LLM Math Proof Evaluation and Agent Quota Governance: An Engineering Practice

    This article explains how to evaluate large language models on mathematical proof tasks, route work across model tiers, and control quota use across hourly and weekly limits. It also covers how to monitor consumption so that teams can choose models based on real task pass rates and manage costs for multi-agent workflows.

    1. Problem Background: Turning Usage Experience into Engineering Problems

    When a team uses large language models for mathematical proofs, code review, small feature development, and technical documentation, the main tension is rarely whether a single answer looks impressive. The real issue is that capability tiers do not match resource quota governance. The experience reduces to three engineering problems. First, high-difficulty math proof tasks quickly consume high-value quota. Second, when agent collaboration lacks a routing strategy, rate limits from short-cycle and long-cycle windows compound, and the weekly budget runs out early. Third, during model selection, public leaderboard rankings are easily confused with pass rates on real tasks.

    A more reliable approach is to build a closed loop of capability evaluation, task routing, budget governance, and observability. Relying on a single subjective impression does not work.

    2. Capability Evaluation Methods for Math Proof Tasks

    1. Distinguish Retrieval-Based Recall from Independent Reasoning

    For propositions whose proofs already appear in public mathematical sources, a model may answer by reciting them. For propositions whose proofs are not given in the source material, ask the model to produce a complete proof and organize it as an English technical lecture note. This better reveals the model’s derivation chain, its handling of definitions and citations, and its treatment of boundary conditions. During evaluation, fix the problem set, label whether each problem has a public proof, and use blind human review to reduce prior bias.

    2. Establish Multi-Dimensional Metrics

    Evaluating proof tasks should not look only at the final conclusion. At minimum, cover these dimensions:

    • Correctness: whether the conclusion is right and whether key lemmas hold;
    • Completeness: whether assumptions, boundary conditions, and necessary lemmas are all stated;
    • Verifiability: whether each step can be checked in sequence, with no skipped steps or circular reasoning;
    • Readability: whether terminology is precise, the structure is clear, and the lecture note is easy to review;
    • Process controllability: whether the number of reasoning steps, the time taken, and the quota consumed fall within an acceptable range.

    3. Classify Failures and Iterate on Prompts

    Group failed cases into categories such as concept confusion, skipped steps, circular reasoning, citing inapplicable theorems, and formatting or expression errors. Track pass rates by category. This guides prompt templates, task decomposition, and model tier selection. A simple verdict that a given model is or is not good enough gives less useful guidance.

    3. Task Tiering and Agent Routing

    Tasks differ in how much reasoning depth and cost sensitivity they require. High-level math proofs need a high reasoning tier. Defect finding, code review, small incremental features, and document organization can use an economy tier or be handled by sub-agents. The key is to make routing rules explicit and versioned, so that not every session defaults to the highest tier.

    Example pseudocode:

    1. policy:
    2. task_class: math_proof
    3. max_tier: high_reasoning
    4. budget:
    5. hourly_quota_ratio: 0.30
    6. weekly_quota_ratio: 0.20
    7. fallback:
    8. - route_to: economy_code_agent
    9. when: quota_used_ratio > 0.80
    10. observability:
    11. metrics:
    12. - quota_used_ratio
    13. - task_latency
    14. - retry_count
    15. - failure_category

    In the agent configuration, define the division of labor clearly. The main agent handles planning and review, and sub-agents handle tasks that can be split off and executed independently. For example, defect finding, code review, and small feature implementation can move to the economy tier, so the main agent only handles steps that require strong reasoning. This preserves quality on complex tasks while lowering overall quota consumption.

    4. Quota and Rate-Limit Governance

    1. Make Dual-Window Budgets Explicit

    When hourly and weekly windows are combined, the team needs to convert the long-period budget into a usable amount for the short period and set thresholds. If the conversion between the long-period quota and the short-period window is not transparent, running long tasks continuously can hit the long-period limit within a short time. Estimate quota consumption before starting a task. Split long tasks into segments and save checkpoints.

    2. Prioritize and Queue Work

    Reserve budget for high-value proof tasks. Low-value tasks can be batched, delayed, or moved to the economy tier. For interruptible tasks, set a maximum retry count and a backoff strategy, so that retries do not further amplify consumption.

    3. Circuit Breaking, Degradation, and Observability

    When the used ratio exceeds a threshold, route work automatically to the economy tier or pause non-critical tasks. Record the task type, tier, consumption, latency, retry count, and failure reason for each call, and attribute them to projects. If the team uses Baidu AI Cloud, its general-purpose container platform, log service, and monitoring and alerting capabilities can be used to build a quota observability and alerting pipeline (subject to regional availability).

    Example budget control logic:

    1. def route(task, quota):
    2. if task.type == "math_proof" and quota.weekly_remaining > 0.40:
    3. return "high_reasoning_tier"
    4. if task.type in ("code_review", "small_feature", "doc_draft"):
    5. return "economy_tier"
    6. if quota.hourly_used > 0.80:
    7. return "queue_or_degrade"
    8. return "standard_tier"

    5. Engineering Rollout Checklist

    1. Build a baseline problem set: cover math propositions with and without published proofs, and fix the human review criteria;
    2. Version routing configuration: manage task types, tiers, and budget thresholds under configuration control;
    3. Set budget alerts: define multi-level thresholds for both the hourly and weekly windows;
    4. Split tasks and cache context: split long tasks, cache repeated context, and reduce wasted calls;
    5. Add an interface abstraction layer: avoid binding business code directly to one service form, which makes replacement and gradual rollout easier;
    6. Roll out gradually with rollback: validate new routing strategies with a small share of traffic first, then expand them step by step;
    7. Report costs by attribution: track consumption and output by project, task type, and agent role.

    6. Conclusion

    The value of LLMs in mathematical proof and agent collaboration cannot be judged by subjective experience or a single leaderboard. A more professional approach builds capability evaluation, task tiering, budget governance, and observability into one engineering loop. Use a fixed problem set to assess independent reasoning. Use routing policies to assign tasks to suitable tiers. Use dual-window budgets and circuit breaking to control costs. Use logs and monitoring alerts to keep calibrating the system. This approach gives teams a repeatable, auditable balance between output quality, stability, and cost.