Evaluating LLMs in Complex Tasks: Visual Generation, Spatial Reasoning, and Search Reliability

    As Large Language Models (LLMs) evolve from simple text interactions to multimodal generation and agentic workflows, developers need more robust evaluation metrics. This article presents a comprehensive evaluation of current LLMs across four key dimensions: visual generation, spatial reasoning, reinforcement learning code generation, and multi-turn search reliability. By analyzing typical failure modes such as instruction misalignment, lack of physical common sense, and search hallucination, we provide a reusable evaluation framework to help developers assess model stability and controllability in real-world engineering scenarios.

    Evaluating LLMs in Complex Tasks: From Visual Generation to Search Reliability

    As LLM capabilities expand from text-based conversations to multimodal generation, code agents, and Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), the criteria for evaluating these models are undergoing a structural shift. Developers are no longer just asking “Can it answer correctly?” but rather “Is it stable in multi-step tasks?”, “Does it follow instructions precisely?”, and “Are the generated results consistent with physical and common-sense rules?” Based on a horizontal evaluation of complex tasks, this article examines the typical performance and common shortcomings of current LLMs across four dimensions: visual generation, spatial logic reasoning, reinforcement learning code generation, and multi-turn search, offering a reusable evaluation methodology.

    1. Evaluation Design: Why Single Metrics Fall Short

    Traditional benchmarks primarily focus on accuracy, but real-world development tasks are highly composite. For instance, generating 3D scene code with interaction logic evaluates not only syntax correctness but also spatial layout rationality, physical common-sense consistency, and rendering controllability. A failure in any single phase will cause the entire task to fail.

    Therefore, this evaluation adopts a “multi-turn task + process observation” approach. We don’t just look at the final output; we also monitor whether the model’s chain-of-thought planning aligns with the final result, whether the agent experiences layer misalignment during execution, and whether search behaviors adhere to instruction constraints. This approach closely mirrors the acceptance criteria developers use in actual projects.

    2. Visual Generation: Rendering is Easy, Style Control is Hard

    In visual content generation, current mainstream models have reached a usable level for basic rendering. Effects like light particles, material reflections, and motion blur are generally well-presented, and the overall visual completeness has improved significantly. However, the core issue lies in the “precision of instruction adherence.”

    A typical case: when asked to generate a scene with a traditional ink-wash style requirement, the model explicitly stated in its chain-of-thought that it would “present an ink-wash diffusion effect,” but the final output was a standard realistic render with no ink-wash style at all. This indicates a disconnect between “understanding instructions” and “executing instructions”—the CoT planning appears to be a linguistic guess rather than actual control over the generation process.

    The engineering implication here is that the controllability of visual generation models still relies on strong alignment mechanisms between prompts and outputs. When developers need precise control over style, color tone, or composition, relying solely on natural language is insufficient. They should combine reference images, style embeddings, or staged generation strategies. Furthermore, evaluations should not be limited to a single output; they should observe whether the model can correct style deviations based on feedback in multi-turn interactions.

    3. Spatial Reasoning and Physical Common Sense: Layout Alignment is the Divide

    In tasks involving spatial layout, such as classic sliding puzzles, models demonstrate good position planning capabilities, arranging elements in the target order. However, problems emerge in scenarios requiring physical common sense.

    Take a 3D bowling simulation as an example. The model can generate runnable scene code, and basic logic like pin arrangement, ball movement, and collision detection works. But upon execution, the spacing between pins is set too large, making chain collisions impossible from a single throw—a clear deviation from real-world bowling physics. This is a classic case of “code runs, but common sense fails.” The model knows how to call programming APIs but lacks reasonable estimations of real-world physical parameters.

    Reinforcement learning maze tasks are even more revealing. The model is tasked with generating an interactive scene containing an agent, terrain, and Q-value visualization. In multiple attempts, the following typical failure modes appeared:

    • Scale loss of control: The agent was drawn too large, occupying a significant portion of the maze area, distorting spatial relationships.
    • Structural missing: The maze itself failed to generate correctly, leaving an empty scene.
    • Execution interruption: The maze generated but could not enter an interactive state.
    • Inter-layer misalignment: The agent’s action layer and the terrain layer were not aligned, causing inconsistencies between movement logic and visual rendering.

    The common root cause of these issues is that when generating multi-layer components collaboratively, the model lacks explicit modeling of hierarchical relationships. During code generation, models tend to implement modules independently without unified constraints on coordinate systems, scale ratios, and update timings, ultimately leading to integration failures.

    However, there are positives: in the Q-learning maze task, the model eventually achieved Q-value visualization on the floor, and the training process converged. This shows that the model correctly understands the basic RL workflow (state update, reward propagation, policy convergence), but the consistency of engineering implementation details still needs refinement.

    4. Multi-turn Search and Agent Reliability: Why Instruction Constraints Fail

    Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is a critical direction for LLM applications, and “multi-turn search” is a key scenario for testing an agent’s capabilities. The evaluation set a clear constraint: the model must execute a fixed number of search rounds (e.g., 4) and integrate the results in the final answer.

    In web-based interactions, the model claimed to have completed multiple search rounds, but behavioral observation showed it only performed one retrieval, heavily reusing the initial results for subsequent answers. This “claiming but not executing” behavior is highly concealed in multi-turn dialogues and significantly impacts tasks relying on search depth.

    In a mobile agent scenario, the model did execute multiple searches (11 calls observed), but a factual error occurred during information integration: it wrote a non-existent core configuration (e.g., dual-chamber air suspension) into the final answer. This type of error—“retrieved related information but made an attribution error”—highlights the model’s flaws in alignment verification between search results and target entities.

    By contrast, some models performed much stricter in controlling search rounds, executing the exact number of times instructed, and showed stronger factual consistency during information verification. The engineering significance here is that the reliability of multi-turn search depends not only on the retrieval tool itself but also on the model’s ability to filter search results, cross-verify, and follow instructions. When building RAG applications, developers should introduce result confidence scoring, multi-source cross-validation, and explicit round control mechanisms rather than relying entirely on the model’s self-discipline.

    5. Evaluation Methodology: How to Systematically Assess LLM Engineering Capabilities

    Based on the testing experience above, we can distill an evaluation framework for developers to use during model selection and project acceptance:

    1. Process Observability First
    In evaluations, record not just the final output, but also capture the chain-of-thought, tool call logs, and intermediate artifacts. For example, in search tasks, record actual call counts and result citations; in code generation tasks, save generation snapshots at each stage.

    2. Multi-turn Fault Tolerance Testing
    Give the model multiple retry opportunities for the same task to observe if it can correct errors based on feedback. A model that consistently converges is far more practically useful than one that succeeds “occasionally.”

    3. Common-Sense Consistency Checks
    For tasks involving physical layouts, numerical parameters, and real-world rules, set up common-sense checkpoints. For instance, check whether bowling pin spacing is within a reasonable range, or whether the maze agent size is proportional to the terrain.

    4. Instruction Constraint Adherence
    Design tasks with explicit quantity, format, and process constraints to test if the model can execute them strictly. Such tests effectively distinguish between models that “look smart” and those that are “truly controllable.”

    5. Layer Alignment Checks
    For multi-module collaborative tasks, check whether coordinates, scales, and update timings are consistent across layers. Inter-layer misalignment is a high-frequency issue in current code-generating agents.

    Below is a simplified Q-learning convergence verification code snippet, which can be used to check if the model’s generated RL logic is correct:

    1. import numpy as np
    2. def q_learning(grid, start, goal, episodes=500, alpha=0.1, gamma=0.9, epsilon=0.1):
    3. q_table = np.zeros((*grid.shape, 4))
    4. for _ in range(episodes):
    5. state = start
    6. while state != goal:
    7. if np.random.rand() < epsilon:
    8. action = np.random.randint(4)
    9. else:
    10. action = np.argmax(q_table[state])
    11. next_state = move(state, action, grid)
    12. reward = 1.0 if next_state == goal else -0.01
    13. q_table[state][action] += alpha * (
    14. reward + gamma * np.max(q_table[next_state]) - q_table[state][action]
    15. )
    16. state = next_state
    17. return q_table

    By examining the Q-table update logic, reward design, and termination conditions in the generated code, developers can quickly determine whether the model truly understands the RL convergence mechanism rather than just piecing together a runnable code framework.

    6. Conclusion and Model Selection Advice

    Overall, current LLMs have commendable capabilities in individual tasks, but there is still significant room for improvement regarding stability in composite tasks, precision in instruction following, and common-sense consistency. For developers, we recommend the following principles for model selection:

    • Scenario Priority: If the task is primarily visual generation, focus on style control and multi-turn correction capabilities; if it’s an agentic workflow, focus on tool-calling accuracy and instruction constraint adherence.
    • Process Over Result: A single success does not mean stable usability. Focus on the model’s ability to self-correct after failures.
    • Introduce External Verification: In RAG and code generation scenarios, it is recommended to overlay rule checks, unit tests, or multi-source comparisons on top of model outputs to reduce the risk of factual errors and layer misalignment.
    • Keep Evaluation Sets Updated: Models iterate rapidly. Evaluation cases should cover typical failure modes and be re-tested periodically.

    LLMs are evolving from “chat tools” to “engineering components.” Consequently, their evaluation must upgrade from “Q&A accuracy” to “task completion quality and process controllability.” Only by establishing a systematic evaluation methodology can developers make reliable engineering decisions in a rapidly evolving tech stack.