Evaluating the Real Capabilities of LLMs in Programming and Visualization Tasks

    Large language models (LLMs) have advanced rapidly in code generation, UI design, and agentic workflows. However, transitioning from generating isolated examples to delivering continuous modifications in real codebases requires a deeper evaluation. This article explores how to assess LLM capabilities beyond surface-level aesthetics, covering context understanding, verification habits, error localization, and algorithmic accuracy. It also provides practical guidelines for developers to build a scientific evaluation framework and effectively manage LLM-driven engineering tasks.

    In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have developed rapidly in areas such as code generation, UI creation, and intelligent agents. Many models can quickly generate web pages, animations, and interactive demos, with outputs that look increasingly complete visually. However, once a task shifts from “generating an example” to “making continuous modifications in a real codebase,” evaluation criteria can no longer rely solely on whether the interface looks good, whether the code volume is sufficient, or whether the model can produce a seemingly detailed thought process.

    The real questions worth exploring are: Can the model understand the context? Can it advance according to a plan? Can it proactively verify the results of each step? Can it distinguish between environmental issues and code issues when errors occur? And ultimately, can it deliver runnable, testable, and maintainable results?

    1. From “Generation” to “Delivery”: A Clear Capability Gap

    In simple tasks, LLMs usually perform well. For example, generating a page based on a text description, implementing a small animation, or building a basic data structure. These tasks share common characteristics:

    • Small code scale;
    • Relatively simple dependencies;
    • Intuitive verification methods;
    • Easy to rewrite entirely after an error;
    • No need for long-term context retention.

    Complex engineering refactoring, however, is entirely different. A real project may contain multiple modules, strict type constraints, existing tests, complex build processes, and a large number of implicit business rules. In this scenario, the model needs to handle the following simultaneously:

    1. Understand the existing project structure, rather than just focusing on the current file;
    2. Identify the differences between requirements and existing behavior;
    3. Break down the goal into multiple interdependent steps;
    4. Promptly execute compilation, testing, and static analysis after modifying code;
    5. Locate the root cause based on error messages;
    6. Avoid breaking other functionalities while fixing a local error;
    7. Retain memory of the task objective throughout the process.

    Therefore, a model’s ability to generate hundreds of lines of code in a few minutes does not mean it is capable of completing complex engineering tasks. Generation speed is merely input-output efficiency; engineering reliability depends on understanding, verification, and error-correction capabilities.

    2. Common Issues Exposed in Complex Coding Tasks

    2.1 Misdiagnosing Code Errors as Environment Issues

    In system-level projects, compilation failures can stem from multiple causes, including inconsistent dependency versions, configuration errors, mismatched interface definitions, unsatisfied lifecycle or type constraints, and code generated by the model that fails to meet project specifications.

    A common problem is that, without fully examining the error message, the model directly attributes the failure to “cache anomalies,” “environmental instability,” or “build system issues.” Clearing the cache can sometimes help, but it cannot replace error diagnosis. A more logical processing sequence should be:

    1. Read the complete error message
    2. ↓
    3. Confirm which module and which line failed
    4. ↓
    5. Determine if it is a syntax, type, dependency, configuration, or environment issue
    6. ↓
    7. Make minimal-range modifications
    8. ↓
    9. Recompile and verify

    If the model does not complete this closed loop and moves directly to the next step, subsequent steps are likely built upon erroneous code. As modifications accumulate, a single local error can cascade into a massive chain of errors.

    2.2 Lack of a “Verification-First” Execution Habit

    Complex tasks are not suitable for generating all code at once. A safer approach is to execute the corresponding verification after completing each stage. For example:

    • After modifying a data structure, run type checks first;
    • After completing core logic, run unit tests first;
    • After integrating an external module, verify API calls first;
    • After completing UI interactions, check if critical operations are usable;
    • After completing all changes, run the full test suite.

    If the model only reports “completed” without showing actual verification results, the conclusion itself is not credible. Especially in agentic programming scenarios, the model might judge progress based on whether files were written or task steps were executed, but “file changed” does not equal “feature correct.”

    2.3 Masking a Lack of Overall Understanding with Numerous Local Modifications

    When a model cannot explain the cause of a failure, it tends to adopt a “shotgun-style fix” strategy: adjusting variables, interfaces, conditions, and configurations across multiple files simultaneously, attempting to make the error disappear through continuous trial and error.

    While this approach might change error messages in the short term, it typically leads to three consequences:

    • The scope of modifications expands rapidly, making rollback difficult;
    • Originally independent issues are mixed together;
    • Even if it eventually compiles, existing features may be broken.

    High-quality engineering fixes should follow the principle of “small step modifications, prompt verification, and context retention.” Every modification should be able to answer three questions:

    1. Why change this?
    2. What problem is expected to be solved?
    3. How to prove the problem has been solved?

    If these three questions cannot be answered, the scope of modifications should not be expanded.

    3. Good Visuals Do Not Equal Correct Interaction Logic

    LLMs can usually quickly produce fairly complete results in web visual generation, including gradient backgrounds, particle animations, card layouts, shadow effects, and dynamic feedback. These elements improve the first impression of a demo, but visual completeness and functional completeness are two different dimensions.

    Taking a common interactive demo as an example, evaluating a page should not just observe “whether the visuals are rich,” but also check:

    • Whether elements are correctly arranged according to rules;
    • Whether interaction areas and display areas are aligned;
    • Whether the state changes correctly after a user click;
    • Whether boundary conditions are handled;
    • Whether the system can recover after a failure;
    • Whether the page remains usable at different screen sizes;
    • Whether animations serve the functionality rather than mask problems.

    For example, in a pathfinding or maze demo, even if it can display grids, numbers, and the training process, it does not mean the algorithm is implemented correctly. You also need to confirm whether the map coordinates, action coordinates, and rendering coordinates use the same definition; whether the agent actually moves according to the policy; whether the training results are reproducible; whether the termination conditions are accurate; and whether the values displayed on the interface correspond to the current state.

    4. Algorithm Demos Must Verify Both “Results” and “Process”

    In reinforcement learning, search algorithms, or simulation systems, models can easily generate code that “looks like an algorithm,” but whether the algorithm is actually effective requires establishing observable verification metrics.

    Taking a grid environment as an example, at least the following should be checked:

    Environment Modeling

    • Are obstacles, starting points, and endpoints clearly defined?
    • Does each position have a unique coordinate?
    • Is out-of-bounds behavior clearly defined?
    • Are there conflict resolution rules between different entities?

    Action Execution

    • Is the action set complete?
    • Does each action map to the correct direction?
    • Are illegal actions rejected or penalized?
    • Is the state consistent before and after movement?

    Training Process

    • Do the state space and action space match?
    • Does the reward function induce reasonable behavior?
    • Do the learning parameters actually take effect in the code?
    • Do results gradually improve as training epochs change?
    • Is convergence achieved accidentally, rather than being terminated early by incorrect conditions?

    Visualization Synchronization

    • Do the map layer, value layer, and agent layer use the same coordinate system?
    • Does the animation display lag behind the actual state?
    • Are the values on the page derived from real training data?
    • Are old states cleared after a reset?

    Only when the algorithm logic, execution results, and page display are all consistent can the demo be considered reliable.

    5. Building a More Scientific LLM Evaluation Method

    For developers, evaluating a model cannot rely on a single experience, nor can it rely solely on the visual effects from a promotional page. It is recommended to establish a task checklist across the following dimensions.

    5.1 Task Understanding Capability

    After providing clear requirements, observe whether the model can:

    • Summarize the existing code structure;
    • Identify key dependencies;
    • Point out potential risks;
    • Ask necessary clarifying questions;
    • Provide a phased execution plan.

    Asking questions proactively does not indicate a lack of capability. For projects with ambiguous requirements, being able to promptly confirm boundaries is more reliable than directly writing large amounts of code.

    5.2 Execution and Verification Capability

    Focus on whether the model actually executed:

    • Compilation;
    • Unit tests;
    • Integration tests;
    • Static analysis;
    • UI interaction verification;
    • Exception scenario verification.

    Do not just accept text descriptions like “tests passed.” You should require the model to provide actual command results, failure messages, and changes before and after the fix whenever possible.

    5.3 Error Localization Capability

    You can artificially inject common issues, such as interface type mismatches, missing configurations, boundary condition errors, or coordinate misalignment, and then observe whether the model can:

    • Accurately recount the error;
    • Assess the scope of impact;
    • Propose a minimal fix;
    • Re-verify after modification;
    • Avoid introducing new, unrelated changes.

    5.4 Long-Process Stability

    Split the task into multiple stages with dependencies, and observe whether the model can maintain goal consistency after continuous operation over a period of time. Long-process tasks are most likely to expose issues like context loss, plan drift, and repetitive modifications.

    6. Practical Recommendations for Developers Using LLMs

    To mitigate risks, you can adopt the following workflows:

    First, let the model read the project and generate a plan before allowing it to make large-scale modifications.

    Second, break large tasks into small, independently verifiable tasks, handling only one clear goal at a time.

    Third, set acceptance criteria for each stage, such as “compilation passes,” “new tests pass,” or “the UI can complete a full operation.”

    Fourth, require the model to explain its reasoning before making changes and to explain the verification results after.

    Fifth, when encountering compilation failures, prioritize retaining the full error message. Do not directly accept unproven explanations like “cache issues” or “environment issues.”

    Sixth, review change summaries regularly. If the number of modifications suddenly increases abnormally, it usually means the model has deviated from the original problem, and you should roll back and re-analyze.

    Seventh, evaluate visual demos and core logic separately. The interface can be optimized later, but the core state, data flow, and algorithmic results must be correct first.

    Conclusion

    The true value of an LLM lies not in its ability to quickly generate a snippet of pretty code, but in its ability to translate requirements into correct implementations and prove the results are reliable through continuous verification. For complex engineering tasks, passing compilation is just the baseline; correct functionality, stable behavior, controllable modifications, and reproducible results are more critical metrics.

    From a practical standpoint, current LLMs already possess strong efficiency advantages in prototyping, styling, and small-scale feature development. However, in large codebase refactoring, continuous debugging, complex state synchronization, and multi-step autonomous execution, they still require developers to provide clear constraints and human supervision.

    Therefore, when selecting and evaluating models, you should not only look at the demo effects but also pay attention to whether they possess engineering closed-loop capabilities: understanding requirements, formulating plans, executing modifications, discovering problems, locating root causes, and completing verification, while remaining cautious rather than blindly expanding modifications upon failure. Only through this comprehensive set of standards can you truly determine whether a model is suitable for entering the production development pipeline.