How to Benchmark LLM Code Generation on Bare-Metal UEFI (and Common Pitfalls to Avoid)
This article presents a reproducible approach to evaluating large language model code-generation ability in bare-metal environments, using "building a classic game under the UEFI Shell" as a unified benchmark. It explains why firmware-level tasks expose weaknesses that web-style prompts miss, how to set up a reproducible test environment with EDK2, OVMF, and QEMU, how to design a weighted scoring rubric with a recording sheet, which I/O protocols generated code should target, observed results for two publicly available models, common failure patterns with concrete fixes, and how teams can turn evaluation into a reliable model-selection process.
1. Introduction: Why Bare-Metal Environments Are Worth Testing
When teams evaluate an LLM’s coding ability, they often reach for tasks like “write a web page,” “build an API,” or “refactor this function.” Such tasks reflect ordinary development skill but rarely expose how stable a model is at the real boundaries of engineering. Bare-metal environments are valuable precisely because there is no operating system, no standard library, and no debugger. The model must face firmware specifications, protocol calls, resource release, and error returns directly.
This article uses one unified benchmark — developing a classic game under the UEFI Shell — to discuss how to run the evaluation, how to record results, how to avoid common mistakes, and how a team should choose a suitable model. This is an independent technical observation. The test accounts are personal, calls were made under public billing, no vendor-granted credits were used, and none of this constitutes a purchasing or commercial partnership recommendation.
Testing took place mainly in early March 2025. The subjects were two publicly available models: V4-Pro and V4-Flash. Because models iterate quickly, the conclusions here apply only to the versions tested; anyone reproducing this should re-record the model version, call parameters, and runtime environment.
2. From the Application Layer to Bare Metal: How Much Harder Is It?
If we summarize the difference in one sentence: in a browser or a high-level language runtime, the smallest runnable unit is usually a page, a function, or a service; in the UEFI Shell, the smallest runnable unit may be just a single line of characters on screen — and getting it there costs a VM reboot.
The difficulty jump shows up in four areas.
First, runtime support drops to zero. Runtimes like Node.js, the JDK, or the Python interpreter absorb language and platform differences. In a firmware environment, standard input/output, memory allocation, random numbers, and string handling must all rely explicitly on firmware protocols or be implemented by hand.
Second, the programming model is different. Web development is usually built on an event loop, with rendering handled by the browser engine. The firmware layer is closer to a “protocol, handle, status code” model: you locate a protocol, open a handle, call an interface, check the return value, and manually release resources.
Third, the feedback loop breaks. When application-layer code fails, you usually see a stack trace or console log; when a bare-metal program crashes, the VM may go to a black screen, hang, or drop straight back to the Shell, so the developer has to rely on serial logs, screenshots, and staged output to locate the problem step by step.
Fourth, there are more constraints. Before calling an interface you must confirm the service is available, buffers must be size-checked, and before redrawing you must check whether the output mode supports the graphics protocol. Overlooking any one of these can cause the program to exit unexpectedly at runtime.
So a bare-metal task does not test how many APIs a model has memorized — it tests whether the model can constrain itself without a high-level runtime to catch mistakes: not inventing interfaces, not crossing specification boundaries, and handling every return value correctly.
3. Test Environment and Methodology
To make the evaluation reproducible, this section describes only the environment and runtime conditions; the scoring dimensions are defined in Part 4.
Which firmware version?
The example environment uses the EDK2 stable branch:
- Branch: edk2-stable202411
- Example commit: 6b4a1f2
- Target architecture: X64
- Firmware emulation: OVMF
- Run method: boot into the UEFI Shell and manually launch the generated .efi application
If you use a different EDK2 commit when reproducing, record the actual commit, the build date, and the source of the OVMF file.
Which build toolchain?
The host system is Windows 10/11 x64. Visual Studio 2019 16.11.35 is used with the following components selected:
- Desktop development with C++
- MSVC v142 - VS 2019 C++ x64/x86 build tools
- Windows 10 SDK 10.0.22621.0 or later
- C++ ATL / MFC are optional; this evaluation does not require them
Example build command:
git clone https://github.com/tianocore/edk2.gitcd edk2git checkout 6b4a1f2git submodule update --initedksetup.batset WORKSPACE=%CD%set EDK_TOOLS_PATH=%CD%\BaseToolsbuild -a X64 -t VS2019 -p OvmfPkg/OvmfPkgX64.dsc -b RELEASE
To build a UEFI Shell application, you can use a similar command:
build -a X64 -t VS2019 -p AppPkg/AppPkg.dsc -m AppPkg/Applications/BareGame/BareGame.inf -b RELEASE
Virtual machine and physical machine conditions
VM configuration:
- QEMU/KVM or a compatible virtualization platform
- Memory: 2048 MB
- CPU: 2 cores
- Disk: no hard disk required; use OVMF firmware and a read-only/writable variable store
- Network: disabled, to avoid generated code depending on the network
- Example run command:
qemu-system-x86_64 -m 2048 \-drive if=pflash,format=raw,readonly=on,file=OVMF_CODE.fd \-drive if=pflash,format=raw,file=OVMF_VARS.fd \-drive file=fat:rw:./build,format=raw,if=virtio
Physical machine conditions:
- An x86_64 UEFI machine
- At least 8 GB of memory
- Supports the UEFI Shell or can boot from a USB drive
- No operating system installed; boot directly into the firmware Shell
- Record the machine model, BIOS version, and firmware version
Full prompt text
To reduce leading hints, the prompt contains no framework preferences and does not specify a concrete implementation path. The prompt template used is:
Build a complete, runnable classic game that can run directly in the UEFI Shell, with the following features:[game name][core gameplay][visual elements][interaction logic][runtime requirements]Additional requirements:1. Must be based on real, usable UEFI protocols; do not fabricate functions that do not exist.2. If the graphics output protocol is unavailable, fall back to simple text output.3. If the input protocol is unavailable, provide a clear error message or exit logic.4. All opened resources must be released before the program exits.5. Output should include C code that can be compiled directly, or the INF file configuration needed.
Example of the filled-in prompt:
[game name] A Space Invaders–style mini game[core gameplay] The player controls a ship at the bottom and fires bullets to destroy enemies moving downward from the top[visual elements] Ship, enemies, bullets, score, lives[interaction logic] Left/right movement, firing, collision detection, scoring, game over, restart[runtime requirements] Run directly in the UEFI Shell, prefer graphics output; if unavailable, use text mode
How were model parameters recorded?
Call parameters were recorded uniformly as:
- Temperature: 0.2
- top_p: 0.9
- Max output length: 4096 tokens
- Timeout: 120 seconds
- Fixed random seed: recorded if supported; if not, record the call time and session ID
- Generation rounds: the same prompt was generated only once, to avoid injecting extra effective context manually
- Correction policy: only one round of correction is allowed, limited to fixing compile errors and obvious runtime anomalies, without changing the task’s style
4. Evaluation Design: Scoring Table, Weights, and Record Sheet
Scoring uses five dimensions, each rated from 1 to 5, with a weighted overall score.
| Dimension | Weight | Observation points |
|---|---|---|
| Functional completeness | 30% | Whether the core gameplay loop is complete; can start, end, and restart |
| Environment compatibility | 20% | Runs in the target environment without changes or with only minor tweaks |
| Code quality | 20% | Structure, error handling, resource release, comment readability |
| Visuals and experience | 15% | Graphics or text output, frame-rate behavior, input responsiveness |
| Iteration efficiency | 15% | Time for a single round of edits; whether the second round introduces new problems |
Definitions of 1 to 5:
- 1 point: unusable. Fails to compile, or fails on first run with no way to determine the cause from logs.
- 2 points: weakly usable. Needs considerable correction to run, missing core functionality, with clearly insufficient error handling.
- 3 points: basically usable. Compiles and the core gameplay loop is complete, but there are issues with resource release, state management, or experience.
- 4 points: good. Runs after one or a few corrections, with a fairly clear structure and reasonably complete exception handling and resource management.
- 5 points: excellent. Runs on first generation, with clear code structure and complete error handling, resource release, and fallback logic.
Overall score formula:
Overall score = Functional completeness × 0.30+ Environment compatibility × 0.20+ Code quality × 0.20+ Visuals and experience × 0.15+ Iteration efficiency × 0.15
Scoring record sheet template:
| Model | Task | Compile result | First run | Corrections | Func. | Compat. | Quality | Visuals | Iteration | Overall | Main issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example model | Simple drawing | Pass | Pass | 0 | |||||||
| Example model | Space Invaders | Pass | Partial | 1 |
5. Optional Technical Routes: How a Model “Sees” and “Hears” on Bare Metal
In a UEFI environment, whether model-generated code actually runs depends first on whether it chooses the right input/output protocols. There are three common routes.
The first is the graphics output route. A program can use EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL to switch to graphics mode and draw the screen with the pixel-level interface it provides. This route suits characters, backgrounds, collision effects, and score displays, but places higher demands on frame synchronization, dirty-region refresh, and buffer management.
The second is the text output route. A program can use EFI_SIMPLE_TEXT_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL to output ASCII graphics in character mode, using cursor control to achieve a terminal-game-like effect. This route depends less on the graphics protocol, but the model must manage the character grid, cursor position, screen clearing, and redraw flicker itself.
The third is the input route. For keyboard input, try EFI_SIMPLE_TEXT_INPUT_EX_PROTOCOL first to support more complete key-state queries; if that protocol is unavailable, fall back to EFI_SIMPLE_TEXT_INPUT_PROTOCOL, or provide a clear exit prompt.
The fallback conditions when no protocol is available should be written explicitly into the evaluation criteria:
- If
EFI_GRAPHICS_OUTPUT_PROTOCOLcannot be obtained viaLocateProtocol, or the number of graphics modes is zero, fall back toEFI_SIMPLE_TEXT_OUTPUT_PROTOCOL. - If no text output protocol can be obtained, return an error code or output an error message the Shell can recognize.
- If no input protocol can be obtained, allow the program to start but tell the user that keyboard input is unavailable, and avoid an infinite loop.
- If the model hardcodes a nonexistent protocol or function, deduct points in the environment-compatibility dimension.
6. Observed Results and Quantitative Outcomes
The following are illustrative test records; the numbers demonstrate the scoring method and are not permanent conclusions for all versions.
| Model | Task | Compile result | First run | Corrections | Overall | Main issue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| V4-Pro | Simple rectangle movement | Pass | Pass | 0 | 4.7 | Clear structure; coordinates and input are well separated |
| V4-Flash | Simple rectangle movement | Pass | Pass | 0 | 4.2 | Compact code; few comments |
| V4-Pro | Space Invaders | Pass | Partial | 1 | 4.4 | Runs on first try; game-over flow needs minor tuning |
| V4-Flash | Space Invaders | Pass | Partial | 1 | 3.8 | Abnormal restart logic; returns to Shell directly after game over |
| V4-Pro | Multiple levels and power-ups | Compile failed | Not run | 1 | 3.5 | Generated a nonexistent audio interface — capability hallucination |
| V4-Flash | Multiple levels and power-ups | Pass | Runtime anomaly | 1 | 3.1 | Level switching did not clear entities; ghost enemies appeared |
From the results, the two models are close on simple tasks, both completing basic drawing and input response. The gap widens on medium tasks: V4-Pro is more complete in entity management, collision detection, and non-blocking input, while V4-Flash tends to leave residual state on complex state transitions. On complex tasks, both expose different kinds of problems: V4-Pro tends to over-engineer, generating audio capabilities that do not exist; V4-Flash is more likely to miss state cleanup and resource resets.
In addition, in the IDE-plugin experience, completion speed is decent, but complex calls occasionally show response latency, and cross-file understanding still has room to improve. When asked to “implement a new game mode based on the current project structure,” the generated code often covers only a single file and responds insufficiently to the overall architecture. This is consistent with the bare-metal findings: models are relatively stable at local correctness but still need human oversight for global consistency.
7. Common Errors, Reproduction Conditions, and Fix Suggestions
The value of a bare-metal evaluation lies not only in scoring but also in accumulating common errors. Three categories are worth recording in detail.
The first is ghost enemies. Reproduction conditions: when switching levels or restarting, the previous level’s enemy array, entity list, or counters are not cleared. Log evidence: on the first frame of the second level, enemy_count is greater than zero, but positions are abnormal or just outside the screen. Fix: call ResetEntities, FreeEntities, or ClearEnemies uniformly in the level initialization function, and zero the related counters and random-seed state.
The second is calling a nonexistent audio interface. Reproduction conditions: the prompt asks for audio, but the environment has no audio protocol, and the model still generates calls like Beep, PlaySound, or similar. Log evidence: undefined symbols appear at the compile stage, or linking fails. Fix: remove the audio-related logic, or change it to a text prompt; if it must be kept, use conditional compilation and clearly mark it as unavailable.
The third is handles not being closed. Reproduction conditions: the program calls LocateProtocol or OpenProtocol repeatedly but never calls CloseProtocol on the exit path. Log evidence: when a later image starts or a device is opened, EFI_ACCESS_DENIED, EFI_INVALID_PARAMETER, or unavailable-resource errors appear. Fix: use a unified cleanup path, such as goto exit, and close protocols, free buffers, and restore text mode before exiting.
8. From Evaluation to Practice: How Teams Choose a Model
The goal of evaluation is not a leaderboard but helping teams integrate model capability stably into the development workflow. When putting this into practice, focus on three points.
First, build a private evaluation set. Extract real tasks from the team’s code repository — implementing a module, fixing a defect, completing a state machine, handling resource release. Re-test periodically with a fixed scoring sheet; this is more reliable than looking only at external leaderboards.
Second, enforce a verification loop. No matter which model is used, generated code must go through compilation, static checks, unit tests, and startup in the emulation environment. Firmware projects especially need OVMF or QEMU startup verification to avoid leaving problems until the real-hardware stage.
Third, constrain the model with specifications. The prompt should include an interface list, status-code conventions, resource-release requirements, fallback conditions, and output format, reducing the space for the model to improvise.
When selecting, distinguish by scenario:
- Data-sensitive or offline environments: prioritize offline models that can be deployed on the intranet, focusing on deployment cost, inference resources, and maintainability.
- Rapid-validation scenarios: use low-cost models for prototype validation, but always pair with human review.
- Long-term development workflows: build a private evaluation set and continuously observe how the model performs on the team’s real tasks, rather than frequently swapping toolchains.
If the team uses a cloud model service, choose a platform with access control, audit logging, and data protection, and use logs and monitoring to keep calls traceable. Tools will keep evolving, but reproducible evaluation methods and strict engineering discipline are the long-term assets.
9. Conclusion: Evaluation Boundaries and Re-Test Recommendations
The conclusions here have a clear scope: they only reflect how the tested models performed on this specific task of building a classic game from scratch under the UEFI Shell, and cannot be directly extended to their ability in general programming, long-context understanding, or multi-turn collaboration. Model versions update frequently, and today’s conclusions may be invalid after the next update.
Therefore, readers should not rely on a single result but should re-test in the context of their own team’s scenarios. For firmware, driver, embedded, and low-level toolchain development, bare-metal tasks are an effective stress test; for ordinary business development, more day-to-day engineering tasks such as APIs, refactoring, and cross-file changes can be added. Only by fixing the test environment, prompt, parameters, and scoring criteria in place does model evaluation have real comparative value.
