LLM Capability Evaluation and Quota Management for AI Coding Tasks

    This article presents reusable methods for evaluating large language models on mathematical reasoning and for planning AI coding tasks under multi-window usage quotas. It covers difficulty tiers, measurable evaluation metrics, stability testing, consumption estimation, budget controls, and tiered multi-model collaboration, helping teams make more reliable model comparisons and allocate limited quota more effectively.

    1. Problem Background

    When a development team uses multiple large language models at the same time, two common problems tend to appear. The first is capability judgment. Different models perform very differently on mathematical reasoning, code understanding, and long-form writing, and a few trial runs are rarely enough to reach a reliable conclusion. The second is resource management. Paid plans often define multiple usage windows, with short-cycle and long-cycle windows active at the same time. Poor task scheduling can exhaust quota early and disrupt later work.

    This article does not evaluate any specific product. Instead, it breaks these two problems into reusable methods: how to design evaluations, how to interpret results, how to estimate consumption, and how to allocate tasks.

    2. Evaluation Methods for LLM Mathematical Reasoning

    2.1 Distinguish Problem Difficulty Levels

    Mathematical problems vary widely in difficulty. Evaluation results are meaningful only when compared within the same difficulty tier. A common way to separate tiers is as follows:

    • Foundation tier: textbook exercises with unique answers that can be verified quickly at scale;
    • Competition tier: public competition problems that require longer reasoning chains;
    • Research tier: open problems without an accepted solution, where the evaluation target is the soundness of the reasoning process rather than a standard answer.

    Treating results on research-tier problems as direct proof of model capability is a common mistake. Answers to open problems often require manual verification, and verification is costly. Some arguments may appear rigorous while containing flaws.

    2.2 Choose Quantifiable Metrics

    At minimum, record the following four metrics:

    1. Final answer accuracy: measured on a fixed problem set. Problems should be frozen in advance to avoid post hoc selection;
    2. Verifiability of reasoning steps: whether each step can be checked independently, and whether there are skipped steps or circular arguments;
    3. Proof completeness: whether boundary cases, counterexamples, and preconditions are all addressed;
    4. Stability: the degree to which repeated runs on the same problem produce consistent results.

    Stability is often overlooked. A model that occasionally gives the correct answer does not necessarily have reliable reasoning capability. Run each problem at least three to five times and analyze the distribution of results.

    2.3 Chain-of-Thought Length Is Not Reasoning Quality

    A longer chain of thought may mean the model is trying repeatedly, or it may mean the model is examining the problem more deeply. Length alone cannot determine which is better. A more reasonable approach is to calculate accuracy under the average output length per problem as an efficiency metric, while also recording output token counts and latency so that reasoning cost is included in the comparison.

    2.4 Evaluate Expression Style Separately from Reasoning Ability

    A fluent and clearly structured answer only shows strong language expression. When evaluating mathematical ability, ignore the impression created by language polishing and focus only on whether conclusions are correct and arguments are rigorous. Blind review can be used, with reviewers who do not know the model source, to reduce subjective bias.

    2.5 Sample Size and the Limits of Subjective Experience

    Personal experience is only a single sample. Forming a stable judgment requires a fixed evaluation set, a fixed prompt template, and a fixed scoring standard, with regular retesting. Model versions update frequently, so conclusions also have a limited shelf life.

    Below is a simplified evaluation workflow:

    1. from statistics import mean
    2. def evaluate_model(model_call, problems, runs=3):
    3. """Call the model multiple times on the same problem set and measure accuracy and stability."""
    4. results = []
    5. for problem in problems:
    6. answers = []
    7. for _ in range(runs):
    8. output = model_call(problem["prompt"])
    9. answers.append(problem["checker"](output)) # Returns True or False
    10. results.append({
    11. "id": problem["id"],
    12. "accuracy": mean(answers), # Average accuracy for this problem
    13. "consistent": len(set(answers)) == 1 # Whether repeated results are consistent
    14. })
    15. overall = mean(r["accuracy"] for r in results)
    16. stability = mean(1.0 if r["consistent"] else 0.0 for r in results)
    17. return {"accuracy": overall, "stability": stability, "details": results}

    The checker needs to be written according to the problem type. Numeric problems compare final results, while proof problems require manual review or auxiliary tools for verification.

    3. Understanding and Estimating Usage Quotas

    3.1 The Combined Effect of Multiple Quota Windows

    Many services impose usage limits across multiple time windows at the same time, such as a short window of several hours and a long window of one week. The windows are independent, and exhaustion of any one of them blocks subsequent requests. Therefore, looking only at the remaining ratio of the long window can be misleading. The short window may already be exhausted while the long window still shows substantial remaining capacity.

    An effective approach is to record used amount, remaining amount, and reset time separately for each window, and use the tightest window as the basis for scheduling.

    3.2 Estimate Consumption per Task

    Task consumption is mainly affected by the following factors:

    • Number of sessions: the more parallel sessions, the faster consumption occurs per unit of time;
    • Reasoning intensity level: a higher level usually means longer internal reasoning and higher consumption;
    • Context length: when reading a large codebase, the input portion consumes a large amount of quota;
    • Subtask splitting: split subtasks each generate calls, and the total often exceeds expectations.

    Before formal batch execution, run one or two representative tasks first, record the actual consumption of each task, and use that to estimate the overall budget.

    3.3 Three Lines of Defense for Budget Control

    1. Pre-check: estimate consumption before a task starts, and queue tasks that exceed remaining quota;
    2. In-progress alerts: notify at 70 percent and 90 percent of a window’s consumption;
    3. Post-review: calculate unit consumption by task type each week and refine the estimation basis.

    4. Division of Work in Multi-Model Collaboration

    4.1 Layer by Task Complexity

    Not every task requires the highest-tier model. Tasks can be roughly divided into three categories by complexity:

    • Low complexity: format checks, simple lookups, and log cleanup, suitable for the economy tier;
    • Medium complexity: local code review, small feature implementation, and unit test completion, suitable for the standard tier;
    • High complexity: cross-module design, root cause analysis of difficult defects, and algorithm derivation, suitable for the high tier.

    The purpose of this layering is to reserve high-tier quota for the steps that truly need it.

    4.2 Define Division Rules in Project Documentation

    Writing division rules into a project’s documentation file keeps all collaborators and tools consistent. Rules should be specific. For example, “prioritize the economy tier for defect finding and code review, and escalate only when results are doubtful” is easier to execute than “save as much as possible.”

    4.3 Set Fallbacks and Human Review

    Conclusions produced by lower tiers need verification. Key conclusions should be confirmed through test cases, static checks, or human review before being merged into the main branch.

    4.4 Quota-Aware Task Routing Example

    1. from dataclasses import dataclass
    2. @dataclass
    3. class QuotaWindow:
    4. name: str
    5. limit: int
    6. used: int
    7. def remaining_ratio(self) -> float:
    8. return max(0.0, 1 - self.used / self.limit)
    9. def choose_tier(complexity: int, windows: list[QuotaWindow]) -> str:
    10. """complexity ranges from 1 to 5; returns the recommended tier."""
    11. tightest = min(w.remaining_ratio() for w in windows)
    12. if tightest < 0.05:
    13. return "defer" # Any window is near exhaustion; defer the task
    14. if complexity >= 4 and tightest > 0.4:
    15. return "high"
    16. if complexity >= 2:
    17. return "standard"
    18. return "economy"