AI-Assisted Firmware Development: Fixing Abandoned UEFI Code and Getting It to Run
Large language models have become powerful productivity tools in application-layer development, but low-level firmware programming with UEFI poses unique challenges due to limited training data, hardware dependencies, and strict specification requirements. This article walks through a real-world experiment: using an AI coding tool to review, debug, and repair a set of abandoned UEFI game code. It covers a dangling pointer issue caused by GOP SetMode/QueryMode interactions and a black-screen bug caused by an incorrect protocol GUID, and shares practical lessons on how AI can serve as a true pair-programming partner in system-level development.
Large language models have evolved rapidly in code generation, and developers have grown accustomed to using AI to boost efficiency in application-layer development. However, in low-level system development scenarios such as UEFI (Unified Extensible Firmware Interface) or BIOS, AI performance often faces serious challenges: there is little open-source training data for this domain, and development depends heavily on hardware interaction and vendor-specific specifications. This article draws on a real low-level firmware development exercise to explore how an AI coding tool can take over and repair seriously flawed, abandoned code—demonstrating AI’s debugging and refactoring capabilities in complex low-level environments.
Background and Task Definition
Writing a program with a graphical interface that runs in a UEFI environment—such as a Tetris game—is far from trivial. UEFI executes before the operating system is loaded, with no standard C library (no stdio.h or stdlib.h), so all graphics rendering and input/output must rely on Protocols defined by the UEFI specification.
In earlier testing, one large language model (Model A) successfully wrote and ran a brick-breaker game within 2.5 hours, while another model (Model B) failed completely when attempting Tetris. After hours of effort, it not only failed to set up the environment but produced no runnable program at all. Notably, however, Model B’s leftover code was not worthless: it contained seven files with a modular design and a seemingly well-organized structure. Simply discarding it felt like a waste. So we set a more challenging task: let an AI coding tool with strong code comprehension capabilities take over and repair this abandoned codebase—a case of “defeating magic with magic.”
Round One: Code Review and Problem Identification
The first step in salvaging a mess is not blindly making changes, but performing a global code review. We copied the seven source files unchanged into a fresh development environment and gave the AI a clear instruction: “Review this UEFI code and identify issues that could prevent the program from running or compiling.”
The AI quickly began module-by-module analysis. Starting from the entry function, it examined the main loop, core game logic, GOP rendering module, and keyboard input handling. Within minutes, it produced a detailed list of issues and claimed that “after fixing these problems, the program should basically run.” This demonstrated AI’s strength in cross-file context understanding—it rapidly built an accurate picture of the entire project’s architecture.
Fix 1: Crash on Startup and the Dangling Pointer Trap
After applying the AI’s initial suggestions, the program actually compiled—already a big improvement over the original code. At runtime, however, the console printed “Starting Game Loop” and then the program exited abnormally.
To investigate the crash, we asked the AI to add more detailed debug logging and monitor execution progress over a serial connection. By analyzing the serial output, the AI pinpointed exactly when the failure occurred: right after invoking the GOP (Graphics Output Protocol).
Root cause:
The problem lay in the interaction between GOP’s QueryMode and SetMode. The original code called QueryMode to obtain current graphics mode information, then immediately called SetMode to set a new resolution. Under the UEFI specification, a SetMode operation may cause the firmware to reallocate video memory or change the frame buffer mapping. The original code then continued using the stale info pointer obtained before QueryMode—but the memory it pointed to had become invalid after SetMode, turning it into a dangling pointer. When the program later tried to read frame buffer information through that dangling pointer, it triggered an exception and crashed.
The fix:
The AI’s fix was straightforward: after SetMode completes, you must call QueryMode again to retrieve up-to-date frame buffer information:
EFI_STATUS Status;EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL *Gop;EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL_MODE *Mode;UINTN SizeOfInfo;EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_MODE_INFORMATION *Info;// ... obtain the Gop protocol ...// Original buggy logic: QueryMode here, then SetMode, invalidating Info// Status = Gop->QueryMode(Gop, Gop->Mode->Mode, &SizeOfInfo, &Info);// Status = Gop->SetMode(Gop, NewMode);// Correct logic: SetMode first, then re-query mode infoStatus = Gop->SetMode(Gop, NewMode);if (EFI_ERROR(Status)) {return Status;}// Re-fetch frame buffer info after SetMode to ensure the pointer is validStatus = Gop->QueryMode(Gop, Gop->Mode->Mode, &SizeOfInfo, &Info);if (EFI_ERROR(Status)) {return Status;}// Info is now valid and safe to use for subsequent rendering logic
After applying this fix and rebuilding, the program no longer crashed, and the main loop ran stably.
Fix 2: Black Screen and the Protocol GUID
The crash was gone, but a new problem appeared: nothing rendered on screen and the game sat in a “black screen” state. We reported this to the AI tool and asked it to analyze the rendering module’s execution path.
Root cause:
After carefully analyzing the runtime results and the GOP initialization process, the AI identified an incorrectly configured GUID (Globally Unique Identifier) for the GOP protocol. In the EDK2 (EFI Development Kit II) framework, multiple graphics-output-related GUIDs are defined. If the wrong GUID is used when locating a protocol, LocateProtocol will fail to find the graphics output protocol instance, causing all subsequent rendering operations to silently fail.
The standard pattern for locating a protocol in UEFI firmware development is:
EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL *Gop = NULL;Status = gBS->LocateProtocol(&gEfiGraphicsOutputProtocolGuid, // must use the correct GUIDNULL,(VOID **)&Gop);
The original code used a similar but incorrect GUID (possibly one intended only for a specific display driver’s testing), leaving Gop either NULL or pointing to the wrong structure.
The fix:
The AI recommended using gEfiGraphicsOutputProtocolGuid as defined in the EDK2 standard library. It also checked the [Protocols] section of the .inf file to ensure the GUID was properly declared as a dependency. After the fix, the program successfully acquired the graphics output protocol, and the long-awaited game interface finally appeared on screen.
Summary and Takeaways
From this experiment of having AI take over and repair abandoned UEFI code, several important conclusions emerge:
- AI has deep reasoning capability for low-level code. Even in a firmware environment without a standard library, AI can accurately diagnose complex low-level issues such as dangling pointers and invalid memory by analyzing code logic together with runtime logs (serial output).
- Context management is key. When asking AI to fix a multi-file project, a full code review first is essential. It helps AI build a global picture of call relationships and avoids chained regressions in other modules while fixing one spot.
- Developers remain the core decision-makers. AI can provide high-quality fixes and code snippets, but developers need the judgment to validate AI’s assumptions and provide correct guidance when AI hits blind spots—such as hardware platform-specific differences.
In low-level system development, large language models are no longer just “code completion tools”—they are powerful pair-programming partners. Used wisely, AI coding tools can significantly reduce debugging costs around complex protocol specifications and memory management, freeing developers to focus on core architecture design.
