AI Coding Agents: Process Constraints That Align Requirements Before Coding

    AI coding assistants often expand scope, make design choices that cannot be traced, and declare work complete without verification. This article describes a four-stage workflow of requirements clarification, design confirmation, step-by-step implementation, and verification with delivery. Confirmation gates between stages keep the work reviewable and reproducible. The article also includes a sample task specification template and a simple check that decides whether implementation can start.

    1. Problem Symptoms

    Many developers have run into a familiar situation. They ask an AI assistant to add a login endpoint, and it rewrites the entire authentication module. They ask about testing and get “it should be fine.” They ask why it made a change, and the explanation sounds reasonable but offers nothing that can be checked.

    These symptoms share a pattern. The task boundary is not yet defined, but coding has already started. The design has not been confirmed, yet the structure has already changed. Verification is incomplete, yet the result has already been declared. These problems mainly come from a workflow that lacks constraints.

    2. Root Cause Analysis

    Language models are good at generating coherent content from context. When a requirement is vague, the model fills the gaps with plausible assumptions and then acts on them directly. Unless the process explicitly requires it to stop and confirm, it will not do so on its own.

    The common risks fall into three categories.

    1. Uncontrolled scope: The change boundary is undefined, and modifications spread into unrelated modules. This increases review cost and regression risk.
    2. Untraceable decisions: Design choices are not recorded in writing. When questioned later, explanations are often generated on the spot and do not reflect the actual reasoning process.
    3. Missing verification: Completion criteria are not defined in advance, so “done” becomes a subjective judgment. Test results may be omitted or described vaguely.

    To address these three risks, the process should make hidden assumptions explicit, fix the deliverables of each stage, and set confirmation gates between stages.

    3. Four-Stage Workflow

    1. Requirements Clarification

    Before coding starts, the human and the AI together produce a short requirements specification with at least four items:

    • Goal: The specific problem this change solves.
    • Non-goals: What will explicitly not be done, to constrain the scope of changes.
    • Inputs and outputs: Interfaces, data formats, and external dependencies.
    • Acceptance criteria: Completion conditions that can be checked one by one.

    In this stage, the AI should raise questions proactively, for example, “Should the number of failed login attempts be limited?” or “Should the existing session mechanism be reused?” When something is uncertain, the AI should list the questions and wait for answers instead of choosing one option by default.

    2. Design and Confirmation

    Once the requirements are settled, produce an implementation plan. The plan should include the list of files involved, interface changes, data structure adjustments, potential risks, and alternatives with the reasons for each trade-off.

    The plan needs human confirmation before implementation begins. During review, focus on whether the plan goes beyond the non-goals and whether it introduces unnecessary refactoring.

    3. Step-by-Step Implementation

    Split the plan into small steps that can each be verified independently, with each step handling only one concern. After each step, record a rollback-friendly commit, which makes problems easier to locate.

    If implementation reveals a change that is not in the plan, stop coding and return to stage two to update the plan and get it confirmed again. This rule effectively prevents “opportunistic refactoring.”

    4. Verification and Delivery

    Before delivery, check each acceptance criterion one by one, and attach the test commands and their results. If an item cannot be verified, state the reason clearly. “It should be fine” cannot replace a verified conclusion.

    The delivery note should also list the files actually changed, so reviewers can confirm that the scope of changes matches the plan.

    4. Example: Task Specification Template

    The following is a specification for a login endpoint task. Teams can adjust the fields to fit their situation.

    1. # Task: Add User Login Endpoint
    2. ## Goal
    3. Provide a login endpoint based on username and password. On success, return an access token.
    4. ## Non-Goals
    5. - Do not modify the existing registration flow
    6. - Do not change the overall structure of the authentication middleware
    7. ## Interface Contract
    8. - Method and path: POST /api/login
    9. - Request body: username, password
    10. - Success: Return 200 with a token field
    11. - Failure: Return 401 with a standard error structure
    12. ## Acceptance Criteria
    13. - [ ] Valid credentials return 200 with a valid token
    14. - [ ] Invalid credentials return 401
    15. - [ ] Unit tests cover both paths above
    16. - [ ] Only files listed in the plan are changed

    Each item in the spec can be checked one by one. Reviewers do not need to guess the AI’s intent. They only need to check whether the actual result meets the agreed terms.

    In a workflow tool, the question “Can implementation start?” can also be written as simple decision logic, for example:

    1. def can_start_implementation(spec: dict, plan_approved: bool) -> bool:
    2. """Implementation may start only when all requirement fields are complete and the plan has been approved."""
    3. required_fields = ["goal", "non_goals", "acceptance_criteria"]
    4. if not all(spec.get(field) for field in required_fields):
    5. return False
    6. return plan_approved

    This kind of check requires no complex infrastructure, yet it turns process requirements into an enforceable gate.

    5. Rollout Recommendations

    1. Keep specification documents under version control and review them together with code, so requirement changes are recorded.
    2. Require explicit confirmation for changes outside the plan, so scope does not quietly expand during coding.
    3. During code review, check the verification records, not just the code diff.
    4. For small changes, the process can be simplified, but the requirements and acceptance criteria should always be kept.
    5. Adopt one shared checklist covering the requirements, design, implementation, and verification stages to reduce variation from individual habits.

    6. Summary

    The efficiency gains from AI-assisted development depend on how controllable the process is. Fixing requirements, plans, and verification results as written deliverables, and placing confirmation gates between stages, makes the AI’s work easier to review and easier to reproduce. Process constraints do not limit what the AI can do. They let people judge whether each step can be trusted.