Evaluating Multimodal Image Generation Models in a Domestic Chip Environment: Methods and Checklists

    Text-to-image evaluation has shifted from "can it generate an image" to "can it accurately understand complex requirements." This article presents a practical evaluation framework for open-source multimodal image generation models whose data processing, training, and inference all run on domestic chips. It covers the task boundaries of text-to-image models, the potential value of running the full pipeline on a single hardware and software stack, the environment information to record before testing, a five-dimension scoring system with suggested weights, test case design with failure logging, structured prompt writing, a deployment checklist, trade-offs among speed, quality, and cost, and safety and compliance considerations. Developers can use it to answer four key questions: is the model usable, is the training pipeline transferable, is deployment cost manageable, and can the system deliver stable output in production?

    Background

    In recent years, the focus of text-to-image model evaluation has shifted from “whether an image can be generated” to “whether complex requirements can be understood accurately.” Users expect models to understand Chinese semantics, follow composition instructions, render readable text, and maintain consistency of subjects, relationships, and details in a specified style.

    For open-source multimodal image generation models whose data processing, training, and inference are all completed in a domestic chip environment, the key question is whether the hardware and software stack can support the full model lifecycle. For developers, this comes down to four questions: Is model quality at a usable level? Can the training pipeline be migrated? Is deployment cost controllable? Can the system produce stable output in real business scenarios?

    1. Task Boundaries of Text-to-Image Models

    A text-to-image model takes a natural language prompt as input and outputs a corresponding image. The input can be Chinese or English, and subject matter may include photorealistic imagery, concept design, children’s illustration, poster drafts, and scientific diagrams.

    Compared with traditional image generation approaches, multimodal models place greater emphasis on combining semantic understanding with visual expression. The model must recognize objects and also understand the relationships between them: the number of subjects, front/back and left/right positions, proportions, occlusion, background environment, artistic style, whether a title or caption is needed, and the overall mood and color scheme. Judging model quality by image sharpness alone is therefore insufficient.

    2. Potential Value of Running the Full Pipeline on Domestic Chips

    In the past, many models were first trained on mature, general-purpose acceleration hardware and then migrated to other hardware for inference. This shortens the development cycle, but the operators, memory management strategies, and parallelization schemes validated during training do not necessarily transfer directly.

    If data preprocessing, training, evaluation, and inference all run on the same domestic chip stack, three types of value are possible. Each must be verified independently; a successful end-to-end run alone does not justify conclusions.

    Software-hardware co-optimization. Training involves matrix computation, attention mechanisms, normalization, sampling, mixed precision, and distributed communication. Verification methods include: measuring operator coverage for the model’s workload; comparing training iteration speed and convergence curves against a reference platform; and checking whether numerical errors fall within an acceptable range.

    Hardware supply and deployment autonomy. In government, enterprise, education, research, and private-deployment scenarios, whether a model can run on designated hardware is often as important as generation quality. Verification methods include: recording end-to-end deployment time in the target environment; compiling a list of required driver and firmware versions; and measuring fault recovery time.

    Engineering consistency. Keeping training and inference environments consistent reduces precision drift and performance fluctuation during cross-platform migration. Verification methods include: for the same batch of prompts, comparing outputs between the post-training validation environment and the production inference environment; and checking whether repeated runs with the same configuration produce reproducible results.

    3. Environment Information to Record Before Evaluation

    Many practical articles describe results without specifying running conditions. To make results reproducible or comparable, at least the following should be recorded:

    • Chip model, driver version, compiler, and operator library version;
    • Deep learning framework and its version;
    • Model weight version and source;
    • Training data scale, cleaning rules, and labeling method;
    • Parallelization strategy, including the combination of data parallelism, model parallelism, and pipeline parallelism;
    • Inference precision, such as fp32, fp16, or bf16;
    • Sampler, sampling steps, random seed, and guidance scale.

    This information may seem tedious, but it determines whether test results can be reproduced by others.

    4. Evaluation Dimensions and Suggested Weights

    Score five dimensions on a scale of 1 to 5 and combine them using weights:

    • Semantic adherence, 30%: Are all required subjects present? Are key constraints preserved?
    • Composition stability, 20%: Are multiple subjects, spatial relationships, and proportions correct?
    • Text rendering, 15%: Are characters correct? Are multi-line layouts properly aligned?
    • Style consistency, 15%: Are differences across repeated generations in the same style acceptable?
    • Inference stability, 20%: Latency, peak memory usage, failure rate, and output consistency.

    Weights can be adjusted by business needs. For example, poster-related businesses may raise the weight of text rendering, while batch content production places more emphasis on inference stability.

    5. Test Cases and Failure Logging

    The test set should cover both simple and complex prompts. Record the input, output, and failure reason for every case; do not keep only successful images. The following are recommended test scenarios; the failure types listed are common issues to watch for, not completed test results:

    • Short-title cases: e.g., “Summer drink poster with the title ‘Refreshing Lemon’.” Check whether title characters are complete and the font rendering is stable.
    • Multi-line text cases: prompts containing three or more lines of caption text. Watch for missing characters, misaligned line breaks, and mismatched text and imagery.
    • Complex composition cases: prompts with three or more subjects and explicit left/right relationships. Watch for incorrect subject counts, subject merging, and distorted proportions.
    • Chinese modifier cases: e.g., “At dusk by the sea, a person in a light-colored coat stands beside a rock, with a low lighthouse in the distance.” Watch for missing figures or lighthouse, and modifiers attached to the wrong objects.

    Each record can be organized with the following fields: case ID, prompt, description of model output, pass/fail, failure type, likely cause, and improvement method. This makes it possible to attribute problems to the prompt, the model’s capabilities, or the inference implementation.

    6. Structured Prompt Writing

    To reduce semantic ambiguity, prompts can follow a fixed structure:

    1. Subject:
    2. Scene:
    3. Composition:
    4. Style:
    5. Lighting and color:
    6. Detail requirements:
    7. Constraints:

    For example, to generate an educational illustration: the subject is the sun, planetary orbits, and outer space; the scene is a children’s science picture-book page; the composition places the sun on the left with several planets distributed along the orbit; the style is simple, bright, cartoon illustration; lighting and color use a deep blue background with vivid, high-contrast colors; detail requirements state that planet sizes differ noticeably and orbit lines are clear; constraints require a clean image with no unrelated figures or complex decoration.

    This format makes comparison testing easy: change one field at a time and observe whether the output changes accordingly. Two writing tips: place the most important constraints early in the prompt, and avoid requesting conflicting styles such as “photorealistic” and “cartoon” at the same time.

    7. Deployment Checklist

    Training completion does not mean the model is ready for production. Verify the following before deployment:

    1. Is the weight format compatible with the inference framework, and is the conversion process documented?
    2. Does the inference framework version match the supported operator list?
    3. After precision conversion, are there noticeable changes in color, texture, or local structure compared with the baseline?
    4. At the target batch size, is peak memory usage within budget?
    5. Has the relationship between batch size and throughput been measured?
    6. Does time-to-first-image meet interactivity requirements?
    7. Do failure logs include request parameters, random seed, version numbers, and error stack traces?
    8. Can a historical output be reproduced with the same configuration?

    Configuration can be centralized in a single file, for example:

    1. model_version: record the weight version
    2. dtype: bf16
    3. sampler: record the sampler name
    4. steps: 30
    5. seed: 42
    6. batch_size: 4

    Fill in actual values based on real tests; the example above only illustrates the field structure.

    8. Trade-offs Among Speed, Quality, and Cost

    Increasing sampling steps usually improves detail but increases latency. Lowering precision reduces memory and compute costs but may affect color and local structure. Design drafts can prioritize speed, promotional images prioritize detail, batch production balances throughput and stability, and interactive applications prioritize time-to-first-image.

    9. Safety and Compliance

    Production environments must handle prohibited content, copyright risks, and portrait and privacy information. A typical workflow includes: prompt review, image classification, manual review of high-risk content, retention of generation logs with a defined retention period, and labeling of generated content. In fields such as medicine, education, and news, generated images may contradict facts and should not be used directly as evidence.

    10. Conclusion

    Running the full pipeline on domestic chips is an engineering goal that can be objectively verified. A model’s performance on Chinese prompts, complex compositions, text rendering, and style consistency must be judged with a test set containing real inputs, outputs, and failure records. Until environment documentation, dimension-based testing, and deployment checks are complete, only a qualified judgment of its applicability is possible. Only when all metrics meet business thresholds can such a solution realistically support large-scale deployment.