Lessons from Using Large Language Models to Assist Low-Level Firmware Development
A hands-on retrospective on using large language models to develop and debug a small firmware-level graphics program: why generating code and fixing code are different skills, how to build a reproducible debugging workflow, and what collaboration patterns actually work when bringing AI-assisted code from "runs once" to "maintainable."
Lessons from Using Large Language Models to Assist Low-Level Firmware Development
Background: When “Code That Generates” Meets “Code That Runs”
In low-level firmware and system software development, code generation is only the first step. The real challenge is getting a program to run reliably in a controlled environment. I recently ran a hands-on experiment around “using general-purpose large language models to assist development of a small firmware-level graphics program”: one type of model generated several small graphics programs, then a different model took over and fixed the legacy code it inherited. Two patterns emerged clearly. First, results for the same type of task varied significantly across models and environments. Second, “generating code” and “fixing code” are not the same capability — the former leans on building from scratch, while the latter depends far more on context understanding, runtime feedback, and disciplined debugging.
To be clear, this is not a product ranking or a benchmark of specific models. Different tasks, environments, and acceptance criteria are not directly comparable. The more valuable questions are: in low-level development, which stages suit LLM assistance, and how should developers design the collaboration workflow to push “plausible-looking code” toward “verifiable programs”?
On Fairness: Evaluation Dimensions Matter More Than Results
Some argued that having different models work on different tasks is unfair. That concern is legitimate. A rigorous comparison would need to control at least these dimensions:
- Task complexity: consistent feature set, inputs and outputs, graphics rendering, and error handling;
- Runtime environment: consistent firmware version, toolchain, and emulator or real-device conditions;
- Acceptance criteria: consistent definitions of compile success, first successful run, stable runtime duration, and maintainability;
- Human intervention budget: how many runtime logs and error feedback rounds the developer may provide;
- Time budget: whether total time and iteration rounds are capped.
In real development, however, tasks are rarely symmetric. Rather than chasing an “absolutely fair model comparison,” it is more meaningful to treat the model as a tool within an engineering workflow and observe how it performs in specific stages: taking over legacy code, isolating low-level issues, and filling in debugging information. Following this approach, I migrated the modular legacy code from earlier work into a new environment unchanged, and had a different model perform two rounds of fixes: the first round aimed at getting it to run; the second aimed at refinement and optimization.
Taking Over Legacy Code: Build a Reproducible Scene First
Legacy code is not “dead code.” Even if a program cannot run, its directory structure, module layout, and interface design may still hold reference value. In this case, the legacy code spanned multiple files with modular design and a reasonably clean structure. Discarding it outright would be wasteful, but running it directly risks the classic “fix one thing, break five” trap. So the first step was not to let the model rewrite everything — it was establishing a reproducible scene:
- Freeze the original code and keep a version snapshot;
- Copy it unchanged into the new environment, avoiding contamination from old build artifacts;
- Complete the build and run instructions, clarifying the entry point, dependencies, and output channels;
- Enable serial logging or an equivalent debug channel so boot-stage output is visible;
- Have the model perform a code review first — not a rewrite.
The first instruction can be deliberately restrained: “Review this code, list the issues per module that could prevent it from running, and suggest a verification order.” The model then examined the entry function, main loop, game logic, rendering module, and input handling, and produced a problem list. The value of this stage is not that the list is guaranteed correct — it moves the developer from “no idea where to start” to “hypotheses that can be verified.”
First Fix Round: From Crash-on-Boot to Runnable
On first run, the program displayed a startup message and exited immediately. That was progress over a program that would not run at all, but still far from usable. The developer asked the model to add more debugging output and monitored progress through the serial port. The investigation showed the program crashed after invoking the graphics output protocol. Further analysis revealed the risk: the pointer returned by the display-mode query pointed to a temporary or invalidated memory region — continuing to use it after switching display modes turned it into a dangling pointer.
The fix was straightforward but highly representative: re-query the framebuffer information after switching display modes instead of reusing the old pointer. Here is the illustrative code:
status = get_display_protocol(&proto);if (status != OK) {log("get display protocol failed");return;}mode_info = query_mode(proto);if (!mode_info.valid) {log("query mode failed");return;}set_mode(proto, target_mode);/* Key: re-query after setting the mode; never reuse the old pointer */mode_info = query_mode(proto);framebuffer = mode_info.framebuffer;if (!framebuffer) {log("framebuffer unavailable");return;}
After the change, the program no longer crashed on startup. But the second issue surfaced immediately: the program ran, yet no graphics appeared. After receiving the runtime results, the model analyzed that the graphics output protocol’s identifier configuration might be wrong. Low-level frameworks often define multiple related identifiers, and using the wrong one means the graphics output protocol cannot be acquired correctly. After correcting the protocol identifier, the graphics output path finally came together.
The lesson from this round: low-level problems cannot be solved by static review alone. The model can propose high-probability hypotheses, but they must be validated with runtime logs, error codes, and minimal reproductions. The more specific the developer’s feedback, the faster the model can narrow down the root cause.
Second Round: From “Runs” to “Maintainable”
The first round solved survival; the second round addressed engineering quality. The refinement stage can focus on:
- Error handling: check return values on every protocol acquisition, mode query, and buffer access;
- Resource cleanup: consolidate exit paths to avoid handle or memory leaks;
- Module boundaries: decouple rendering, input, game state, and the platform adaptation layer;
- Log levels: separate searchable logs for boot, protocol, rendering, and input;
- Input robustness: guard against empty input, repeated keypresses, and boundary coordinates;
- Readability: consistent naming, key comments where they matter, removal of dead branches;
- Regression checks: rebuild, run, and record results after every change.
The model’s strength in this phase is tirelessly adding checks — but the risk is producing code that looks complete yet violates platform constraints. Refinement therefore must pair with human review and small, incremental commits. A good practice: change only one theme per round, such as “error handling only” or “resource cleanup only,” then immediately compile and run to prevent problems from stacking up.
Key Debugging Lessons and Collaboration Rules
Several reusable lessons came out of this practice:
- Review before rewrite: have the model produce a problem list and verification order first; avoid large-scale rewrites up front;
- Logs first: if a low-level program lacks logs, add debugging output before attempting diagnosis;
- Minimal reproduction: narrow each issue to a single point — protocol acquisition, mode switching, or rendering initialization;
- Hypotheses must be verifiable: every model claim should map to an observable runtime behavior or error code;
- Small commits: keep a version of every change so failures can be rolled back;
- Human review of protocol details: for platform specifications, memory lifetimes, and protocol identifiers, never blindly trust generated results;
- Unified acceptance criteria: stage acceptance into compile success, first run, stable run, and regression pass.
If you need to reproduce the test environment in the cloud, container platforms, logging services, and monitoring and alerting tools can improve reproducibility; your specific choices should still be driven by your team’s existing environment and compliance requirements.
Takeaways and Conclusion
The overall impression: in low-level firmware development, large language models work best as a “high-intensity collaboration assistant,” not an “automated deliverer.” They excel at quickly reading modular code, listing suspicious points, filling in debugging information, and drafting fixes. But their awareness of the runtime environment depends on developer feedback, and details like protocol lifecycles, pointer validity, and platform identifiers still require human verification. Model-generated code may look the part — but only compile, run, logs, and regression testing can turn a draft into an engineering deliverable.
The more reliable collaboration model, therefore, is: humans define acceptance criteria, provide runtime feedback, and enforce platform constraints; models accelerate reviews, propose hypotheses, generate fix drafts, and complete repetitive code. Fold “model generation” into version control, logging, and testing pipelines, and only then can LLM assistance genuinely improve delivery certainty for complex low-level tasks.
