How Much Can Free Credits Really Buy? A Practical Method for Evaluating AI Coding Assistants

    Free credits do not directly translate into usable tokens or completed requests. This guide explains how to convert credits into successful requests and token volume while accounting for input pricing, cache hits, output length, and retries. It also covers utilization-based inference costs, TTFT and TPS measurement, benchmarking methodology, and a practical checklist for comparing AI coding assistants.

    The Short Version

    A credit allowance is not the same as the number of tokens you can use. The number of requests that a given budget supports depends on pricing, cache-hit rate, retry rate, and output length. When evaluating an AI coding assistant, compare TTFT, TPS, supported capabilities, and cost per completed task—not just the headline credit amount.

    This article covers three areas:

    1. How to convert a credit allowance into tokens, including a complete example.
    2. How utilization changes the cost per unit.
    3. How to measure TTFT and TPS, including a Python script and recommended reporting methodology.

    All prices and hardware figures in this article are hypothetical and are intended only to demonstrate the calculations. Replace them with current prices from the relevant provider before making a purchasing decision.

    1. What Changes in Credit Allowances May Indicate

    When a provider frequently adjusts its credit allowance, the changes may offer signals in three areas. These are only hypotheses and should be validated against pricing, cache-hit rates, and measured latency.

    First, the point at which credits stop increasing may be close to the provider’s cost boundary. Subsidies usually grow only while marginal costs remain manageable. If an allowance remains unchanged while the user base grows significantly, the provider may be tightening cost controls.

    Second, a substantial increase in credits may indicate a change in deployment strategy—for example, a transition from forwarding requests to an upstream API to operating a self-managed inference cluster. Such a change can affect latency and reliability. Providers do not usually disclose their exact architecture, so announcements and measurements should be treated as the primary sources of evidence.

    Third, if usage remains flat after additional credits are introduced, product capabilities or usage friction may be the main constraint. Price is not necessarily the only issue. Reliability for your workloads, ease of integration, and output consistency all affect whether users continue using a service.

    Credit figures circulating online should always be matched to a specific time period, platform, model version, and official announcement. Verify them independently. This article does not cite specific credit figures.

    2. What Makes Up Inference Cost

    The unit cost of large-model inference mainly consists of four components:

    1. GPU amortization: The cost of purchasing or renting hardware, converted from GPU-hours into a cost per request.
    2. Memory usage and concurrency efficiency: Larger models and longer contexts allow fewer concurrent requests per GPU, increasing the cost per token.
    3. Scheduling and utilization: Batching policies and queueing mechanisms determine actual GPU utilization. If utilization remains low, costs cannot be reduced effectively.
    4. Operations and redundancy: Spare nodes, monitoring, and on-call operations are distributed across tokens to maintain availability. More redundancy increases unit cost, but it can reduce queueing and failures during incidents.

    The impact of utilization can be estimated with the following formulas:

    1. Amortized compute cost per million output tokens
    2. = GPU-hour cost ÷ actual output throughput (output tokens/hour) × 1,000,000
    3. Actual output throughput
    4. = peak output throughput × average utilization

    Throughput must be measured consistently in output tokens. If input tokens are included in the denominator, the calculated unit price will appear artificially low.

    Assume that one GPU costs $3 per GPU-hour and has a peak output throughput of 3,000 tokens per second, or 10.8 million tokens per hour. At 100% utilization, the amortized compute cost per million output tokens is approximately $0.28. At 40% utilization, the cost rises to approximately $0.69.

    These are hypothetical figures used only to demonstrate the effect of utilization. Actual batching policies, concurrency settings, and redundancy levels will change the result. The example should not be used directly for procurement decisions.

    3. Converting Credits into Usable Tokens

    The calculation has three stages:

    1. Calculate the cost of one request.
    2. Calculate how many successful requests the allowance can cover.
    3. Multiply that number by the tokens used per request.
    1. Cost per request
    2. = (uncached input tokens × input price
    3. + cached input tokens × cache price
    4. + output tokens × output price)
    5. ÷ 1,000,000

    The retry rate r must be defined clearly. In this article, r means the average number of additional requests sent for each successful request. For example, if every 100 successful requests requires an average of three additional failed retries, then r = 0.03.

    1. Successful requests covered
    2. = allowance ÷ (cost per request × (1 + r))
    3. Successful tokens
    4. = successful requests covered × total tokens per successful request
    5. Billed tokens consumed
    6. = successful tokens × (1 + r)

    These two token counts should be kept separate. Successful tokens represent the final output associated with completed requests. Billed tokens consumed include usage from failed requests and retries; this is the figure that determines when the allowance is exhausted. Treating successful tokens as billed tokens will overestimate the usable volume.

    If the provider documents a per-attempt failure rate p and automatically retries until a request succeeds, the average number of attempts per successful request is:

    1. 1 / (1 − p)

    In that case, replace (1 + r) in the formulas above with 1 / (1 − p).

    Worked Example

    Assume the following conditions:

    • Input price: $1 per million tokens
    • Cached input price: $0.10 per million tokens
    • Output price: $4 per million tokens
    • Average input per request: 8,000 tokens
    • Cache-hit rate: 60%
    • Uncached input: 3,200 tokens
    • Cached input: 4,800 tokens
    • Output: 1,000 tokens
    • Retry rate: r = 3%
    • Credit allowance: $500

    Step 1: Calculate input cost

    1. 8,000 × (0.4 × $1 + 0.6 × $0.10) ÷ 1,000,000
    2. = $0.00368

    Step 2: Calculate output cost

    1. 1,000 × $4 ÷ 1,000,000
    2. = $0.004

    Step 3: Calculate the cost per request

    1. $0.00368 + $0.004
    2. = $0.00768

    Step 4: Include retries

    1. $0.00768 × 1.03
    2. = $0.0079104

    Step 5: Calculate successful requests covered

    1. $500 ÷ $0.0079104
    2. ≈ 63,208 successful requests

    Step 6: Calculate successful tokens

    Each successful request uses 9,000 tokens: 8,000 input tokens plus 1,000 output tokens.

    1. 63,208 × 9,000
    2. ≈ 569 million successful tokens

    Step 7: Calculate billed token consumption

    1. 569 million × 1.03
    2. ≈ 586 million billed tokens

    Under these assumptions, a $500 allowance supports approximately 63,000 successful requests, or about 570 million successful tokens. Billed consumption is approximately 590 million tokens.

    If the calculation instead uses the 1 / (1 − p) method with a per-attempt failure rate of p = 3%, the multiplier is approximately 1.0309. The allowance would support roughly 63,150 successful requests, which is close to the result above. As failure rates increase, the difference between the two methods becomes more significant. Use the method that matches the provider’s documentation.

    4. How to Measure TTFT and TPS

    TTFT, or time to first token, is the time from sending a request to receiving the first output token. It includes network round-trip time, queueing, and prefill time.

    TPS, or output throughput, measures the speed at which the model generates output. This article defines it as:

    1. TPS = output token count ÷ (end time − first-token time)

    This definition excludes queueing and TTFT so that it reflects only the generation phase. If you care more about the end-to-end user experience, record total duration and end-to-end tokens per second separately.

    Keep the following conditions fixed and record them in the results table:

    • Model name and version
    • Integration method
    • Region
    • Measurement period
    • Concurrency
    • Input-length distribution
    • max_tokens
    • temperature
    • Whether streaming output is enabled

    The following Python script uses an OpenAI-compatible streaming interface. Replace count_tokens with the tokenizer that matches the model under test. Read the endpoint and API key from environment variables rather than hard-coding them.

    1. import os
    2. import statistics
    3. import time
    4. from openai import OpenAI
    5. def count_tokens(text):
    6. # Replace this with the tokenizer for the model under test.
    7. # Keep the tokenizer consistent across all comparisons.
    8. raise NotImplementedError
    9. def measure_once(client, model, prompt, max_tokens=512):
    10. start = time.perf_counter()
    11. first_token_at = None
    12. pieces = []
    13. stream = client.chat.completions.create(
    14. model=model,
    15. messages=[{"role": "user", "content": prompt}],
    16. max_tokens=max_tokens,
    17. temperature=0,
    18. stream=True,
    19. )
    20. for chunk in stream:
    21. if not chunk.choices:
    22. continue
    23. delta = chunk.choices[0].delta.content
    24. if delta:
    25. if first_token_at is None:
    26. first_token_at = time.perf_counter()
    27. pieces.append(delta)
    28. end = time.perf_counter()
    29. if first_token_at is None:
    30. return None # Empty output; count it as a failure
    31. out_tokens = count_tokens("".join(pieces))
    32. decode_time = end - first_token_at
    33. if out_tokens == 0 or decode_time <= 0:
    34. return None
    35. ttft = first_token_at - start
    36. tps = out_tokens / decode_time
    37. return ttft, tps
    38. def percentile(values, q):
    39. values = sorted(values)
    40. idx = min(len(values) - 1, int(q * len(values)))
    41. return values[idx]
    42. def run_benchmark(client, model, prompts, warmup=20):
    43. for p in prompts[:warmup]:
    44. measure_once(client, model, p) # Warm-up results are excluded
    45. results, failures = [], 0
    46. for p in prompts[warmup:]:
    47. r = measure_once(client, model, p)
    48. if r is None:
    49. failures += 1
    50. else:
    51. results.append(r)
    52. ttfts = [x[0] for x in results]
    53. tpss = [x[1] for x in results]
    54. return {
    55. "n": len(results),
    56. "failures": failures,
    57. "ttft_median": statistics.median(ttfts),
    58. "ttft_p95": percentile(ttfts, 0.95),
    59. "tps_median": statistics.median(tpss),
    60. "tps_p5": percentile(tpss, 0.05),
    61. }
    62. if __name__ == "__main__":
    63. client = OpenAI(
    64. base_url=os.environ["LLM_BASE_URL"],
    65. api_key=os.environ["LLM_API_KEY"],
    66. )
    67. prompts = [] # Sample from real tasks; use at least 220 prompts
    68. print(run_benchmark(client, "your-model-version", prompts))
    • Warm-up: Discard the first 20 requests before formal measurement to reduce the impact of connection setup and cache cold starts.
    • Sample size: Use at least 200 valid requests for each scenario. With fewer samples, P95 can vary substantially.
    • Time periods: Measure the same model during at least three different time periods. This helps prevent peak-hour queueing from being mistaken for the model’s inherent speed.
    • Metrics: Report median and P95 for TTFT. Report median and P5 for TPS, where P5 reflects slower performance. Avoid using the mean as the primary metric because extreme values can distort it.
    • Failed requests: Count them separately. Exclude them from TTFT and TPS, but include them in the retry rate and in the credit conversion calculations from Section 3.

    Results Record

    Item What to record
    Model and version Full version identifier; do not write “latest”
    Integration method Official API, proxy platform, or self-hosted deployment
    Region and network City, carrier, and whether a proxy is used
    Measurement period Date, start and end time, and whether it was a peak business period
    Concurrency Number of simultaneous requests
    Input length Median and P95
    Output limit max_tokens
    Sampling parameters temperature, top_p
    Samples and failures Valid sample count, failure count, and retry count
    TTFT Median and P95
    TPS Median and P5

    5. Evaluation Checklist

    When comparing models or AI coding assistants, review the following items:

    Evaluation item Questions to answer
    Cost per task How much does one real task cost on average, including retries and failures?
    Cache-hit rate Are your request prefixes stable enough to benefit from caching?
    Retry rate What is the failure rate during peak periods, and are failed requests billed?
    TTFT Is first-token latency acceptable for interactive use?
    TPS Can long-output tasks finish within an acceptable time?
    Capability coverage How accurate and format-consistent is the model on your task set?
    Credit expiration When do free credits expire, and are they separated by model?
    Migration cost Is the API compatible, and how much code must be changed to switch providers?

    6. Common Mistakes

    Mistake 1: Looking only at the credit amount.
    Convert credits into usable tokens or completed tasks. Two $500 allowances can support very different workloads when pricing, cache hits, and output lengths differ.

    Mistake 2: Ignoring retry consumption.
    Failed requests are often still billed. When retry rates rise during peak periods, the usable volume can fall significantly.

    Mistake 3: Treating successful tokens as billed tokens.
    Successful tokens represent completed output, while billed tokens determine how quickly the allowance is consumed.

    Mistake 4: Comparing TTFT and TPS under inconsistent conditions.
    Time of day, region, concurrency, and max_tokens can all affect the result. Standardize the test conditions before comparing systems.

    Mistake 5: Making a decision based on one test run.
    A single measurement is highly sensitive to network conditions and queueing. Use enough samples, follow the methodology in Section 4, and repeat the test across multiple time periods.