Choosing AI Coding Tools: A Task-Type Based Combination Guide
Selecting the right AI coding tools requires evaluating task types and combining them accordingly. This article explores how to choose tools based on task scale, write effective rule files for project compliance, address common AI coding errors, control costs, manage rule exemptions, set up CI checklists, and implement a combined workflow across architecture exploration, local coding, and daily maintenance.
1. How to Choose AI Coding Tools: Task Scale Matters
Before selecting a tool, first categorize the task. Tasks such as building from scratch, dealing with abstract goals, and requiring upfront design plans can be classified as planning tasks. Tasks like modifying an existing module in a codebase, fixing a single point defect, or unifying code styles can be classified as local tasks.
Planning tasks are suited for tools with strong autonomous planning capabilities. These tools can break down requirements into modules, dependencies, and step-by-step plans, making them ideal for game mechanic drafts or initial system architecture designs that require divergent thinking and logical connections. However, the output plan still requires human review. Provided the task description is thorough and the plan is reviewed, the manual effort for decomposition may be reduced, though the extent depends on project complexity and tool version, which must be measured with real tasks.
Local tasks are better handled by tools capable of reading the current file and nearby code. These tools have a smaller scope of change and are less likely to affect unrelated modules. When selecting tools, it is recommended to record test results using the following table.
| Evaluation Metric | Measurement Method | Required Information to Record |
|---|---|---|
| First-time Pass Rate | Proportion of tasks passed on the first acceptance in the same batch | Tool name, version number, test date |
| Rework Count | Number of modification rounds | Task ID, task description |
| Change Scope | Number of files touched | File list before and after changes |
| Completion Time | Time from issuing the instruction to acceptance pass | Operator, environment info |
Data sources must be traceable. Without actual test data, it is not advisable to assert that a specific tool has a lower error rate.
2. Writing Rule Files: Ensuring AI Complies with Project Styles
In medium to large projects with multiple modules, AI-generated code not conforming to existing specifications is the most common issue. The cause is usually that the tool does not understand the project’s layered structure, naming conventions, and historical agreements, so it starts writing based on general patterns. The solution is to maintain a clear rule file in the project root directory, outlining key conventions.
Here is a reusable template:
# Project Rules## Project Overview- Project name, tech stack, runtime environment versions## Directory and Layering- controller: Only handles parameter validation and response assembly- service: Contains business logic- repository: Only handles data access## Naming Conventions- Class names use PascalCase, method names use camelCase- Database fields use snake_case## Exception Handling- Business exceptions uniformly inherit from BizException- Swallowing exceptions directly in the service layer is prohibited## Utility Class Whitelist- Date processing uses DateUtils; direct calls to java.util.Date formatting methods are prohibited- HTTP calls use HttpClientWrapper## Design Pattern Conventions- Creation of payment channels uses the factory pattern, entry point is PaymentFactory## Prohibited Actions- Writing business logic in controllers is prohibited- Directly modifying historical scripts in the migrations directory is prohibited## Modification Scope- A single task is only allowed to modify files under the modules/order directory## Acceptance Commands- mvn test- npm run lint
The more specific the rule file, the less likely the tool is to deviate from the direction. Each rule should be manually verifiable and also checkable by automated scripts.
3. Common Errors and Corresponding Solutions
The most common error in multi-step tasks is goal forgetting. Constraints determined early on may be ignored in subsequent execution, resulting in rework. The countermeasure is to break tasks into shorter chains and re-verify the constraint checklist at the end of each segment. The length of the short task chain needs to be tested individually; a common practice is to start with short steps and adjust after observing the rework rate.
The second common error is style drift. If the internal code style of the project itself is inconsistent, the tool will randomly imitate one of the writing styles. The countermeasure is to designate a module as an example first, and note in the rule file: “New code should follow the style of the modules/order directory.”
The third error is bypassing rules without authorization. Some tools actively skip restrictions when they determine a conflict between rules and the task. The countermeasure is to set all sensitive operations—such as deleting files, modifying permission configurations, and changing database structures—to require manual confirmation.
The fourth error is increased costs due to repeated calls. Frequently triggering the planning and execution loop will quickly consume quota. The countermeasure is discussed in the next section on budget allocation.
The fifth error is interface or plugin anomalies after version updates. The countermeasure is to lock versions and verify upgrades in an isolated environment first.
4. Cost Control: Allocating Budget by Task
The key to cost control is setting different budget limits for different tasks. Simple rule-based tasks, such as format adjustments, renaming, or adding comments, can use lower-cost models. Architecture design tasks require more reasoning and planning and can be allocated a higher quota.
Regarding the cost difference between screenshots and text descriptions, actual measurement is required. Token consumption depends on the complexity of the screenshot, the model’s billing method, and the description length. The measurement method is to use the same UI task, input it using both screenshot and text description methods, record the Token usage and completion time for each, and then compare the results.
A monthly review should be conducted. Count the time and Token consumption of various tasks, organize repetitive tasks into fixed processes, and reduce the overhead of exploring from scratch each time.
5. What Records to Keep When Relaxing Rules
During the creative development phase, moderately relaxing rules can improve efficiency. However, in projects with high compliance requirements, any rule exemption must be recorded. Each time a rule is relaxed, at least the following should be recorded:
- Approver and approval time
- Rule ID and specific content relaxed
- Reason for relaxation and scope of impact
- Complete operation log of the tool
- Rollback plan and the person responsible for executing the rollback
In production environments, tools should be prohibited from automatically skipping any rules. Modifications to rule files must also go through version management and require human review.
6. Building a CI Checklist
In high-frequency development scenarios, tool anomalies can disrupt the workflow. Writing recovery procedures into CI or team operation manuals can reduce troubleshooting time. The recommended checklist is as follows:
- Lock tool version numbers and plugin version numbers, and record them in the project configuration
- Back up configuration files before modifying editor or tool configurations
- Check if the rule file exists and verify its format is correct
- Run code style checks and unit tests
- When a tool crashes, first save the summary of the current session, then restart the tool
- After restarting, load the summary of the previous session and run git diff to verify recent changes
- Verify unfinished tasks one by one to avoid omissions
Backup and version locking are prerequisites for the recovery process. Without backups, it is impossible to confirm whether the configuration is complete during recovery.
7. Implementing a Combined Workflow
Based on the previous analysis, the development process can be divided into three phases, assigned to different types of tools.
| Phase | Task Type | Recommended Tool Type | Rule File | Budget Quota | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architecture Exploration | Build from scratch, design planning | Autonomous Planning | Overall project rules and requirement docs | High | Plan passes human review |
| Local Coding | Module modification, single point fix | Local Editing | Rule file for the corresponding module | Medium | Passes unit tests and style checks |
| Daily Maintenance | Format adjustment, renaming, comments | Low-cost Model | General rule file | Low | Passes style checks |
Specific steps are as follows:
- In the architecture exploration phase, write the requirements and constraints into an independent planning document, have the tool output a technical plan, and finalize it after human review.
- Break down the finalized plan into small tasks and assign them to local editing tools one by one. Each task must specify the rule file to be followed in the instruction.
- For differentiated requirements across different modules, split the rules into separate files, such as
rules/order.mdandrules/payment.md, and explicitly state “Execute according to rules/order.md” in the task instructions. Whether the referenced file can be read correctly should first be verified with a small task. - After each phase, check the results against the acceptance criteria, and record the time and Token usage to provide data for the next round of tool selection.
The division of labor among tools is essentially assigning different types of work to specialized roles, and then ensuring the output meets project specifications through rule files and acceptance criteria. Tool selection conclusions should be based on the team’s own test data, rather than external reviews.
