Selecting a Chinese LLM for STEM Work: How to Evaluate the Top Four Tiers

    Chinese LLM selection is highly task-dependent, so there is no universal “top four” ranking. This article presents a practical framework for STEM users: evaluate models in four capability tiers—balanced general-purpose, reasoning and academic, software engineering, and cost-efficient or locally deployable—then validate them with a small task-specific test set, weighted scoring, and human review.

    Selecting a Chinese LLM for STEM Work: How to Evaluate the Top Four Tiers

    1. Start by recognizing that there is no fixed “top four” list

    Discussions about Chinese LLM rankings often turn into debates over which model is number one. For STEM users, however, suitability is usually not determined by a single overall score. It depends on the task.

    Examples include:

    • Mathematical derivation: emphasis on symbolic understanding, rigorous steps, and result verification.
    • Programming: emphasis on requirement analysis, code correctness, debugging ability, and engineering structure.
    • Paper reading: emphasis on long context, terminology understanding, information extraction, and citation boundaries.
    • Experiment planning: emphasis on knowledge coverage, variable control, risk warnings, and verifiability.
    • Batch calls: emphasis on API stability, response speed, price, and concurrency limits.
    • Local or private deployment: emphasis on model size, VRAM usage, quantization compatibility, and deployment difficulty.

    Therefore, rather than giving an absolute ranking, it is more useful to divide Chinese LLMs into four broad tiers and use standardized tests to determine which tier fits a particular workflow.

    2. Tier 1: balanced general-purpose models

    General-purpose models usually have solid Chinese-language understanding, code generation, knowledge question answering, long-text summarization, and tool-calling capabilities. They are suitable for everyday research and engineering tasks.

    The advantage of this tier is that it has no obvious weak point. Such a model may not be the best at every capability, but it can often handle the full workflow from requirement decomposition to first-draft generation and then revision. For STEM users, broad capability is often more valuable in practice than a top score on a single benchmark.

    Typical use cases include:

    1. Reading technical documentation and producing structured summaries.
    2. Writing scripts based on natural-language requirements.
    3. Analyzing error messages and proposing troubleshooting paths.
    4. Converting experiment records into standardized reports.
    5. Organizing papers by section.
    6. Generating initial code for database queries, data processing, or automation tasks.

    However, general-purpose models also have common problems. First, their output may look reasonable while being unreliable in detail, especially in formula derivation, version differences, and boundary conditions. Second, a model may state uncertain content too confidently. In a research setting, its output should not be treated as a final conclusion. Instead, require the model to list assumptions, show derivations, and describe verification methods.

    3. Tier 2: models that perform well on reasoning and academic tasks

    For academic tasks in STEM fields, reasoning ability is often more important than language fluency. A strong reasoning model should be able to break down a problem, identify premises, distinguish known conditions from implicit conditions, and check whether its conclusion satisfies the constraints.

    When evaluating this type of model, pay particular attention to the following capabilities:

    3.1 Does it analyze the problem structure first?

    For a complex problem, a model should not immediately provide an unexplained conclusion. It should first clarify inputs, goals, constraints, and intermediate variables. For example, in algorithm design, it should explain time complexity, space complexity, and behavior under special inputs.

    3.2 Can it handle multi-step derivations?

    Simple arithmetic is not a good measure of reasoning ability. A more effective test is to provide a problem with multiple conditions and observe whether the model keeps variable definitions consistent and avoids silently changing the meaning of a concept in later steps.

    3.3 Does it self-check?

    Ideally, a model should check its final result for order of magnitude, units, boundary conditions, or counterexamples. For code, it should also flag possible abnormal inputs and resource bottlenecks.

    3.4 Can it distinguish facts from speculation?

    In academic settings, a model must clearly state which content comes from known sources and which is inferred from experience. When it cannot confirm something, it should use expressions such as “may” or “needs verification” rather than presenting an uncertain conclusion as certain.

    This tier is suitable for paper outline design, experiment plan discussion, algorithm analysis, mathematical modeling, and complex code review. However, response speed may be slower and usage cost may be higher. In practice, complex tasks can be routed to the reasoning model, while simple rewriting, format conversion, and batch classification can be handled by a lightweight model.

    4. Tier 3: models with strong coding and engineering capabilities

    For developers, generating code is only the baseline. A more important question is whether the model understands an existing project.

    Valuable programming assistance should cover at least the following steps:

    • Identify the project directory structure and module responsibilities.
    • Modify local logic under existing interface constraints.
    • Handle exceptions, logging, and input validation.
    • Write unit tests.
    • Analyze performance issues.
    • Explain dependencies and deployment considerations.
    • Avoid breaking existing functionality when changing code.

    Many models perform well when generating standalone examples, but once placed in a real project they may use inconsistent variable names, call nonexistent APIs, ignore concurrency issues, or make changes that are too broad. Therefore, it is not enough to test whether a model can generate code. You also need to test whether it can modify code under constraints.

    A small code benchmark is recommended. Prepare several real but anonymized tasks, each containing a requirement description, existing code, error logs, and acceptance criteria. Then observe separately:

    1. Whether the model accurately restates the requirements.
    2. Whether it locates the problem before making changes.
    3. Whether the modified code passes tests.
    4. Whether it explains potential side effects.
    5. Whether it can perform a second round of repair based on test results.

    For enterprise development or research projects, use a closed loop: model generates a draft, local tests run, model analyzes failures, and a human confirms the result. Do not copy model output directly into production.

    5. Tier 4: cost-effective and locally deployable models

    For individual developers, students, and teams with limited budgets, cost-effectiveness is often more important than absolute capability. Some models may not lead in a single capability, but they have advantages in response speed, usage cost, open deployment, and task stability.

    This tier is suitable for:

    • Text classification and information extraction.
    • Meeting-notes organization.
    • Code-comment generation.
    • Simple data cleaning.
    • Batch document rewriting.
    • Internal knowledge-base question answering.
    • Local processing of sensitive data.

    If data cannot leave the internal network, local deployment is especially important. Deployment planning should consider model parameter size, quantization method, VRAM capacity, context length, and concurrency requirements. A larger model is not always better: larger models often have a higher capability ceiling, but inference cost, response latency, and operational complexity also increase.

    In real projects, a large-model and small-model collaboration strategy can be used. Complex problems are handled by the large model, simple tasks by lightweight models; high-risk outputs go through human review, while low-risk tasks are executed automatically in batches. This architecture is often more economical than using the same large model for every task.

    6. How STEM users should build a test set

    Without a test set, “good” often remains a subjective impression. Build a minimal evaluation set around your own work. It should include at least the following five types of tasks.

    6.1 Knowledge accuracy test

    Prepare a set of questions in your area of expertise, covering fundamental concepts, technical terminology, and easily confused boundaries. Focus on whether the model misattributes information, mixes up concepts, or provides outdated information.

    6.2 Reasoning rigor test

    Choose problems that require multi-step analysis. Ask the model to write down assumptions, derivations, and conclusions, and additionally require a counterexample check. Do not look only at the final answer. Also examine whether the intermediate process is self-consistent.

    6.3 Code correctness test

    Use programming tasks with explicit inputs and outputs, and verify results through automated tests. Metrics can include first-pass rate, number of repair rounds, completeness of exception handling, and code maintainability.

    6.4 Long-text processing test

    Provide technical reports, experiment records, or specification documents, and ask the model to extract key conclusions, variables, risks, and action items. Check whether the model omits information and whether it mixes content from different sections.

    6.5 Stability test

    Ask the same question repeatedly and observe variations in the answer. Change the wording of the question and observe whether the model still maintains a consistent conclusion. For batch tasks, also monitor timeouts, format errors, and abnormal responses.

    7. Do not rely only on parameter count and leaderboard rankings

    Parameter count reflects model capacity, but it does not directly equal practical performance. Data quality, training methods, alignment strategies, reasoning mechanisms, and deployment optimization are also important.

    In addition, public leaderboards often cover only a limited set of tasks and do not represent your real work scenarios. A model that ranks highly in general question answering is not necessarily the best choice for your specialized code, experimental data, or enterprise documents.

    A more reasonable decision method is to build a weighted scorecard. For example:

    Evaluation dimension What to examine
    Domain accuracy Whether it understands technical terms and is prone to factual errors
    Reasoning ability Whether multi-step analysis is coherent and whether results can be reviewed
    Coding ability Code runnability, test pass rate, and maintainability
    Long-context ability Information recall, structured summarization, and context consistency
    Response efficiency Latency, throughput, and concurrency stability
    Cost Cost per call, deployment cost, and operational cost
    Data security Data isolation, access control, and log management
    Integrability Ease of integration with existing systems and automated workflows

    The final choice should be determined by actual weights, not by a single online ranking.

    For individual users, start with a strong general-purpose model as the primary model, then add a reasoning model and a lightweight model as supplements. The primary model handles daily question answering, code drafts, and document organization; the reasoning model handles complex analysis; the lightweight model handles batch processing.

    For research teams, consider connecting models to literature management, experiment records, and code repositories. However, permissions, de-identification, and human review mechanisms must be in place. Before processing unpublished results, personal information, or raw experimental data, confirm the data-processing boundaries.

    For enterprise users, one option is to use general-purpose LLM services from cloud platforms such as Baidu AI Cloud, and combine them with object storage, logging, monitoring and alerting, and permission management to build a complete application. The key is not simply “connecting a model,” but forming a production process that is traceable, evaluable, and rollback-capable.

    9. Conclusion: the top four are capability combinations, not a fixed list

    Competition among Chinese LLMs is gradually shifting from “which one can chat” to “which one can reliably complete specific work.” When STEM users choose a model, they should focus on task fit, result verification, and total cost.

    If the goal is a well-rounded experience, prioritize a balanced general-purpose model. If the focus is mathematics, research, and complex analysis, emphasize reasoning ability. If the main work is software development, focus on testing code modification and the debugging loop. If the budget is limited or data is sensitive, pay attention to lightweight models, local deployment, and batch-processing capability.

    The “top four Chinese LLMs” are therefore better understood as four major capability directions rather than a permanent brand ranking. Build your own test set, adopt multi-model collaboration, and keep human review in the loop. That is the more reliable and professional approach.