How to Choose an AI Coding Tool: A Reproducible Comparison Using the Same Demo
A practical framework for evaluating AI coding tools through IDE integration, task execution modes, code quality, engineering practices, multi-agent collaboration, and a shared e-commerce demo. The article also explains how to standardize test conditions and record measurable results without relying on unsupported rankings or marketing claims.
1. Why AI Coding Tools Need to Be Re-evaluated
AI coding tools designed for overseas markets may present practical constraints around access stability, data compliance, and support for Chinese-language workflows. Local development teams therefore need to determine whether domestic tools can support their daily engineering work. However, products can differ significantly in their underlying models, task scheduling, interaction patterns, and engineering output. The same marketing material may correspond to very different user experiences.
Before selecting a tool, it is more reliable to standardize the evaluation method than to compare feature lists alone.
How should teams choose a domestic AI coding tool? How do these tools differ from overseas alternatives? What should developers consider when building an e-commerce site? The answers depend on the specific project. This article presents a reproducible evaluation framework that can be used to compare tools with the same small demo.
2. Four Core Evaluation Dimensions
1. IDE Integration and Ease of Use
AI coding tools generally fall into two categories.
Plugin-based tools are installed in existing editors such as VS Code. They are suitable for existing projects and have a lower migration cost. Standalone IDEs include a terminal, debugger, and version-control features. They are better suited to new projects built from scratch, but they consume more system resources and require teams to adopt a common editor workflow.
The following items should be checked:
- Whether the tool can open an existing project directory directly and recognize its dependencies.
- The compatibility range between the plugin and its host editor.
- Startup time and memory usage. Record both cold-start and warm-start performance, and document the test machine configuration.
- Whether interface animations or anthropomorphic elements can be disabled.
Network dependency also requires hands-on testing. A domestic service may be accessible without a proxy, but latency can still vary depending on the network provider, model-service load, and concurrency. This article does not provide fixed millisecond values.
Testing should be performed in the target network environment. During the same time period, send at least 30 similar requests continuously, then record the P50 and P95 time to first byte and total completion time. The test period should also be documented.
2. Task Execution Modes
Early AI coding tools often used a fully automated workflow: the user provided a complex requirement, and the tool generated the entire codebase in one pass. This approach can be fast for simple tasks, but errors can spread when the system misunderstands a complex business requirement. It is also difficult for users to intervene during execution.
Two collaborative modes are now common:
- Craft mode, or step-by-step construction: The tool first creates the project structure, then implements the pages, and finally integrates the APIs. It waits for user confirmation after each stage. The risk of each individual step is lower, but the waiting time increases when there are many stages.
- Builder mode, or modular development: The tool generates modules such as authentication, shopping cart, and orders separately. Users can modify one module before continuing. This provides stronger control, but splitting tasks too finely can increase the number of confirmation cycles.
The execution mode should match the complexity of the task. Fully automated generation may be acceptable for simple scripts or prototypes, while multi-page business systems are generally better suited to step-by-step or modular workflows.
3. Code Quality and Engineering Practices
The maintenance cost of AI-generated code depends heavily on its project structure. The following checks can be used directly for acceptance testing:
- Directory structure: Does the tool create directories such as
components,pages,utils, andservices? Are business logic and data requests separated? - Mock data: Is mock data placed in an independent module, or can the project switch to real APIs through environment variables?
- Style isolation: Are CSS Modules or another isolation strategy used correctly? Do global styles rely on consistent theme variables?
- Forms and error handling: Are required fields, email formats, and password-strength rules validated? Do asynchronous requests include loading, failure, and empty-data states?
- Dependency declarations: Is
package.jsoncomplete? Is a lockfile generated? Can the project run immediately after installation? - Error boundaries: Is there a fallback component for page-level exceptions?
The project scaffold should also be documented. Create React App is no longer maintained, so new projects should use templates that are still maintained, such as Vite. Regardless of the selected scaffold, the evaluation record should include its name and version.
4. Multi-Agent Collaboration and Context Memory
Some tools allow multiple agents to process different subtasks in parallel. For example, one agent may handle routing, another state management, and another styling. Parallel execution can reduce total time, but it also increases coordination costs.
The following areas should be checked:
- Does the task-assignment panel show each agent’s scope of responsibility and allow manual reassignment?
- When multiple agents modify the same file, does the tool provide file locking or conflict warnings?
- What is the rollback granularity? Can users return to a specific output from a specific agent, or only to a point in the overall session?
- How does failure retry work? When an individual agent fails repeatedly, is there a retry limit, and is the user prompted to intervene?
3. A Reproducible Evaluation Using the Same E-Commerce Demo
To compare different tools, the requirements must remain consistent. The demo used in this evaluation includes five categories of pages:
- Product details
- Purchase confirmation
- Purchase success
- Login and registration
- User center
The user center includes a dashboard, orders, wallet and coupons, and settings. The demo must support a complete shopping flow and basic form validation. It must also adapt to both mobile and desktop viewports: 375 × 667 and 1440 × 900.
1. Fixed Conditions Before Testing
Before testing each tool, record the following:
- Operating system and version, Node.js version, package manager, and package-manager version. The current LTS version of Node.js is recommended.
- Tool name, version, and test date.
- Selected model, if the tool supports model switching.
- Network environment and test period.
Use exactly the same requirement text for every tool. Do not provide additional explanations during testing.
2. Metrics to Record
- Whether the project compiles after the first generation, along with the number of compilation errors.
- The number of runtime errors, including missing imports, class-name conflicts, and null-value access.
- The number of manual fixes. For each fix, record how many files were changed.
- Total time from submitting the requirements to making the pages accessible. Record tool waiting time and manual-fix time separately.
- Screenshots at both mobile and desktop viewport sizes, with overflow, overlapping elements, and color-contrast problems identified.
A sample record is shown below:
| Tool | Version | First Compilation | Runtime Errors | Fixes | Total Time (minutes) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candidate Tool 1 | To be filled | To be filled | To be filled | To be filled | To be filled | To be filled |
All figures in the table must come from the current test. Results from other evaluations should not be used.
3. Observations from One Trial
During one trial, the author observed three typical categories of problems. These observations are provided only to illustrate what should be checked. They do not establish a ranking and do not represent the overall quality of any product.
The first category was insufficient information density. Some tools generated product-detail pages containing only image placeholders and brief descriptions, without specification fields or review sections. Acceptance testing should verify whether the page includes actual data fields.
The second category was visual and responsive-design defects. Some tools generated white button text on a white background, while some list pages displayed horizontal overflow on narrow screens.
