AI Coding Agents for Firmware Development: A Hands-on UEFI Snake Game Test and Pitfall Guide
This article reports a hands-on evaluation of AI coding agents on firmware-layer development, using a UEFI graphics Snake game as the test case. It lays out the task constraints and a three-round iteration process — a basic version, a feature-enhanced version, and a fully Chinese-localized version — and groups the problems the agents exposed into six categories: overreaching file writes outside the working directory, incomplete setup of the simulated runtime environment, GOP graphics interface details, Chinese character rendering and text encoding, memory and call-timing hazards, and build and runtime verification. It then compares three agents across successive projects and closes with six practical recommendations for human-AI collaboration. Developers will learn where AI coding agents excel, where they fall short, and how to structure constraints and verification to get reliable results in firmware work.
1. Introduction: Why Test Coding Agents with a Firmware-Layer Mini-Game
Building applications at the firmware layer is a good way to observe the overall capabilities of an AI coding agent. This kind of development has several built-in difficulties:
- No operating system underneath: The program runs directly in the environment provided by UEFI firmware. At startup there is no file system and no graphics driver, and routine techniques such as calling standard libraries or using process isolation are unavailable.
- Low-level interfaces: Graphics output depends on the GOP (Graphics Output Protocol) defined by the firmware specification, and input depends on a simple text input protocol. Higher-level abstractions such as windows, event loops, and timers all have to be implemented from scratch.
- Strict timing requirements: The UEFI application lifecycle is short. Once you call the exit function of the boot services, the related memory is reclaimed, and any subsequent access to boot-service functions will almost certainly cause a fault.
- Limited debugging options: When a program fails, it often just shows a black screen or reboots automatically, making it hard to set breakpoints, single-step, or print stack traces the way you would with a normal program.
Implementing a Snake game in this environment involves a modest amount of code, but the requirements are dense. It covers graphics rendering, input handling, the animation loop, collision detection, state management, progressive difficulty, and interface localization all at once. The build also has to deal with the toolchain, the boot media, and a simulation environment. This broad coverage makes it a good test of an agent’s ability to understand and deliver under complex constraints.
This article is based on a complete practice run using an AI coding agent to build a UEFI graphics application: about three hours in total, more than twenty prompts, and three rounds of iteration — a basic version, a feature-enhanced version, and a fully Chinese-localized version. The article groups the problems that surfaced into six categories, compares the results with two other similar projects, and finally offers reusable practical advice.
2. Test Plan and Iteration Process
2.1 Task Constraints
- Runtime environment: A UEFI application launched from the UEFI Shell, with graphics output through the GOP protocol and no audio.
- Supporting environment: A pure-software UEFI application that runs in a firmware simulation environment during testing, so no physical hardware is required.
- Requirements list: Core Snake gameplay, menus and status hints, keyboard control (arrow keys and WASD), pause, multiple levels, obstacles, particle effects, and a fully Chinese interface.
- Startup: Start from an empty directory and let the agent build everything from project initialization to a runnable version on its own.
2.2 Three Rounds of Iteration
- Round 1: Basic version. Establish the build pipeline, implement GOP graphics initialization, and implement core logic such as snake movement, eating food, and collision detection.
- Round 2: Feature-enhanced version. Introduce double-buffered rendering, multiple levels, obstacles, and particle effects, and add dual keyboard control and pause.
- Round 3: Localization. Convert the menu, status display, and control hints to Chinese, and solve the problem of rendering Chinese characters in the firmware environment.
The final delivered version has the following features:
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Pure firmware execution | Runs directly at the firmware layer with no dependency on any OS |
| Fully Chinese interface | Chinese menus, status display, and control hints |
| Hardware-accelerated graphics | Directly drives the GPU framebuffer through the GOP protocol |
| Double-buffered rendering | Draws to a back buffer first, then refreshes the whole frame at once to eliminate tearing |
| Multi-level system | Levels advance automatically as the score increases, with rising difficulty |
| Obstacle system | Obstacles appear in higher levels to increase the challenge |
| Particle effects | Visual feedback triggers when food is eaten |
| Keyboard control | Supports both arrow keys and WASD |
| Pause | Press P to pause or resume at any time |
2.3 Observation Dimensions
- Requirement understanding: Did it grasp the core constraint of “no OS, GOP graphics output”?
- Context adherence: Did it follow the agreed directory layout and framework?
- Environment setup: Were the build chain, boot media, and simulation environment right the first time?
- Code correctness: Does it compile and actually run to the expected effect?
- Self-correction: When it hit a problem, could it locate the root cause instead of repeatedly trial-and-erroring?
- Iteration stability: As features grew, did existing functionality regress?
3. Six Categories of Problems Exposed in Practice
Pitfall 1: Overreaching File Access and Loss of Directory Boundaries
Symptoms: The prompt explicitly specified a working directory, but when initializing the project the agent created the project structure one level above the working directory. Once it reached the build stage, it generated multiple directories — build tools, build artifacts, configuration — in the parent directory as well.
Impact analysis:
- It polluted directories outside the task scope, mixing with other content on the user’s machine.
- The project boundary became unclear, making later location and cleanup difficult.
- It shows that the agent’s understanding of the “working directory” is soft. Even with the parameter that skips permission confirmation enabled, it does not constrain its own write scope on its own.
Cross-observation: A similar problem appeared in an earlier project of the same graphics-app type: the agent set up the project structure outside the target directory on its own initiative. This kind of behavior is not necessarily a model-capability issue; it looks more like a lack of boundary awareness when executing autonomously.
Recommendations:
- Use a strongly worded constraint in the first prompt to limit the write scope;
- Configure the permission policy on the principle of least privilege, preferring a configurable directory allowlist;
- After each round of tasks, check the directory tree and correct any boundary violations immediately.
[Work boundary] All files created or modified from now on must be located within thecurrent working directory. Creating files in the parent or adjacent directories isstrictly forbidden. When you need to install external tools, first explain their purposeand install location, and proceed only after confirmation.
Pitfall 2: Incomplete Setup of the Simulated Runtime Environment
Symptoms: Although the prompt already hinted at using an emulator, the agent still chose to download a prebuilt firmware image on its own to save compilation time. The problem: the firmware’s boot menu had no UEFI Shell boot entry, and no application was placed on the boot media. This directly led to “compiles successfully, but there is no way to verify it.”
Impact analysis:
- Runtime verification is the key to closing the loop in firmware application development. Without a runnable verification environment, every subsequent change can only be guessed at.
- Prebuilt firmware images differ in boot-entry configuration, default boot paths, and device mapping. Using one without checking tends to stall at the very first step.
- The agent chose its own dependencies, showing no awareness that “once the environment is set up, it must be verified.”
Recommendations: Environment setup should be led by the developer or strictly reviewed. At minimum, confirm:
- Whether the firmware exposes a UEFI Shell entry — for example, whether a Shell is built in or a Shell boot entry is supported;
- Whether the application is placed at the default path required by the boot media — for example, the default boot file path on a FAT-formatted medium;
- Whether the boot parameters correctly point to that medium — for example, the drive mapping and boot-order configuration in the emulator;
- Whether observation means such as a serial port or screenshots are available, so you can confirm the program has started.
Pitfall 3: Interface Details of GOP Graphics Programming
In a firmware environment, everything on screen comes from GOP, and a misunderstanding often shows up directly as a black screen, garbled graphics, or a crash.
- Pixel format: Different display devices may use different pixel arrangements, such as RGB versus BGR. Decide based on the frame-buffer pixel-format field rather than hard-coding color values.
- Resolution and mode switching: Querying a mode, setting a mode, and reading mode information are easy to mix up. When mode setting fails, you must check the return status and prepare a fallback.
- Off-screen buffers and block transfer: If static backgrounds, menus, and characters are written pixel by pixel, performance is poor. It is common to allocate an off-screen buffer as root-pool memory and then use a block-transfer operation for a whole-frame refresh.
- Basic rendering primitives: Filling rectangles, drawing characters, and computing character spacing all need to be implemented consistently within your own rendering layer.
/* Illustrative code: all GOP operations must go through status checks *//* The EFI_STATUS Status declaration and the retrieval of gImageHandle and gGop are omitted *//* Query current mode information */UINT32 ModeIdx = gGop->Mode->Mode; /* Save the original mode for fallback */EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_MODE_INFORMATION *Info = NULL;UINTN SizeOfInfo = 0;Status = gGop->QueryMode (gGop, ModeIdx, &SizeOfInfo, &Info);if (EFI_ERROR (Status)) { /* Log the error and exit */ }/* When using BltVideoToBltBuffer, the target buffer must be allocated from the root pool */UINTN FrameSize = (UINTN)Info->PixelsPerScanLine* Info->VerticalResolution * 4; /* 4 bytes per pixel */UINT8 *BackBuf = NULL;Status = gBS->AllocatePool (EfiBootServicesData, FrameSize,(VOID **)&BackBuf);/* Then use Blt operations to refresh the entire frame to the display device, as shown below *//* gGop->Blt (gGop, BackBuf, EfiBltBufferToVideo,0, 0, 0, 0, Info->HorizontalResolution,Info->VerticalResolution, 0); */
If you debug this kind of code only on a normal platform, you can rely on screenshots and logs to locate problems quickly. But in an emulator, a single out-of-bounds write can trigger an abnormal reboot, so you must agree on parameter validation and error paths in advance.
Pitfall 4: Chinese Character Rendering and Text Encoding
In UEFI, the basic unit of a string is the wide character, and common pitfalls related to rendering Chinese glyphs include:
- Mixed encoding: Mixing single-byte and double-byte characters in string constants and variables easily causes linker errors or garbled output;
- Missing glyph data: The firmware environment does not include a Chinese font by default. Simplified Chinese characters are usually laid out contiguously within the Unicode Extension A block, so you can index a bitmap font directly using “Unicode value minus the block’s start value,” but you must supply the font data yourself;
- Character width: Chinese characters usually occupy two English character positions in a monospaced font, so menu layout and alignment computed on a single-byte basis will misalign;
- Background handling: Chinese glyphs need a background color filled within the character cell, otherwise the Snake pattern on the underlying image will show through;
- Refresh order: When double buffering and Chinese text are used together, whole-frame refreshes cause the text to flicker, so static menus and dynamic elements should be maintained in separate layers.
Pitfall 5: Memory and Call Timing
In firmware applications, memory management is far more sensitive than in normal programs:
- Lifetime errors: After boot services exit, the boot-service table is no longer available. If the code still calls boot-service functions such as allocate and free at that point, it crashes immediately. A common mistake is to dynamically allocate a buffer inside the graphics loop without taking the exit timing into account;
- Pointers and lengths: For collection structures such as snake-body coordinates, food positions, and the particle list, once memory is reallocated the old pointers become invalid immediately and must be updated in sync;
- Free paths: If any step in the allocation path fails, all previously allocated memory should be released in full to avoid leaks caused by an early return;
- Input protocol release: When using the extended text input protocol, close it promptly after use, otherwise it will occupy console input.
Recommendations: Treat “boot services exit” as an explicit architectural boundary. Complete all long-lived memory allocations and protocol initialization before exit, use only protocol interfaces afterward, and mark the boundary in code comments.
Pitfall 6: Build and Runtime Verification
- Toolchain differences: Different toolchains have different requirements for target format, dependency libraries, and entry configuration. Build scripts generated by AI are often based on a certain conventional style, and if that does not match your local environment, linking fails repeatedly;
- Creating boot media: Application files usually need to be placed in a specific directory structure and packaged as a bootable image, such as FAT-formatted boot media. Path case and filename length both affect whether they can be recognized;
- Emulator launch parameters: Parameters such as boot order, drive-letter mapping, and the display window are not unified and are easy to confuse during debugging;
- Observability: After a program is launched from the Shell, if there is no output it is hard to tell whether it is stuck in initialization or whether a graphics interface call failed. It is recommended to print status at key steps and show the failure reason on screen instead of rebooting directly.
4. Cross-Comparison: Three Agents on Firmware Tasks
Looking at the three practice runs together reveals a clear set of common patterns.
| Dimension | This run (Model A) | Earlier run (Model B) | Even earlier run (Model C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Task type | UEFI graphics Snake | Similar graphics app | Firmware-layer graphics app |
| Directory boundaries | Wrote outside scope multiple times | Project structure misplaced | Similar to this run |
| Environment setup | Downloaded a prebuilt firmware image itself | Failed to fully verify execution | About the same |
| Graphics implementation | Completed GOP rendering and double buffering | Basically usable | Usable |
| Chinese localization | Completed | Not attempted | Not attempted |
| Self-correction | Partly self-repaired | Relied on manual hints | Relied on manual hints |
Takeaways from the comparison:
- The more a decision “looks convenient,” the more it needs human confirmation. The agent chose a prebuilt firmware image instead of building it itself; on the surface that sped things up, but in practice it introduced an unverified runtime environment.
- Boundary awareness is a common weakness of most agents today. No matter which model, as soon as it is granted autonomy to “do the work,” it may overstep in directory management, so external constraints are essential.
- Capability differences show up mostly in how fast iterations converge. From the basic version to the localized version, if the project structure has to be re-explained every round, the cost rises sharply.
5. Six Recommendations for Using AI Coding Agents Well
- Set the rules first, then assign the task. Use a short project-description file to fix the directory structure, build commands, and verification method, so the agent works within constraints.
- Build the environment yourself, or at least accept it yourself. The “foundation” — emulator images, boot media, boot-entry configuration — should be led by the developer, or verified item by item by the developer.
- Move in small steps and accept each round. Advance only one goal per round, for example “first display a single block,” “then make the snake move,” “finally add the menu,” rather than piling on all requirements at once.
- Make invisible failures visible. Add status printing, on-screen error messages, and log persistence so the agent also has “eyes.”
- Replace vague descriptions with structured prompts. Specifying interfaces, data structures, directory locations, and acceptance criteria reduces rework far more than “you figure it out.”
- Keep human judgment in the loop. Any operation involving file-write scope, downloading external dependencies, or enabling permission parameters should be confirmed by a human before execution.
6. Conclusion
From this practice run, AI coding agents already show fairly strong code-generation capability on firmware-layer tasks. From GOP graphics initialization to double-buffered rendering, and on to Chinese glyph handling, the core logic mostly came together on the first pass. The real difficulty lies in the “environment” and the “boundaries”: whether the simulated runtime environment is ready, whether directory permissions are controlled, and whether call timing follows the rules.
For developers, rather than asking “which model is stronger,” it is better to build a workflow for human-AI collaboration: humans handle the environment, the constraints, and acceptance, while the agent handles implementation and iteration. This keeps the agent’s efficiency advantage while meeting firmware development’s high demand for determinism.
