Evaluating LLM Reasoning with Complex Strategy Game Tasks

    This article describes a strategy-game-based method for evaluating an LLM’s comprehensive reasoning. It explains why general QA tests are insufficient, how to break down requirements for a turn-based-to-RTS conversion and a toggleable automatic research assistant, five evaluation dimensions, a reference implementation structure, an acceptance checklist, and common implementation pitfalls.

    1. Why Use Strategy Games for LLM Evaluation

    General question-answering tests mainly examine knowledge coverage and language expression. They are less effective at revealing a model’s ability to track state across multi-step tasks. Strategy games combine rule constraints, resource allocation, timing decisions, and adversarial play, making them suitable for comprehensive evaluation. To produce a runnable game prototype, a model must understand three things at the same time: how the interface maps to internal state, where the boundaries of the rules lie, and how each action affects subsequent state.

    The evaluation focus is therefore not whether the visuals are polished, but whether the logic forms a closed loop. Whether a game runs according to its rules, whether state remains consistent, and whether edge cases are handled correctly are more informative than surface appearance.

    2. Requirements Breakdown: From Rule Understanding to System Design

    This evaluation includes two requirements. The first asks the model to convert a turn-based strategy game into a real-time strategy (RTS) game. The second asks it to add a toggleable automatic research assistance system. The two requirements test the model’s understanding of genre characteristics and its understanding of the intent behind a new feature.

    2.1 From Turn-Based to Real-Time

    Changing a turn-based game to real-time may appear to require only removing an “End Turn” button, but it actually requires changing the entire scheduling model. Turn-based games are driven by player actions, and the system resolves everything at the end of a turn. Real-time games are driven by time, and all units, buildings, and research progress update continuously over time.

    Real-time games typically have the following characteristics:

    • There is no manual turn-advance operation; the game clock runs automatically.
    • Construction, production, and research each have independent progress timers.
    • Player commands may arrive at any moment, and the system must handle concurrent input correctly.
    • Resource acquisition rates for both sides are determined by the same rules and do not depend on input frequency.

    To judge whether a model truly understands real-time mechanics, observe whether it places time advancement in an independent loop rather than embedding time advancement inside each click callback. The latter may appear to run, but once the game stops receiving input, time also stops. That violates the basic characteristics of real-time play.

    2.2 Fairness Constraints

    Fairness is a core constraint in real-time strategy games. Common practices include:

    • All units are updated using the same fixed time step.
    • Resource output and production speed are determined only by game rule parameters.
    • The computer opponent and the human player use the same game interface and receive no extra information or extra speed.

    The fixed time step is especially important. If time advancement is tied to device frame rate, higher-performance devices will complete research faster than lower-performance devices, and fairness cannot be guaranteed.

    2.3 Automatic Research Assistant System

    The original game has no automatic research feature. The model therefore needs to understand the intent to “add an AI assistant system” and design a toggleable module on its own. A reasonable design usually includes the following:

    • Provide a toggle option that the player can check or uncheck at any time.
    • Start research only when resources are sufficient, avoiding resource overdraft.
    • When the research queue is empty, select the next researchable item according to a preset priority.
    • Manual research initiated by the player takes priority, and the assistant does not interrupt an ongoing task.

    This design reflects the model’s ability to translate requirements. The model needs to translate “help the player research automatically” into specific state conditions, priority rules, and resource-checking logic, rather than generating only a button.

    3. Evaluation Dimensions

    To avoid judging only by demo effects, evaluate generated results across the following five dimensions:

    1. Rule understanding: whether the model can accurately explain the meaning of real-time mechanics and fairness and reflect both in the implementation.
    2. Architecture reasonableness: whether time advancement is independent of input events and whether game state is centrally managed.
    3. Functional completeness: whether both requirements run correctly, rather than only completing interface presentation.
    4. Edge-case handling: whether situations such as insufficient resources, interrupted research, and rapid repeated clicks have clear handling approaches.
    5. Maintainability: whether module boundaries are clear, naming is consistent, and key logic has necessary comments.

    Each dimension should have observable criteria. For example, “functional completeness” can be judged by actual running results, and “architecture reasonableness” can be judged by checking where the time-advancement code is located.

    4. Reference Implementation Approach

    The pseudocode below shows the core structure. It does not depend on any specific engine or framework; it only illustrates the relationship among time advancement, research scheduling, and the assistant system.

    1. TICK = 0.1 # Fixed time step in seconds
    2. class GameState:
    3. resources # Resource amount, tracked independently for each side
    4. research_queue # Current research queue
    5. units # Unit list
    6. def update(dt):
    7. # Advance all production and research progress by fixed step
    8. ...
    9. def can_afford(cost):
    10. # Check whether resources are sufficient to pay cost
    11. ...
    12. class ResearchAssistant:
    13. def __init__(self):
    14. self.enabled = False # Controlled by player toggle
    15. def tick(state):
    16. if not self.enabled:
    17. return
    18. if state.research_queue is not empty:
    19. return # Research already in progress; do not preempt
    20. for tech in state.available_techs(): # Sorted by priority
    21. if state.can_afford(tech.cost):
    22. state.start_research(tech)
    23. return
    24. def game_loop(state, assistant):
    25. while not state.is_over():
    26. state.update(TICK) # Time advances automatically via the loop
    27. assistant.tick(state) # Assistant shares the same interface as the player
    28. render(state)
    29. wait(TICK)

    This structure has three key points. First, time advancement is in an independent loop; whether the player acts does not affect the passage of time. Second, the assistant starts research through the same state interface used by the player and does not bypass the rules. Third, the resource check is completed before research starts, avoiding negative resources.

    5. Acceptance Method

    Generated results can be verified item by item using the following checklist:

    • After startup, with no operations performed, time and resources still grow at a fixed rate.
    • When the assistant is off, research must be initiated manually by the player.
    • When the assistant is on, it does not start research if resources are insufficient.
    • When resources are sufficient and the queue is empty, the assistant can start research automatically and complete it without human operation.
    • Both sides have the same resource growth rate, and the computer opponent receives no extra output.
    • During rapid repeated clicks, game state does not become corrupted, for example, the same resource is not deducted twice.

    For verification, run the game multiple times with a fixed random seed and record key state at each time step. If the logs from two runs are completely identical, time advancement is deterministic, and fairness issues are easier to troubleshoot.

    6. Common Issues

    The following issues appear frequently in actual testing:

    • Changing only the interface and not the logic. The game interface looks real-time, but internally it still resolves by turns. To check, disable rendering and observe whether time still advances.
    • Tying the time step to frame rate. Speed differs across devices, breaking fairness. The solution is to use a fixed time step, with rendering responsible only for display.
    • The assistant directly manipulates interface elements. This makes logic difficult to test and can easily cause inconsistency with interface state. The assistant should call only game-state interfaces.
    • Progress comparison errors. Research progress is obtained by accumulating floating-point values, and direct equality comparison may miss cases. Use a greater-than-or-equal comparison or set a tolerance.
    • Ignoring research interruption. The player may cancel research or resources may be consumed, and generated code needs to explain how these cases are handled.

    7. Conclusion

    Strategy games are an effective test for evaluating an LLM’s comprehensive capabilities. They require the model to understand rules, state, timing, and intent at the same time, and the results can be verified directly through runtime behavior.

    Evaluation conclusions should be based on observable behavior. Whether an implementation is acceptable should depend on whether it satisfies the time characteristics of real-time play, whether it guarantees fairness for both sides, whether the assistant works correctly under resource constraints, and whether edge cases are handled reasonably. Looking only at a demo video or subjective impressions makes it difficult to distinguish surface implementation from implementation that truly understands the rules.

    For R&D teams, this testing method can also be transferred to other scenarios, such as evaluating requirement understanding for scheduling systems, simulation, and automated operations tools. The key is to break requirements into verifiable rules and then check them item by item with a fixed acceptance checklist.