specifications.

    Generalized Linear Models (GLMs) and Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMMs) are both designed to analyze non-normal response variables, including binary outcomes, count data, and proportions. Both models use a link function to connect the response variable with explanatory variables, but they make different assumptions about the independence of observations.

    In simple terms:

    • A GLM is usually appropriate when observations can reasonably be treated as independent.
    • A GLMM should generally be considered when observations are correlated because of repeated measurements, hierarchical structures, clustered sampling, or differences between individuals or groups.
    • If the correlation can be adequately addressed by including appropriate fixed effects or another correlation structure, a GLM or another extended model may still be sufficient.
    • Therefore, model selection should not be based mechanically on whether a grouping variable exists. It should be based on the data-generating process and the structure of the errors.

    1. The Common Foundation of GLMs and GLMMs

    A GLM does not require the response variable to follow a normal distribution. It usually consists of three components:

    1. Random component: Specifies the probability distribution of the response, such as the normal, binomial, or Poisson distribution.
    2. Systematic component: Defines a linear predictor using the explanatory variables.
    3. Link function: Connects the expected value of the response to the linear predictor.

    The general form is:

    [
    g\left(E(Yi)\right)=\beta_0+\beta_1X{i1}+\cdots+\betapX{ip}
    ]

    where (g(\cdot)) is the link function, (Y_i) is the response for observation (i), and the (\beta) values are fixed-effect parameters.

    For example:

    • Binary outcomes commonly use a binomial distribution with a logit link.
    • Count outcomes commonly use a Poisson distribution with a log link.
    • Continuous outcomes can use a normal distribution with an identity link.

    A GLMM extends this framework by adding random effects:

    [
    g\left(E(Y{ij}\mid b_j)\right)
    =
    \beta_0+\beta_1X
    {ij}+\cdots+\betapX{pij}+b_j
    ]

    Here, (b_j) represents the random effect for group or individual (j). It captures differences between groups that are not explained by the observed predictors.

    2. The Key Question: Are the Observations Independent?

    A standard GLM generally assumes that different observations are independent. In this context, “independent” does not mean that the response variables have no real-world connection at all. It means that, after accounting for the explanatory variables in the model, the remaining errors do not show systematic correlation.

    If two observations share unmeasured influences, their errors may be correlated. Examples include:

    • Multiple measurements from the same patient over time;
    • Several members of the same household;
    • Multiple students in the same class;
    • Several respondents from the same geographic area;
    • Multiple records generated by the same device over time;
    • Annual business data from the same company.

    These observations are not fully independent. They may be similar because they share an environment, management practices, genetic background, device conditions, or individual characteristics.

    If a GLM is applied without accounting for this dependence, the estimated coefficients may sometimes remain close to the underlying values. However, the standard errors can be estimated incorrectly. This affects confidence intervals, significance tests, and overall conclusions. For example, a variable that is not truly significant may be incorrectly identified as significant, or predictive uncertainty may be underestimated.

    3. Fixed Effects and Random Effects

    Distinguishing fixed effects from random effects is central to understanding the difference between GLMs and GLMMs.

    3.1 Fixed Effects

    Fixed effects estimate the specific influence of variables of direct interest. Examples include:

    • The effect of a teaching method on academic performance;
    • The effect of age on the probability of disease;
    • The effect of advertising expenditure on sales;
    • The effect of temperature on equipment failure rates.

    Researchers typically care about the coefficients of these variables and want to generalize the results to populations under similar conditions.

    If the groups themselves are the focus of the study, or if there are only a small number of groups with clear individual meaning, the groups can also be included as fixed effects. For example, school identity can be entered as a categorical variable to estimate the difference between each school and a reference school.

    3.2 Random Effects

    Random effects describe variation among groups drawn from a broader population. The main goal is usually not to estimate a separate coefficient for every group, but to characterize the variation between groups.

    For example, when studying student performance across multiple schools, schools may differ in curriculum, teacher quality, and management practices. If the goal is to generalize the findings to a broader population of schools, school can be treated as a random effect.

    A random-intercept model can be written as:

    [
    g\left(E(Y{ij})\right)
    =
    \beta_0+\beta_1X
    {ij}+u_j
    ]

    where (u_j) represents the deviation of group (j) from the overall average level.

    If groups differ not only in their baseline levels but also in the strength of a predictor’s effect, a random slope can be added:

    [
    g\left(E(Y{ij})\right)
    =
    \beta_0+\beta_1X
    {ij}+u{0j}+u{1j}X_{ij}
    ]

    This specification allows groups to have different baseline levels and different effects of (X).

    4. A School–Class–Student Example

    Suppose you are studying the factors that affect student performance. The data may include:

    • Multiple schools;
    • Several classes within each school;
    • Multiple students within each class;
    • Multiple exam scores for each student.

    This creates a clear nested structure:

    [
    \text{Exam records} \subset \text{Students} \subset \text{Classes} \subset \text{Schools}
    ]

    Students in the same class may share teachers, course schedules, and classroom conditions, causing their scores to be correlated. Classes within the same school may also be affected by common school policies and resource allocation.

    Suppose the model includes only student-level characteristics, such as study time, family background, and attendance, while ignoring differences between schools and classes. The unexplained group effects will then be absorbed into the error term, creating correlation among the errors.

    A multilevel GLMM can be written as:

    [
    Y{ijk}
    =
    \beta_0+\beta_1X
    {ijk}+uk+v{jk}+\varepsilon_{ijk}
    ]

    where:

    • (i) identifies the student;
    • (j) identifies the class;
    • (k) identifies the school;
    • (u_k) is the school-level random effect;
    • (v_{jk}) is the class-level random effect within school (k);
    • (\varepsilon_{ijk}) is the individual-level residual error.

    If the outcome is a continuous score, a linear mixed model can be used. If the outcome is whether a student passes, a GLMM with a binomial distribution may be appropriate. If the outcome is a count, such as the number of exams taken or absences recorded, a Poisson or another count-based GLMM may be considered.

    5. Does Including a Grouping Variable Mean a GLM Is Always Sufficient?

    This is a common source of confusion.

    If all schools and classes in the study are of direct interest, and the researcher wants to estimate the difference for each school or class, they can be included as fixed effects. For example:

    [
    g(E(Y))=\beta0+\beta_1X+\gamma{\text{school}}+\delta_{\text{class}}
    ]

    This specification can explain systematic differences between schools and classes.

    However, adding grouping variables does not automatically guarantee that all observations are independent. Several issues may remain:

    1. The same student may have multiple measurements, creating within-student correlation.
    2. Unobserved common shocks may still affect students within the same class.
    3. Errors may be autocorrelated over time.
    4. Some group-level effects may not be fully captured by categorical variables.
    5. With limited data, including many fixed effects may result in too many parameters.

    Therefore, treating schools and classes as fixed effects is not equivalent to proving that the independence assumption required by a GLM has been satisfied. Residual diagnostics, the study design, and the data structure must all be considered.

    If there are only a few clearly defined grouping variables and the remaining errors can reasonably be treated as independent after adjustment, a GLM may remain a suitable candidate. If there are many groups, or if the goal is to generalize to groups that were not observed, a GLMM is often more appropriate.

    6. Situations Where a GLMM Is Usually Preferred

    6.1 Repeated Measures and Longitudinal Data

    The same subject is observed repeatedly at different time points. Because the measurements share subject-specific characteristics, they are usually not independent.

    For example, a study may record health indicators repeatedly for the same participants. A subject-level random intercept can represent baseline differences between individuals. If individuals also follow different trajectories over time, a random slope for time can be added.

    6.2 Hierarchical or Nested Data

    Examples include:

    • Employees within departments and departments within companies;
    • Students within classes and classes within schools;
    • Residents within communities and communities within regions.

    These structures are often suitable for multilevel GLMMs.

    6.3 Clustered Sampling

    When samples are selected by group, observations within the same group are often more similar. Ignoring the clustering effect can lead to overestimating the effective sample size.

    6.4 Multicenter or Multisite Studies

    Different sites may vary in equipment, personnel, environment, and management procedures. Treating site as a random effect can account for unobserved baseline differences and improve the generalizability of the model.

    6.5 Longitudinal Panel Data

    Panel data include both individual and time dimensions. The analysis must account for differences between individuals as well as the correlation among observations from the same individual over time. Random effects or specialized correlation structures are often needed.

    7. How to Choose Between a GLM, a GLMM, and Other Models

    The following steps provide a practical framework.

    Step 1: Identify the Response Type

    Determine whether the outcome is continuous, binary, a count, a proportion, or another type. Then select an appropriate probability distribution and link function.

    Step 2: Map the Data Hierarchy

    Check whether the data contain levels such as individuals, households, classes, schools, regions, or time points. Also determine whether the same subject or unit appears in multiple records.

    Step 3: Define the Research Objective

    If specific groups are themselves the focus, fixed effects may be appropriate. If the groups are representative samples from a larger population, random effects are often more suitable.

    Step 4: Identify Possible Within-Group Correlation

    Use the study design, domain knowledge, and descriptive analysis to determine whether observations within a group are more similar than observations across groups. Do not rely only on a statistical test, because the result can depend on sample size, model specification, and the number of groups.

    Step 5: Fit and Compare Candidate Models

    Possible candidates include:

    • A GLM that ignores group structure;
    • A GLM with group-level fixed effects;
    • A GLMM with a random intercept;
    • A GLMM with both random intercepts and random slopes.

    The comparison should consider coefficient stability, standard errors, information criteria, predictive performance, residual behavior, and whether the model matches the research objective.

    8. Common Misconceptions

    Misconception 1: Any Categorical Variable Requires a GLMM

    A categorical variable does not automatically imply a random effect. The key question is whether the variable represents a fixed factor whose specific effects should be estimated, or group-level variation sampled from a broader population.

    Misconception 2: Adding a School Variable Automatically Makes Observations Independent

    Fixed effects can explain average differences between groups, but they do not necessarily remove all within-group correlation. In particular, they do not automatically handle repeated measurements or temporal autocorrelation.

    Misconception 3: A GLMM Is Always More Advanced or Better Than a GLM

    A GLMM is more complex. It requires estimating random-effect variances and may encounter convergence problems, singular fits, or identification difficulties. If the data are genuinely independent, a GLMM can add unnecessary complexity.

    Misconception 4: Random Effects Work Better with Fewer Groups

    Random effects require a sufficient number of groups to support stable variance-component estimation. When there are very few groups, the estimates may be unstable. The decision should then be made carefully based on the research objective, study design, and sensitivity analyses.

    9. Summary

    The fundamental difference between a GLM and a GLMM is not whether the response variable is normally distributed. It is whether the model needs to account for correlation associated with groups, individuals, or time.

    • A GLM is suitable when observations are approximately independent.
    • A GLMM is suitable when the data contain hierarchical structures, repeated measurements, clustered sampling, or individual heterogeneity.
    • Fixed effects estimate the effects of clearly defined variables or specific groups.
    • Random effects describe variation among groups drawn from a larger population.
    • Including a grouping variable as a fixed effect does not necessarily resolve every dependence problem.
    • Model selection should consider the data structure, research objective, error assumptions, and the intended interpretation of the results.

    In practice, the most important step is not to decide immediately between a GLM and a GLMM. Instead, start with three questions:

    1. Does the data contain clustering or repeated observations?
    2. Has the model adequately explained the resulting dependence?
    3. Should the conclusions describe the observed groups, or generalize to a broader population of groups?

    Answering these questions provides a more reliable basis for choosing between a GLM, a GLMM, or another suitable model.