Debugging Firmware-Level Development with an AI Coding Assistant: From Crashes to a Running UEFI Game
This case study examines how an AI coding assistant helped recover a nonfunctional UEFI graphics game project. Through code review, serial logging, and controlled fixes, the debugging process progressed from silent crashes and missing graphics output to a working game. It also distills practical principles for using AI in firmware and other system-level development environments.
Why Choose a Difficult Firmware Task?
Evaluating an AI coding assistant by asking it to build a web-based Snake game is not especially meaningful. Training data is full of examples like that, so most models can generate one successfully with little effort. More revealing tasks are those with limited training data, closed execution environments, and long feedback loops between an error and its root cause.
Graphics development in a UEFI environment fits all of these conditions. There is no operating system to provide support, no standard library to rely on, and graphics output must connect directly to firmware protocol interfaces. Debugging is largely limited to examining serial logs one line at a time.
This task was also not a clean implementation from scratch. The previous test had left behind a seven-module project generated by another model. Its structure looked reasonable, but the program could not run at all. The new assistant’s first job was to take over and repair someone else’s broken codebase.
That setup is more representative of real engineering work than simply comparing who can generate code fastest. In practice, AI is often used to understand, repair, and optimize existing code rather than create everything from nothing. The ability to read unfamiliar code and locate problems in an environment with incomplete information is a much stronger test of engineering capability.
Round 1: From Broken Code to a Running Program
Step 1: Review the Code Before Editing It
I copied the legacy code into the new environment without changes. My first instruction to the assistant was deliberately restrained: review the code, identify issues that could prevent it from running, and do not modify anything yet.
This order matters. If you immediately ask an AI to “fix the program,” it may respond with a broad rewrite. The more code it changes, the greater the chance of introducing new problems, and the harder it becomes for the developer to maintain control of the codebase.
A review-first workflow forces the model to build an understanding of the overall project before making changes. It also gives the developer an opportunity to examine the proposed fixes in advance.
After several minutes, the assistant had reviewed the entry point, main loop, game logic, rendering code, and input handling. It produced a list of issues and claimed that the project would run after the proposed changes were applied.
Problem 1: The Program Crashed and Exited Silently
The actual result was different. The program started and printed Starting Game Loop to the serial console, then exited immediately. That was still better than the previous state, where the build environment could not even be brought up, but the game was far from playable.
For low-level debugging, I used one of the simplest and most effective techniques: asking the AI to add more diagnostic output along the critical execution paths and then monitoring progress through the serial console.
In a bare-metal environment, there may be no breakpoint debugger available. Logging becomes your primary way to observe the program. By printing a message after each major stage, the last log entry before termination provides an approximate boundary for the failure.
After narrowing down the logs, the problem was traced to a graphics output protocol query. The program had received a dangling pointer while querying mode information. After the display mode was changed, the memory containing the previous framebuffer information was no longer valid, but the code continued to access it.
The fix followed a common pattern: retrieve the framebuffer information again after SetMode completes instead of reusing the pointer obtained before the mode switch.
The underlying issue was a mismatch between pointer lifetime and hardware state changes. This type of bug is common in firmware development because a firmware interface may reallocate or remap resources when the display mode changes.
After the fix, the crash disappeared.
This debugging loop is worth remembering:
The developer provides the observed behavior, the AI proposes a hypothesis, logs are used to validate that hypothesis, and the AI then implements the fix.
Within that loop, the AI handles analysis and potential solutions, while the developer provides the real-world execution feedback that the model cannot generate on its own.
Problem 2: The Program Was Running, but No Graphics Appeared
Eliminating the crash was only the baseline. The program now ran reliably, but the display remained blank.
After I reported the behavior, the assistant analyzed the runtime logs and identified the graphics output protocol GUID configuration as a likely cause.
Firmware development has a subtle trap here: the same protocol may have multiple similar-looking GUID definitions across specifications and reference implementations, even though they serve different purposes. If the wrong one is used, protocol discovery may fail without producing an obvious error. The program continues running but does not obtain the resource it needs.
This kind of silent failure is often more difficult to debug than a crash because there is no clear exception or termination point to investigate.
The lesson is straightforward:
For standard protocol programming, “magic constants” such as GUIDs, protocol names, and version numbers must be checked against the official specification.
AI models can confuse similar definitions from different contexts. Human verification against the relevant documentation remains essential.
General Lessons for Working with AI on System-Level Code
Looking back at the debugging process, I identified four practices that apply to most AI-assisted system development tasks.
1. Break the task into small steps and provide real feedback.
Do not give the AI a vague goal such as “make the game run.” Instead, define clear stages: review the code, fix the crash, and bring up graphics output. Feed the actual runtime result back to the model after each step. The quality of its reasoning is significantly better when it has concrete evidence than when it is generating a complete solution in an information vacuum.
2. Review first, then modify, to control the scope of changes.
Ask the AI to produce an issue analysis and modification plan before it edits the code. Human approval helps prevent broad rewrites from introducing regressions and ensures that the developer maintains an understanding of the codebase.
3. In environments without a debugger, logs are essential.
Ask the AI to instrument critical paths and use serial or console output to verify execution flow. In bare-metal, firmware, and kernel-level development, this may be the only reliable way to observe what the program is doing. AI is particularly effective at reasoning from sequences of log messages, provided that it receives enough information.
4. Keep a human verification gate for AI-generated output.
This is especially important for factual constants such as GUIDs, register addresses, and protocol versions. AI can produce values that look plausible but are incorrect. Whenever a detail can be checked against the specification, verification is far less expensive than debugging an error after deployment.
Conclusion
Across two rounds of iteration, an originally nonfunctional firmware project was brought back to life. The first round resolved the crash and graphics initialization problems, while the second moved on to refining the game logic and improving performance.
The assistant demonstrated several capabilities that are valuable in low-level development: understanding code across multiple modules, reasoning from logs, and identifying bugs related to resource and pointer lifetimes. Its workflow increasingly resembled that of an engineer familiar with systems programming.
At the same time, the process made the limitations clear. The AI still needed a human in the loop to provide real execution feedback, verify factual details, and control the scope of code changes.
The most practical way to use this kind of tool today is to treat it as a senior pair-programming partner that needs clear instructions and timely feedback—not as a vending machine that automatically produces finished software.
