UEFI Graphics Development with an AI Coding Assistant: A Practical Retrospective
This article presents a practical retrospective on using an AI coding assistant to build a UEFI Breakout game with Chinese-character rendering. Starting from a seven-file legacy codebase, the assistant performed a structured code review, then helped diagnose a crash caused by invalid display-mode data after SetMode and an incorrect GOP protocol GUID that silently prevented graphics initialization. The article documents the debugging process and distills four collaboration practices: incremental verification, logging first, treating the AI as an analysis partner, and keeping firmware domain expertise in the loop.
Why Use UEFI as a Testbed for AI Coding?
AI coding assistants are already quite capable in ordinary web backend and scripting tasks, where problems can often be cross-checked against search engines and existing documentation. UEFI, by contrast, is a classic bare-metal environment: there is no operating system to fall back on, no mature debugger ecosystem, and very limited error reporting. When a program fails, it often simply exits or hangs.
That environment places much higher demands on code quality and debugging discipline than ordinary application development. It therefore provides a useful test of how well an AI coding assistant handles real engineering problems.
The goal of this experiment was specific: implement a Breakout game that supports Chinese-character rendering in a firmware environment and make it run reliably. Development was divided into two rounds. The first round focused on getting the program to run. The second focused on structural optimization and refinement. This “make it work, then make it better” rhythm is also a widely accepted best practice in embedded and firmware development: before basic functionality is verified, pursuing code aesthetics too early usually costs more than it saves.
Starting from Legacy Code: Have the AI Review First
The experiment did not start from zero. It began with code left over from another development session. The code consisted of seven files and used a modular design: the entry function, main loop, game logic, rendering, and input handling were separated. Structurally, it looked reasonably clean.
But “looks clean” and “runs correctly” can be separated by several hidden pitfalls.
The first instruction was simple: Review this code and identify potential issues. The AI coding assistant inspected each module and, after a few minutes, produced a list of issues: timing risks in protocol calls, pointer lifetime problems, resource initialization ordering, and other categories of hidden faults. It also indicated that the code should run once those issues were fixed.
This step illustrates a key value of AI-assisted development: before changing any code, have the model build a global understanding of the codebase and produce a structured issue list. That not only makes human review easier but also provides a clear roadmap for subsequent fixes.
Issue 1: A Crash and a Dangling Pointer
After the review, I compiled and ran the program immediately. It started successfully, printed startup logs to the screen, and entered the game main loop. Then it exited directly, without any error message.
In a UEFI environment, this kind of “silent exit” is one of the most difficult failures to handle. There is no stack trace and no exception pop-up; all information must be dug out manually. The approach was to add logging and narrow the scope:
- Instrument critical paths. I asked the AI to insert debug output at the entry point, protocol acquisition, graphics initialization, the main loop, and other key points, and to monitor execution progress in real time over serial output.
- Locate the failure. The logs showed that the program failed after calls to the Graphics Output Protocol (GOP). That narrowed the investigation to a small section of graphics initialization code.
- Analyze the root cause. After a careful comparison, the AI found the problem: the display-mode information pointer returned by QueryMode points essentially to temporary memory. After SetMode is called to switch display modes, that memory is no longer valid, and dereferencing it later becomes a classic dangling-pointer access.
The fix was straightforward: after SetMode completes, reacquire the framebuffer and related display information before performing any rendering operations. With that change, the program no longer crashed.
This episode is representative. It exposes a classic trap in firmware development: a pointer returned by a protocol is not necessarily a long-lived resource handle; its lifetime is tied to a particular call context. The AI could infer the risk from static code review and then confirm the root cause through runtime logs. That combination of static analysis and dynamic verification is the standard methodology human engineers use when debugging firmware.
Issue 2: An Incorrect Protocol GUID
After the crash was fixed, the program ran stably, but the graphical interface still did not appear. I fed the symptoms back to the AI. After analyzing the runtime output, it identified the second issue: the GUID used for the Graphics Output Protocol was incorrect.
The relevant point is that in mainstream UEFI development frameworks, more than one GUID is defined around graphics output, corresponding to different protocol versions and purposes. When a developer looks up a protocol through Boot Services, passing the wrong GUID does not produce an error. The lookup simply fails to find the target protocol, and subsequent initialization fails silently.
This kind of error cannot be detected at compile time. It can only be located by comparing runtime logs with protocol knowledge. After the GUID was corrected, graphics initialization finally worked, the game appeared correctly on screen, and the first-round goal of getting the program to run was achieved.
Lessons: Four Principles for AI-Assisted Low-Level Development
Looking back at the whole process, a few collaboration practices are broadly useful:
- Commit in small steps and verify incrementally. Do not expect to issue one instruction such as “write the whole game” and get a reliable result. Split the work into small steps: code review, compilation and execution, fault isolation, and item-by-item fixes. Verify each step in practice; the AI’s performance will be much more stable.
- Log first. In a bare-metal environment, serial logs are essentially the only observation channel. Have the AI establish comprehensive debug output before discussing feature implementation. This saves considerable time.
- Treat the AI as an analysis partner, not a code generator. The two most effective interactions in this experiment both began with the model producing an issue list and root-cause analysis. A human confirmed the analysis before changes were made. This avoided introducing new problems through blind edits.
- Keep domain knowledge in the loop. Firmware-specific knowledge such as protocol-pointer lifetime and GUID matching can be retrieved and reasoned about with AI assistance, but developers must be able to judge whether the conclusions are reasonable. The final check remains human.
Low-level development may be a niche area, but it is a good mirror for testing an AI coding assistant’s engineering ability. When the environment is no longer forgiving, what matters is a systematic troubleshooting method and rigorous verification habits. That is exactly where human engineers and AI should complement each other most.
