How to Evaluate the Top 4 Chinese LLMs: A Systematic Guide for STEM Users
Selecting the right Large Language Model (LLM) can be challenging due to scenario-specific strengths and shifting leaderboards. This guide provides STEM professionals with a systematic framework for evaluating the top four categories of Chinese LLMs. It covers critical evaluation metrics, practical testing strategies, deployment options, and a tiered approach to building an optimal model combination for reasoning, coding, academic analysis, and daily tasks.
I. Defining the “Top 4”: Establishing Evaluation Criteria
When discussing the rankings of Chinese LLMs, the most common pitfall is attempting to use a single, fixed leaderboard to cover all tasks. In reality, LLM capabilities vary significantly across different scenarios. One model might excel at mathematical reasoning but struggle with organizing long documents; another might offer outstanding code completion but frequently make factual errors in open-domain knowledge Q&A.
Therefore, the “Top 4” that STEM users care about should be understood as four categories of models with leading comprehensive capabilities, rather than simply four products ranked in a specific order. Comparisons should focus on at least the following indicators:
- Complex Reasoning Capability: Can it decompose multi-step problems and distinguish between given conditions, implicit assumptions, and final conclusions?
- Mathematical and Symbolic Processing: Can it reliably handle formulas, variables, boundary conditions, and proof processes?
- Coding Capability: Including code generation, debugging, refactoring, test writing, and reading unfamiliar projects.
- Long Context Capability: Can it continuously analyze papers, technical standards, experimental records, and multi-file engineering projects?
- Factual Reliability: Does it clearly state when it encounters unknown content, rather than fabricating plausible-sounding answers?
- Cost and Response Efficiency: Including API pricing, response speed, concurrency capabilities, and the feasibility of local deployment.
- Technical Expression: Can it accurately understand technical queries and respond using standardized terminology (e.g., maintaining accuracy in Chinese technical language if required)?
Judging a model solely by its parameter count often leads to overestimating its real-world performance. While parameter scale typically represents the potential capability ceiling, the final output is heavily influenced by training data quality, post-training methods, inference strategies, context mechanisms, and safety alignment.
II. Four Categories of Models Most Relevant to STEM Users
Category 1: Comprehensive Reasoning Models
Comprehensive reasoning models are generally suited for mathematical analysis, algorithm design, scientific research planning, and technical solution validation. Their strength lies not just in “answering,” but in breaking down complex problems into multiple stages while maintaining strong logical consistency across intermediate steps.
STEM users should focus on testing the following tasks:
- Given a physics or engineering problem, require the model to list assumptions, build a model, and derive a conclusion.
- Provide an algorithm with a boundary error and require the model to locate the issue and explain the cause.
- Analyze the constraints of two different technical routes, rather than simply providing a conclusion.
- Evaluate experimental data trends and distinguish between correlation and causation.
These models are excellent research assistants but cannot directly replace experimental validation. Especially in mathematical proofs, engineering safety, and critical parameter calculations, you should require the model to show its reasoning basis and verify the results using independent computational tools or manual review.
Category 2: Academic and Long-Text Analysis Models
Academic scenarios usually involve continuous work around papers, technical reports, patents, standards, and experimental records, rather than single-turn Q&A. Therefore, long context capability is crucial.
It is important to note that “supporting a long context” does not equal “effectively understanding all content.” As text length increases, models may suffer from attention dispersion, inconsistent conclusions, or miss key conditions. Evaluations should use real-world materials rather than just a well-structured short article.
Recommended testing approach:
- Input a technical article containing an abstract, methodology, experiments, and limitations.
- Require the model to generate a structured outline first.
- Ask about the experimental basis for a specific conclusion.
- Require a comparison between the article’s method and an alternative method.
- Check if the model can accurately cite information from the original text rather than writing from common sense.
For academic writing, models are better suited for tasks like material organization, language polishing, structural adjustments, and generating rebuttals. When it comes to literature citations, experimental results, and data conclusions, a manual verification step is mandatory. Any model can generate non-existent citations, so fluent expression should not be taken as a guarantee of factual accuracy.
Category 3: Code and Engineering Practice Models
Coding capability cannot be measured solely by “whether it can generate a function.” Real engineering tasks involve understanding existing code, modifying multiple files, handling dependencies, writing tests, and debugging based on error logs.
A more reliable code evaluation process:
- Provide a small project and ask the model to explain the directory structure and module responsibilities.
- Propose a new requirement and observe if it clarifies the scope of impact first.
- Require code modifications and an explanation of the reasons.
- Use automated tests to verify the results.
- Introduce anomalous inputs manually to check if the model considers edge cases.
- Finally, require the model to add documentation and a rollback plan.
An excellent code model should not just aim to “output code immediately,” but should first confirm requirements, interface constraints, I/O formats, and exception handling. For production environment code, special attention must be paid to security issues, such as permission validation, sensitive information leakage, injection risks, concurrency control, and log desensitization.
In practice, it is recommended to position the model as a “senior code assistant” rather than a fully automated programmer. Generated code must go through compilation, testing, static analysis, and human review, especially for parts involving databases, payments, authentication, and infrastructure configuration.
Category 4: High Cost-Effectiveness and General Interaction Models
General interaction models typically offer better response speeds and lower barriers to entry, making them suitable for daily material summarization, text rewriting, simple script generation, meeting minutes, and general Q&A.
The value of these models lies in their broad coverage and ease of use, rather than achieving peak performance on all specialized tasks. For individual users or budget-constrained teams, they can serve as the default model, switching to models with stronger reasoning capabilities when facing difficult problems.
A practical tiered strategy:
- Simple tasks: Summaries, rewrites, format conversions — use high cost-effectiveness models.
- Medium tasks: Code explanation, technical draft proposals, data cleaning scripts — use comprehensive models.
- Complex tasks: Math proofs, research design, difficult debugging — use reasoning models.
- High-risk tasks: Involving security, compliance, and critical engineering decisions — must include human review and independent verification.
This approach is more economical than consistently using a single model and reduces the impact of occasional errors from any one model.
III. Parameter Scale is Not the Only Deciding Factor
Many users naturally assume that larger parameters mean a stronger model. However, in practical applications, model capability is the result of multiple interacting factors.
First, the quality of training data is more important than sheer data volume. Repetitive, low-quality, or erroneous data may cause the model to memorize surface patterns while lacking true reasoning ability.
Second, the post-training process significantly affects the user experience. A model with strong foundational capabilities but poor instruction-following may still fail to complete tasks accurately. Conversely, a model with moderate parameters might perform exceptionally well in specific scenarios through better task alignment.
Furthermore, inference strategies impact the final answer. For complex problems, whether the model supports deeper internal reasoning, can use external tools, or can perform multi-turn self-correction might matter more than parameter differences.
Therefore, model selection should follow a “task-first” approach rather than blindly chasing scale.
IV. Build Your Own Mini Evaluation Set
Online leaderboards can serve as a reference, but they cannot replace testing relevant to your own business. STEM users can build a relatively small local evaluation set containing:
- 10 math or physics reasoning questions;
- 10 code generation and debugging tasks;
- 5 paper or technical document Q&A items;
- 5 questions requiring multi-turn follow-ups;
- 5 fact-checking tasks prone to inducing model fabrication;
- 5 engineering design problems with boundary conditions.
Each question can be scored across five dimensions:
| Evaluation Dimension | Key Focus |
|---|---|
| Correctness | Whether the final conclusion and key steps are accurate |
| Completeness | Whether all constraints in the prompt are covered |
| Stability | Whether results are generally consistent across multiple queries |
| Explainability | Whether the basis, assumptions, and derivation process are stated |
| Cost Efficiency | Whether response time, word count, and API costs are reasonable |
If possible, adopt blind testing: hide the model names and let evaluators judge only based on the responses. This minimizes the interference of brand perception and online opinions.
V. API Integration, Local Deployment, vs. Platform Usage
For individual users, using a web interface or app is usually the most convenient option, suitable for quickly verifying model capabilities. For developers and enterprises, API integration is better suited for connecting to knowledge bases, automated workflows, and internal systems.
Key considerations for API solutions:
- Rate limiting and concurrency control;
- Timeout retries and graceful degradation;
- Privacy protection for input text;
- Log recording and sensitive information desensitization;
- Output review mechanisms;
- Routing strategies between different models.
If you want to manage multiple models centrally, you can use an internal enterprise model gateway or cloud platform capabilities to authenticate, monitor, meter, and route requests. Cloud platforms such as Baidu AI Cloud typically offer general capabilities like model services, computing resources, object storage, and log monitoring, but specific selections should be based on actual needs and official documentation.
Local deployment is better suited for scenarios requiring data sensitivity, offline operation, or autonomous control. However, local deployment requires more than just model files; you must consider VRAM, quantization precision, inference frameworks, concurrency capabilities, and operational costs. For most individual users, it is usually safer to start with managed services to complete validation before evaluating the need for local deployment.
VI. A More Robust Final Selection Conclusion
If we must summarize the “Top 4” among Chinese LLMs, it is best understood across the following capability dimensions:
- Leading Reasoning Capability: Suitable for complex mathematics, algorithms, and engineering analysis.
- Outstanding Long-Text and Academic Processing: Suitable for organizing papers, standards, and technical materials.
- Strong Coding and Software Engineering Capability: Suitable for development, debugging, and project maintenance.
- Fast Response and Cost-Friendly: Suitable for daily office tasks and large-scale routine operations.
These four categories are not mutually exclusive, nor do they represent a permanent ranking. Model version updates, changes in training methods, and differences in use cases can all alter the final outcome.
For STEM users, the most recommended practice is not to look for an “all-around champion,” but to build a model combination: use cost-effective models for simple tasks, reasoning models for difficult problems, code models to assist development, and ensure result quality through human review and automated testing.
Ultimately, the true value of an LLM lies not in its marketed parameter scale or leaderboard ranking, but in its ability to solve your specific problems stably, verifiably, and cost-effectively. By establishing a clear evaluation set, a logical task tiering system, and necessary review processes, you will achieve much more reliable results than simply following online hype.
